FEASTS Combined with Interferometry (IV): Mapping HI Emission to a limit of $N_{\text{HI}}=10^{17.7} \text{cm}^{-2}$ in Seven Edge-on Galaxies

Dong Yang, Jing Wang, Zhijie Qu, Ze-Zhong Liang, Xuchen Lin, Simon Weng, Xinkai Chen, Barbara Catinella, L. Cortese, David B. Fisher, Luis C. Ho, Yingjie Jing, Fangzhou Jiang, Peng Jiang, Ziming Liu, Céline Péroux, Shao Li, L. Staveley‐Smith, Q. Daniel Wang, Jie WangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, part of the FEASTS (FAST Extended Atlas of Selected Targets Survey) series, utilizes the unprecedented sensitivity of the Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST) to map the "missing" neutral hydrogen (HI) surrounding galaxies. By focusing on seven edge-on galaxies, the researchers successfully separated the diffuse, extraplanar gas from the dense galactic disks, revealing that this extended gas is ubiquitous, accounts for up to 20% of a galaxy's total HI mass, and maintains a flattened, ellipsoidal distribution that challenges current cosmological simulations.

TL;DR

Using the world’s largest single-dish radio telescope, astronomers have mapped the incredibly faint "atmosphere" of neutral hydrogen surrounding nearby galaxies. They found that this gas extends tens of kiloparsecs into space but remains surprisingly flattened, providing a new "missing link" between dense galactic disks and the sparse intergalactic medium.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Galaxies are not closed systems; they "breathe" by accreting fresh gas from the intergalactic medium and ejecting processed gas via supernova-driven winds. This exchange happens in the circumgalactic medium (CGM). However, studying the CGM is notoriously difficult.

Radio interferometers (like the VLA) provide high-resolution images but suffer from the "missing short-spacing" problem, which makes them blind to large-scale, diffuse gas structures. Conversely, absorption studies (using background quasars) are incredibly sensitive but only provide a "pencil-beam" view—a single data point per galaxy. This paper addresses the gap by providing deep, spatially resolved emission maps of the low-density HI gas that bridges the disk and the CGM.

Methods

The team observed seven edge-on galaxies (inclination $> 85^{\circ}$) to clearly distinguish gas moving "up" out of the disk.

  • FAST Observations: They leveraged FAST’s massive collecting area to reach a $3\sigma$ column density limit of $5 \times 10^{17} \text{cm}^{-2}$, significantly deeper than most previous surveys.
  • Separation Techniques: To isolate the extraplanar gas from the bright disk, they used two complementary methods:
  • Interferometry-based: They subtracted convolved interferometric data (which captures only the dense disk) from the FAST data.
  • Parametric Modeling: They fitted a dual-component Gaussian model (a thin disk + an extended extraplanar component) to the vertical profiles of the gas.
  • Beam Simulation: Because FAST has a complex 19-beam receiver, they developed a custom "observing simulator" to account for sidelobes and beam patterns, ensuring that the detected "extra" gas wasn't just an artifact of the telescope's optics.

Datasets

  • FEASTS Survey: The primary data source, providing HI maps for galaxies like NGC 891, NGC 4565, and NGC 5907.
  • HALOGAS & CHANGES: Existing high-resolution interferometric surveys used as a baseline for the disk component.
  • COS-Halos & CUBS: Quasar absorption datasets used to compare the FAST emission results with traditional CGM detection methods.
  • Illustris & IllustrisTNG: Cosmological hydrodynamical simulations used to test theoretical predictions against the new observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Flattened Halo: The most striking finding is that the extraplanar HI is not a spherical "cloud" but a flattened ellipsoid (average axis ratio of $\sim 0.56$). This suggests that the gas is likely "recycled"—ejected from the disk and falling back—rather than being a pristine, spherical halo of accreting gas.
  • The Scaling Law: There is a tight positive correlation between the vertical extent of the gas ($z_{18}$) and the total HI mass of the galaxy. More massive galaxies have significantly taller HI "atmospheres."
  • The Missing Link: The off-disk HI profiles from FAST perfectly match the lower envelope of previous Lyman-$\alpha$ absorption measurements. This effectively connects two different fields of study, showing that the "diffuse" gas seen in absorption is the same structure FAST is now seeing in emission.

Key Results

  • Mass Fraction: Extraplanar HI accounts for 5% to 20% of the total HI mass in these galaxies.
  • Spatial Extent: At a column density of $10^{18} \text{cm}^{-2}$, the gas extends 20–50 kpc away from the galactic plane.
  • Simulation Tension: The results show significant tension with the Illustris simulation, which predicts much more spherical and extended HI halos ($z_{18} \sim 110$ kpc). While the newer IllustrisTNG is more accurate, it still struggles to perfectly replicate the observed flattened geometry, suggesting that feedback and accretion recipes in models need further refinement.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the sample size; with only seven galaxies, it is difficult to make definitive claims about the entire galaxy population. Additionally, the large beam size of FAST (~3 arcmin) means that the inner disk structure is "smeared," requiring sophisticated modeling to extract the extraplanar signal.

The authors suggest that future work will involve expanding the sample through the ongoing FEASTS program and using joint deconvolution techniques (combining FAST and interferometry data) to produce maps that have both high resolution and high sensitivity to diffuse structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a statistical study of the neutral atomic hydrogen (HI) gas extending into the circumgalactic medium perpendicular to the disk for 7 edge-on galaxies with inclinations above $85^{\circ}$ from the FEASTS program with a $3σ$ ($20\,\text{km}\,\text{s}^{-1}$) column density ($N_{\text{HI}}$) depth of $5\times10^{17} \text{cm}^{-2}$. We develop two photometric methods to separate the extraplanar HI from the disk component, based on existing interferometric data and parametric modeling of the disk flux distribution respectively. With both methods, the FEASTS data exhibit clear extended wings beyond the disk along the minor axis. The extraplanar HI accounts for 5% to 20% of the total HI mass and extends to $20\text{-}50$ kpc at $N_{\text{HI}}=10^{18} \text{cm}^{-2}$. We find a tight positive correlation between vertical extensions of the extraplanar HI and total HI mass $M_\text{HI}$. The iso-density shape of HI at $N_{\text{HI}}=10^{18} \text{cm}^{-2}$ has an average axis ratio of $0.56\pm0.11$. The off-disk $N_{\text{HI}}$ profiles of these edge-on galaxies well represent the lower envelop of previous Lyman-$α$ absorption measurements at low-redshift. Our results suggest that at $N_{\text{HI}}=5\times10^{17} \text{cm}^{-2}$, the HI extends considerably further than the known thin and thick disks in the vertical direction, but still remains much flattener than a spherical distribution, consistent with theoretical expectations that outflow, circulation, and accretion should have different impacts in these two directions. We show the tension of our results with Illustris and TNG predictions, highlighting the constraining power of our results for future simulations.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2025feasts,
  author = {Dong Yang and Jing Wang and Zhijie Qu and Ze-Zhong Liang and Xuchen Lin and Simon Weng and Xinkai Chen and Barbara Catinella and L. Cortese and David B. Fisher and Luis C. Ho and Yingjie Jing and Fangzhou Jiang and Peng Jiang and Ziming Liu and Céline Péroux and Shao Li and L. Staveley‐Smith and Q. Daniel Wang and Jie Wang},
  title = {{FEASTS Combined with Interferometry (IV): Mapping HI Emission to a limit of $N\_\{\textbackslash\{\}text\{HI\}\}=10^\{17.7\} \textbackslash\{\}text\{cm\}^\{-2\}$ in Seven Edge-on Galaxies}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.16926},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.16926},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure