Features of Roof Rainwater Runoff Pollution in a Northern Coastal City under the Effects of Multiple Factors

Lingling Zhang, Wenping Liu, Bin Zheng, Ao Xu, Baode SunInternational Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how air pollution, season, rainfall intensity, and antecedent dry periods affect the quality of roof rainwater runoff in Yantai, China. The findings highlight that season is the most significant factor, with autumn yielding the cleanest runoff, and reveal distinct "washing" phases during rainfall events, crucial for designing effective rainwater harvesting systems in coastal cities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rainwater is a valuable resource, especially in water-scarce regions like Yantai, China. While rainwater harvesting is encouraged, the quality of runoff from urban roofs can be compromised by various environmental factors, making it unsuitable for direct use without treatment. Previous research has explored roof runoff pollution, but there's a need for region-specific characterization, particularly for northern coastal cities, which have unique environmental conditions. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing the complex interplay of factors influencing roof rainwater runoff quality in Yantai, providing crucial data for optimizing rainwater utilization and purification strategies in such environments.

Methods

The researchers employed a controlled experimental approach, collecting rainwater samples from an inclined tile roof (a common roofing type in Yantai) over 12 natural rainfall events between March and November 2018. They monitored key water quality parameters: chemical oxygen demand (COD), suspended solids (SS), ammonia nitrogen (NH4-N), turbidity, total nitrogen (TN), and pH. To understand the influence of different factors, they used a control variates method, isolating the effects of air pollution, season, rainfall intensity, and antecedent dry period. Pollutant concentration curves were plotted against rainfall duration, and statistical analysis was used to identify trends and correlations.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 12 natural rainfall events in Yantai, China, during 2018. Specific details on the collected samples, including rainfall amount, intensity, antecedent dry period, and the number of samples taken per event, are provided in Table 1. Additionally, monthly air quality data for Yantai in 2018 was used to correlate with rainwater quality.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Season Reigns Supreme: Season emerged as the most dominant factor influencing roof rainwater quality, with autumn runoff being significantly cleaner than spring or summer. This underscores the importance of considering seasonal variations in any rainwater management plan.
  • Air Pollution's Indirect Role: While air pollution directly impacts natural rainfall quality, its influence on roof runoff is more indirect. The study found that higher cumulative rainfall correlated with lower air pollutant content, suggesting that rain itself can help cleanse the atmosphere.
  • The "Washing" Effect is Key: Roof runoff exhibits a distinct "initial washing" effect, where pollutant concentrations are highest at the beginning of a rainfall event. This is followed by a "secondary washing" effect, causing a rebound in pollutant levels during later stages. Understanding these phases is critical for effective collection and treatment.
  • Antecedent Dry Period Matters (Up to a Point): Longer dry periods lead to higher initial pollutant concentrations on the roof. However, the impact plateaus after about 10 days, suggesting a saturation point for pollutant accumulation.
  • Rainfall Intensity as a Cleanser: Higher rainfall intensity generally leads to a faster and deeper decline in pollutant concentrations during the initial washing phase, resulting in cleaner runoff.

Key Results

  • Roof runoff rainwater was found to be significantly more polluted than natural rainfall, indicating that roof surfaces are the primary source of pollutants.
  • In autumn, roof rainwater quality was best, followed by spring, and then summer.
  • During the initial 10-20 minutes of rainfall, pollutant concentrations decreased rapidly, with the rate of decrease accelerating with increasing rainfall intensity.
  • The antecedent dry period significantly impacted initial pollutant levels, with the highest increments observed after a 10-day dry spell.
  • The pollutant content in roof runoff followed a pattern of sudden change, transition, and stable phases, with the duration of these phases influenced by rainfall intensity.
  • The initial runoff (first 10-20 minutes) often exceeded water quality standards for domestic use, suggesting it should be discarded.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that the findings are specific to an inclined tile roof in Yantai and may not be directly generalizable to other roofing materials or urban environments. Future work could expand to investigate different roofing materials and their impact on runoff quality. Additionally, while the study identifies the phases of runoff pollution, further research could delve deeper into the mechanisms behind the "secondary washing effect" and the rebound of pollutant concentrations in the transition and stable phases. The authors suggest that their findings provide a valuable reference for designing efficient rainwater purification facilities in northern coastal cities.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper attempts to disclose the features of roof rainwater runoff pollution under the effects of air pollution, season, rainfall intensity, and antecedent dry period. Targeting an inclined tile roof in Yantai, China, this paper samples rainwater multiple times from March to November, 2018. The quality of roof rainwater samples in 12 representative natural rainfalls was monitored, and the curves of the main pollutants in these samples were plotted. On this basis, the authors analyzed the change features and outflow laws of the main pollution indices of roof runoff rainwater under the effects of different factors. The results show that: The degree of air pollution directly bears on rainwater quality. The rainfall also has a certain impact on air pollution indices. Season is the leading influencing factor of the quality of roof runoff rainwater. The best rainwater quality was observed in autumn, followed by that in spring and then that in summer. In the first 10-20min of each rainfall, the pollutant contents decreased at a growing rate with the increase of rainfall intensity. The increments of the initial pollutant contents reached the maximum at the antecedent dry period of 10d. The changes of all pollution indices of roof runoff rainwater could be divided into the sudden change phase, the transition phase, and the stable phase. Roof rainwater runoff has an obvious initial washing effect, and exerts a secondary washing effect. The research results provide a good reference for northern coastal cities to rationalize the parameters of rainwater purification facilities.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2020features,
  author = {Lingling Zhang and Wenping Liu and Bin Zheng and Ao Xu and Baode Sun},
  title = {{Features of Roof Rainwater Runoff Pollution in a Northern Coastal City under the Effects of Multiple Factors}},
  journal = {International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.18280/ijsdp.150403},
}
Figure