Feedback control of morphogen gradient scale

Yilun Zhu, Yuchi Qiu, Weitao Chen, Qing Nie, Arthur D. LanderbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the prevailing "expander" model for morphogen gradient scaling in developing tissues. Instead, it proposes a new model where scaling is driven by feedback-driven downregulation of Dpp receptors and co-receptors, which ultimately limits the scaling process to a specific size. This finding offers a more nuanced understanding of how developing organisms achieve precise patterning despite significant growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing organisms grow substantially, yet their tissues maintain precise spatial patterns. This requires morphogen gradients, which convey positional information, to scale proportionally with the tissue size. The prevailing model for this "morphogen gradient scaling" involved a secreted "expander" molecule that diffused to spread the gradient. This paper investigates the role of the protein Pentagone (Pent) in Drosophila wing disc development, a candidate for such an expander. The authors question whether Pent truly possesses the necessary properties to act as a global expander and propose an alternative mechanism for scaling.

Methods

The study employed a combination of genetic manipulation, live imaging, and mathematical modeling. Key techniques included:

  • Genetic manipulation: Knockdown and overexpression of genes (Pent, sfl-RNAi, tkv-RNAi) in specific domains of the wing disc using Gal4/UAS systems.
  • Immunostaining: Using antibodies to visualize key proteins like phosphorylated Mad (pMad), a readout of Dpp signaling activity, as well as markers for cell boundaries (Ptc, Wg) and co-receptors (Dlp).
  • Confocal microscopy: Imaging wing discs to quantify protein distribution and gradient shapes.
  • Mathematical modeling: Developing a computational model to simulate Dpp gradient dynamics and test hypotheses about scaling mechanisms.
  • Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and cross-correlation raster scanning intensity correlation microscopy (ccRICS): Used to assess diffusion and potential interactions of molecules.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on experimental data generated from live imaging and immunostaining of Drosophila melanogaster wing discs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pent's limited range undermines the "expander" model: Contrary to expectations, Pent's influence on the Dpp gradient is highly localized, decaying within a few cell diameters. This suggests it cannot act as a global expander.
  • Feedback on receptors is key: The authors propose that scaling is driven by feedback loops where Dpp signaling leads to the downregulation of its own receptors (Tkv) and co-receptors (like Dally and Dlp).
  • Scaling has a size limit: The proposed feedback mechanism naturally imposes a limit on scaling, which the authors observe experimentally. This suggests that scaling isn't an indefinite process but rather a transient phenomenon tied to developmental stage.
  • "Pseudo-source-sink" scaling: The model suggests a transition from initial source-sink scaling to a "pseudo-source-sink" mechanism as discs grow. This involves the downregulation of receptors creating a "sink" effect further away from the source, even without a physical boundary.
  • Growth and patterning are coupled: The size limitation of scaling and its potential role in terminating growth suggest a tight coupling between tissue growth and pattern formation.

Key Results

  • Knocking down Pent in specific compartments of the wing disc only affected the Dpp gradient in those compartments, indicating Pent's local action.
  • Overexpression of Pent phenocopied the effects of disabling co-receptors (Dally, Dlp) within the Pent expression domain, further supporting its local action.
  • Mathematical modeling accurately reproduced experimental observations for various genotypes, supporting the feedback-driven receptor downregulation model.
  • The model predicted, and experiments confirmed, that scaling fails beyond a certain disc size (around 50-60 µm for posterior compartment size).
  • Disabling feedback loops (by bypassing Tkv or Dally regulation) significantly impaired scaling, with complete bypass leading to near-elimination of scaling.
  • Pent mutants showed impaired scaling, but the mechanism was distinct from feedback loop bypass, suggesting Pent acts on initial conditions rather than the scaling process itself.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pent's precise role remains somewhat enigmatic: While the paper demonstrates Pent's limited range and its effects can be mimicked by local co-receptor manipulation, the exact reason for its necessity in wing disc development, beyond its effect on Dpp gradient scaling, is still unclear. The authors speculate about independent functions, such as its role in vein formation.
  • Model simplification: The mathematical model, while powerful, necessarily simplifies complex biological processes. Further refinement could incorporate more detailed molecular interactions.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest exploring the implications of size-limited scaling for terminating growth, given the known coupling between Dpp signaling and disc growth. Investigating the precise mechanisms by which Pent participates in wing disc development beyond its role in gradient scaling is also a promising avenue. The parallels with early vertebrate embryo patterning also warrant further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

SUMMARY Gradients of the morphogen decapentaplegic (Dpp) pattern Drosophila wing imaginal discs, establishing gene expression boundaries at specific locations. As discs grow, Dpp gradients expand, keeping relative boundary positions approximately stationary. Such scaling fails in mutants for Pentagone ( pent ), a gene repressed by Dpp that encodes a diffusible protein that expands Dpp gradients. Although these properties fit a recent mathematical model of automatic gradient scaling, we show here that Pent lacks a property essential to that model—the ability to spread with minimal loss throughout the morphogen field. Instead, Pent’s actions appear confined to within a few cell diameters of its site of synthesis, and can be phenocopied by manipulating non-diffusible targets of Pent strictly within the Pent expression domain. Through genetic manipulation and mathematical modeling we develop an alternative model of scaling, driven by feedback down-regulation of Dpp receptors and co-receptors. Among the model’s predictions is a size limit beyond which scaling fails—something we observe directly in wing discs.
BibTeX
@misc{zhu2019feedback,
  author = {Yilun Zhu and Yuchi Qiu and Weitao Chen and Qing Nie and Arthur D. Lander},
  title = {{Feedback control of morphogen gradient scale}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/824292},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure