Feasibility study of shutter scan acquisition for region of interest (<scp>ROI</scp>) digital tomosynthesis

Dohyeon Kim, Byungdu Jo, Donghoon Lee, Haenghwa Lee, Sunghoon Choi, Hyemi Kim, Zhen Chao, Seungyeon Choi, Hee‐Joung KimJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "shutter scan" acquisition method for digital tomosynthesis (DTS) that significantly improves image quality within a Region of Interest (ROI) while simultaneously reducing patient radiation dose. By strategically acquiring both truncated and non-truncated projections, the method enhances contrast and detail in targeted areas, offering a promising advancement for diagnostic imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Medical imaging, particularly digital tomosynthesis (DTS), faces a constant challenge in balancing image quality with patient radiation exposure. While DTS offers 3D-like reconstructions from 2D projections, it still delivers a higher dose than standard radiography. Diagnostically crucial information is often concentrated in specific areas (Regions of Interest or ROIs), but conventional DTS acquisition captures a broad field of view (FOV), leading to unnecessary dose to surrounding tissues and potentially diluting image quality within the ROI. Existing ROI reconstruction techniques often struggle with artifacts introduced by limited-view data. This paper aims to address this by proposing a shutter scan acquisition method that specifically targets ROIs for improved image quality and dose reduction.

Methods

The core innovation is the "shutter scan" acquisition technique. Unlike conventional full-view scans that capture complete projections, the shutter scan acquires a mix of truncated and non-truncated projections. Specifically, 21 truncated and 20 non-truncated projections were acquired over a 40° angular range.

To handle the truncation artifacts inherent in the truncated projections, a novel image processing pipeline was developed. This pipeline involves:

  1. 2D Laplace Operator: Used to detect edges caused by truncation.
  2. Linear Interpolation: Pixel values around the detected edges are interpolated to fill the truncated regions.
  3. Inverse Laplace Transform: Applied to the processed image.

After this pre-processing, the Filtered Back Projection (FBP) algorithm, a standard and computationally efficient reconstruction method, was used to generate the tomographic images. The study also involved a comparative analysis using a standard full-view scan acquisition with the same number of projections.

Datasets

The study utilized the LUNGMAN phantom (Kyoto Kagaku, Japan), a multipurpose chest phantom designed to simulate human chest anatomy. This phantom contained artificial lung nodules of three different sizes: 8 mm, 10 mm, and 12 mm. These nodules served as the ROIs for evaluating image quality. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the LUNGMAN phantom was used to evaluate the proposed method against a conventional approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Targeted Dose Reduction: By limiting the acquisition to a specific ROI, the shutter scan method inherently reduces the total radiation dose delivered to the patient, as less area is irradiated.
  • Artifact Mitigation is Crucial: Truncated projections introduce significant artifacts. The proposed image processing technique is essential for making the shutter scan method viable, demonstrating that these artifacts can be effectively corrected.
  • ROI Enhancement: The shutter scan method demonstrably improves image quality within the ROI, leading to better visualization of nodules. This suggests that focusing acquisition on areas of interest can yield superior diagnostic information.
  • Balancing ROI and Global Information: While the focus is on ROI enhancement, the inclusion of non-truncated projections allows for the reconstruction of anatomical information outside the ROI, which is critical for overall diagnostic context.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Contrast: The shutter scan acquisition resulted in improved contrast for lung nodules within the ROI. Specifically, CNR values for 8 mm and 12 mm nodules increased by 6.38% and 21.21%, respectively. The 10 mm nodule showed a slight decrease in CNR (-3.63%), which the authors attribute to its position relative to the ROI.
  • Reduced Noise: COV values, representing image noise, were consistently lower for lung nodules in shutter scan images compared to full-view scans.
  • Improved Figure of Merit (FOM): The FOM, which quantifies image quality relative to dose, showed significant improvements. FOM values for the 8, 10, and 12 mm nodules increased by 3.06, 2.25, and 2.33 times, respectively.
  • Dose Reduction: The total Dose Area Product (DAP) values were reduced by 36.36% with the shutter scan acquisition compared to the full-view acquisition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited ROI Impact Outside: While CNR improved within the ROI, the effect outside the ROI was minimal. The authors acknowledge that the position of the lesion relative to the defined ROI is critical for effective shutter scan application.
  • Need for Clinical Validation: The study was conducted on a phantom. Further research is needed to verify the clinical value through quantitative dose evaluation studies and to investigate the optimal acquisition parameters for shutter scan acquisition.
  • Scatter Radiation Analysis: The authors suggest that further study is needed to quantitatively analyze the impact of reduced FOV on scatter radiation and how it contributes to improved image quality.
  • Clinical Applicability: Future work will focus on conducting further studies on the clinical application of this method to demonstrate its applicability in real clinical cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dose reduction techniques have been studied in medical imaging. We propose shutter scan acquisition for region of interest (ROI) imaging to reduce the patient exposure dose received from a digital tomosynthesis system. A prototype chest digital tomosynthesis (CDT) system (LISTEM, Wonju, Korea) and the LUNGMAN phantom (Kyoto Kagaku, Japan) with lung nodules 8, 10, and 12 mm in size were used for this study. A total of 41 projections with shutter scan acquisition consisted of 21 truncated projections and 20 non-truncated projections. For comparison, 41 projections using conventional full view scan acquisition were also acquired. Truncated projections obtained by shutter scan acquisition were corrected by proposed image processing procedure to remove the truncation artifacts. The image quality was evaluated using the contrast to noise ratio (CNR), coefficient of variation (COV), and figure of merit (FOM). We measured the dose area product (DAP) value to verify the dose reduction using shutter scan acquisition. The ROI of the reconstructed image from shutter scan acquisition showed enhanced contrast. The results showed that CNR values of 8 and 12 mm lung nodules increased by 6.38% and 21.21%, respectively, and the CNR value of 10 mm lung nodule decreased by 3.63%. COV values of the lung nodules were lower in a shutter scan image than in a full view scan image. FOM values of 8, 10, and 12 mm lung nodules increased by 3.06, 2.25, and 2.33 times, respectively. This study compared the proposed shutter scan and conventional full view scan acquisition. In conclusion, using a shutter scan acquisition method resulted in enhanced contrast images within the ROI and higher FOM values. The patient exposure dose of the proposed shutter scan acquisition method can be reduced by limiting the field of view (FOV) to focus on the ROI.
BibTeX
@article{kim2018feasibility,
  author = {Dohyeon Kim and Byungdu Jo and Donghoon Lee and Haenghwa Lee and Sunghoon Choi and Hyemi Kim and Zhen Chao and Seungyeon Choi and Hee‐Joung Kim and Hee‐Joung Kim and Hee‐Joung Kim},
  title = {{Feasibility study of shutter scan acquisition for region of interest (<scp>ROI</scp>) digital tomosynthesis}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1002/acm2.12294},
}
Figure