FEcMD: A multi-physics and multi-scale computational program for electron emission characteristics dynamically coupled with atomic structure in metal nano-emitters

Nan Li, Xinyu Gao, Xianghui Feng, Kai Wu, Yonghong Cheng, Bing XiaoarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Field emission coupled with molecular dynamics simulation (FEcMD) software package is a computational tool for studying the electron emission characteristics and the atomic structure evolution of micro- and nano-protrusions made of pure metals or multi-component alloys by means of multi-physics and multi-scale methodology. The implementations of molecular dynamics, the electrodynamics, and the heat conduction in FEcMD program are addressed. For molecular dynamics simulation, the Lennard-Jones potentials, embedded atomic method (EAM), and moment tensor potentials (MTP) are fully supported for both alloys and pure metals. In the electrodynamics, the FEcMD program incorporates the space charge fields (space charge potential and exchange-correlation effects) in the Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin-Jeffreys (WKBJ) approximation to evaluate the field emission current density more reliably for nano-gaps between two metal electrodes. Additionally, the advanced two-temperature heat conduction model is implemented in FEcMD program, and which provides more reliable descriptions for the temperature evolutions of electron and phonon subsystems under the radiofrequency (RF) or pulse electric fields. Comprehensive benchmark tests are performed for each module in FEcMD software to validate the numerical results, and also to access the accuracy and efficiency of the implemented algorithms. Finally, some typical applications of FEcMD program are also demonstrated for understanding the evolution of temperature and electric field coupled with the dynamic changing of atomic structures for metal micro- and nano-protrusions.

Introduction

In high-voltage environments—like those found in X-ray tubes, particle accelerators, or fusion reactors—metal surfaces can develop microscopic "protrusions." Under high electric fields, these tiny tips emit electrons via a process called field emission. This emission generates intense heat, which can cause the tip to deform, melt, or even evaporate, eventually triggering a catastrophic "vacuum arc" or electrical breakdown.

The challenge for researchers is that this is a multi-physics, multi-scale phenomenon. It requires tracking individual atoms (molecular dynamics), solving complex electromagnetic equations (electrodynamics), and modeling heat flow (thermodynamics) simultaneously. Existing tools often oversimplify the physics, such as assuming the electrons and the metal lattice are at the same temperature or ignoring quantum "space charge" effects where emitted electrons repel each other. FEcMD was built to fill these gaps.

The FEcMD Framework

The FEcMD (Field Emission coupled Molecular Dynamics) program is built on a C++ framework that coordinates four primary modules to simulate the dynamic evolution of metal nano-emitters.

Schematic of the dynamic coupling between the MD, AF, MESH, HC, and ED modules in FEcMD.

As shown in the figure above, the system relies on the tight coupling of several specialized modules:

  1. Molecular Dynamics (MD): Tracks atomic positions and coordinates. It uniquely supports Moment Tensor Potentials (MTP)—a type of machine learning potential that allows for the high-accuracy simulation of complex alloys (like Tungsten-Molybdenum) which were previously too difficult to model with standard methods.
  2. Electrodynamics (ED): Solves the Poisson equation using the Finite Element Method (FEM). It uses a Particle-in-Cell (PIC) approach to track emitted electrons and accounts for the Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin-Jeffreys (WKBJ) approximation to calculate current density.
  3. Heat Conduction (HC): Implements a Two-Temperature Model (TTM). This treats the "electron gas" and the "atomic lattice (phonons)" as two separate but coupled systems. This is crucial for high-frequency (RF) or pulsed fields where electrons can heat up much faster than the atoms can vibrate.
  4. Mesh Generation: Dynamically updates a finite element mesh as the nanotip changes shape, ensuring the physics calculations remain accurate even as the metal melts or stretches.

Key Insights and Results

FEcMD provides a more nuanced look at the "thermal runaway" processes that lead to vacuum breakdown. Key findings from the initial benchmarks include:

  • The Temperature Gap: One of the most striking insights is the "decoupling" of temperatures. In the first few picoseconds of a high-field pulse, the electron temperature at the tip can skyrocket to 2500K while the atomic lattice remains relatively cool. Ignoring this leads to massive errors in predicting when a device will fail.
  • Quantum Crowding: In nano-gaps, the density of emitted electrons is so high that they create a "space charge" that repels subsequent electrons. FEcMD shows that including exchange-correlation effects (a quantum mechanical interaction) actually lowers the energy barrier for emission, accelerating the path to thermal runaway.
  • Alloy Stability: The program successfully modeled how W-Mo alloys form protrusions. Interestingly, the simulation showed that the alloy evaporates "congruently"—meaning the mixture of metals stays consistent even as it turns into a gas, which is vital for maintaining electrode performance.

Conclusion

FEcMD represents a significant step forward in the simulation of nano-scale electronics and high-gradient physics. While currently limited to single-node multi-threading, the software's modular architecture and support for machine learning potentials offer a robust platform for future development. FEcMD is currently available as an open-source tool on GitHub, inviting the community to help refine the "digital twin" of the vacuum breakdown process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Field emission coupled with molecular dynamics simulation (FEcMD) software package is a computational tool for studying the electron emission characteristics and the atomic structure evolution of micro- and nano-protrusions made of pure metals or multi-component alloys by means of multi-physics and multi-scale methodology. The implementations of molecular dynamics, the electrodynamics, and the heat conduction in FEcMD program are addressed. For molecular dynamics simulation, the Lennard-Jones potentials, embedded atomic method (EAM), and moment tensor potentials (MTP) are fully supported for both alloys and pure metals. In the electrodynamics, the FEcMD program incorporates the space charge fields (space charge potential and exchange-correlation effects) in the Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin-Jeffreys (WKBJ) approximation to evaluate the field emission current density more reliably for nano-gaps between two metal electrodes. Additionally, the advanced two-temperature heat conduction model is implemented in FEcMD program, and which provides more reliable descriptions for the temperature evolutions of electron and phonon subsystems under the radiofrequency (RF) or pulse electric fields. Comprehensive benchmark tests are performed for each module in FEcMD software to validate the numerical results, and also to access the accuracy and efficiency of the implemented algorithms. Finally, some typical applications of FEcMD program are also demonstrated for understanding the evolution of temperature and electric field coupled with the dynamic changing of atomic structures for metal micro- and nano-protrusions.
BibTeX
@misc{li2023fecmd,
  author = {Nan Li and Xinyu Gao and Xianghui Feng and Kai Wu and Yonghong Cheng and Bing Xiao},
  title = {{FEcMD: A multi-physics and multi-scale computational program for electron emission characteristics dynamically coupled with atomic structure in metal nano-emitters}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2310.04751},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.04751},
}
Figure