TL;DR
This paper introduces FedCDI, a novel federated causal discovery framework that leverages interventional data to learn causal structures from distributed, privacy-sensitive datasets. FedCDI addresses the limitations of existing federated methods by enabling the integration of interventional data, leading to more accurate and identifiable causal models, even with heterogeneous data distributions across clients.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Discovering causal relationships is crucial for understanding complex systems and making informed decisions, especially in domains like healthcare where data is sensitive and distributed. Traditional causal discovery methods often require centralized data, which is a privacy concern. Federated causal discovery (FCD) aims to address this by learning from decentralized data without direct access to raw samples. However, existing FCD methods are largely limited to observational data and linear models, which can lead to ambiguity (Markov equivalence classes) and higher model uncertainty. Interventional data, collected through targeted perturbations, can significantly improve causal structure identifiability. This paper tackles the challenge of effectively integrating interventional data into a federated learning framework for causal discovery, a gap that has been largely unexplored.
Methods
The core of FedCDI is a two-phase iterative process:
- Local Discovery: Each client uses a local causal discovery method (LCDM) to infer a belief about the causal structure from its local data. The paper suggests using ENCO (Efficient Neural Causal Discovery) as a suitable LCDM due to its scalability and ability to handle interventional data. Crucially, clients incorporate a "prior belief" (from the server's aggregated knowledge) into their local optimization, guiding their learning process, especially when their local data is uncertain.
- Global Aggregation: A central server aggregates the "belief updates" (not raw data) from clients. The key innovation here is the proximity-based belief aggregation method. This method intelligently weights clients' contributions based on the quality and relevance of their interventional samples. Specifically, it considers how interventions performed by a client relate to the edges being inferred, giving more weight to clients whose interventions directly impact the causal relationships under consideration. This approach is designed to handle scenarios where clients have access to different sets of intervened covariates (vertical data distribution).
Datasets
The paper uses both synthetic and real-world graphs for evaluation.
- Synthetic Data: Generated using the random Erdős–Rényi (ER) model for DAGs of size d=20, with varying numbers of edges (ER-n graphs). Data generation for variables uses MLPs with categorical inputs.
- Real-world Graphs: Utilizes graphs from the
bnlearnpackage, specifically Sachs, Alarm, and Asia.
The paper notes that for real-world causal discovery datasets, the required interventional samples are often lacking, necessitating the generation of synthetic data for experiments, similar to prior work.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Interventional Data is Key for Federated Causal Discovery: The paper strongly advocates for the use of interventional data in FCD, showing it significantly improves identifiability and reduces uncertainty compared to observational-only methods.
- Proximity-Based Aggregation is Crucial for Heterogeneous Interventions: The proposed proximity-based aggregation method is a significant advancement, allowing FedCDI to effectively leverage interventional data even when clients have access to different sets of intervened variables. This is a critical step towards real-world applicability.
- Federated Learning Enhances Privacy Without Sacrificing Performance: FedCDI demonstrates that it's possible to achieve performance comparable to centralized methods while maintaining strong privacy guarantees by exchanging belief updates instead of raw data.
- Clients' Contributions are Weighted by Intervention Relevance: The intelligent weighting scheme ensures that clients with more informative interventions have a greater influence on the global causal structure, leading to more robust discoveries.
Key Results
- FedCDI consistently outperforms federated methods that rely solely on observational data.
- The proximity-based aggregation method significantly outperforms naive averaging when dealing with vertically distributed interventional data.
- FedCDI achieves performance comparable to centralized approaches, even when clients have access to only a fraction of the data.
- The method demonstrates scalability with an increasing number of clients and interventional samples. For instance, in Figure 2, FedCDI's performance closely tracks the centralized approach. Table 1 shows FedCDI (2-clients) achieving SHD scores as low as 2.6±0.6 for ER-1, outperforming other federated baselines.
Limitations and Future Work
- Real-world Data Scarcity: A major limitation is the lack of real-world datasets with sufficient interventional samples for federated causal discovery. The paper relies on generating synthetic data for most experiments.
- Client Data Threshold: If a client's local dataset falls below a certain threshold, the resulting DAG becomes highly inaccurate. The paper suggests future work to propose a generic method for determining this threshold.
- Computational Complexity: While parallelization helps, some LCDMs (like SDI) can be computationally demanding, limiting the scale of experiments.
- Acyclicity Guarantee: Ensuring the final aggregated adjacency matrix strictly represents a DAG might require additional constraints or post-processing steps. Future work could integrate acyclicity constraints directly into the aggregation process.
Summary updated