Feasibility study of TPC at electron positron colliders atZpole operation

M. Zhao, M. Q. Ruan, Huirong Qi, Yue GaoJournal of Instrumentation 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Time Projection Chamber (TPC) is a promising technology for future electron-positron colliders. However, its application might be limited at high event rates and high hit occupancies. In this paper, we study the feasibility of using a TPC at the Circular Electron Positron Collider (CEPC) at the $Z$ pole using fully simulated $Z \rightarrow q\bar{q}$ samples. By evaluating the local charge density and voxel occupancy at different TPC parameters, our study shows that the TPC could be applied to CEPC $Z$-pole operation if ion back-flow is controlled to the per mille level. We also suggest applicable TPC parameters for FCC-ee $Z$-pole operations, where the instantaneous luminosity is two orders of magnitude higher than that of the CEPC.

Introduction

Future circular electron-positron colliders, such as the CEPC and FCC-ee, are envisioned as "Higgs and Z factories." Operating at the $Z$ pole involves extremely high event rates—up to 60 kHz for the FCC-ee. While TPCs are favored for their high-precision 3D tracking and low material budget, they are inherently slow detectors. The primary concern is whether the accumulation of ions, which drift much slower than electrons, will create a "space charge" that distorts the internal electric field beyond manageable limits.

Methodology

The study utilized the Mokka simulation framework (based on Geant4) to model the CEPC detector geometry. The researchers focused on $Z \to q\bar{q}$ decays, as these events produce the highest track densities. A dataset of 9,000 simulated events was used to analyze voxel occupancy and space charge effects. Voxel occupancy was determined by dividing the TPC volume into 3D cells (voxels) based on readout pad size and electronics sampling rates.

The Ion Problem and Space Charge

The critical challenge for high-rate TPCs is the "history" of ions remaining in the drift volume. As illustrated in Figure 1, ions are generated both by primary particle tracks and as "back-flow" from the amplification stage at the endcap.

Schematic of ion drift in a TPC, illustrating primary ions from tracks and back-flow ions from the endcap.

Because ions move approximately 10,000 times slower than electrons, the TPC volume contains ions from hundreds of previous events at any given time. This accumulation creates an electric field distortion that shifts the measured position of particle hits. To keep these distortions manageable (around $10 \mu m$ for CEPC), the Ion Back Flow (IBF) must be strictly controlled.

Results: Occupancy and Density Analysis

A key finding of the simulation is that voxel occupancy remains remarkably low. Even at the innermost layers, the maximum occupancy is approximately $2 \times 10^{-5}$, indicating that overlapping hits are not a primary bottleneck for track reconstruction.

The study also quantified the radial distribution of hit and charge densities. As seen in Figure 4, these densities are highest near the interaction point (inner radius) and decay rapidly as the radius increases.

Radial distribution of hit density (left) and charge density (right) within the TPC volume.

For the CEPC at nominal luminosity, the maximum track distortion is estimated at $10 \mu m$, which is well within the safety margins for the detector's spatial resolution. However, for the FCC-ee, distortions could reach 1 cm in the worst-case scenario. To maintain precision in such environments, IBF must be suppressed to the $0.1\%$ (per mille) level.

Conclusion

The TPC remains a viable candidate for $Z$-pole operation at future colliders, provided that hardware challenges regarding ion back-flow are met. Achieving per mille level IBF control is the critical engineering hurdle for micro-pattern gaseous detectors. Future R&D must focus on detector stability and the development of advanced distortion correction algorithms to mitigate the effects of space charge in extreme luminosity environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

TPC is a promising technology for the future electron positron colliders. However, its application might be limited at high event rate and high hit occupancies. In this paper, we study the feasibility of using TPC at the circular electron positron collider (CEPC) at $Z$ pole using full simulated $Z \rightarrow q\bar{q}$ samples. By evaluating the local charge density and voxel occupancy at different TPC parameters. Our study shows that the TPC could be applied to the CEPC $Z$ pole operation if back flow ion is controlled to per mille level. We also suggest the applicable TPC parameters for FCC-ee $Z$ pole operations, whose instant luminosity is $2\times 10^{36} \mathrm{cm^2\,s^{-1}}$, 2 orders of magnitude higher than that of CEPC.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2017feasibility,
  author = {M. Zhao and M. Q. Ruan and Huirong Qi and Yue Gao},
  title = {{Feasibility study of TPC at electron positron colliders at<i>Z</i>pole operation}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/12/07/p07005},
}
Figure