Feasibility of using optical coherence tomography to detect acute radiation-induced esophageal damage in small animal models

Pouya Jelvehgaran, Daniël M. de Bruin, Francisco J. Salguero, Gerben R. Borst, Ji‐Ying Song, Ton G. van Leeuwen, Johannes F. de Boer, Tanja Alderliesten, Marcel van HerkJournal of Biomedical Optics 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the use of optical coherence tomography (OCT) to non-invasively detect and monitor acute radiation-induced esophageal damage (ARIED) in mice. The study demonstrates that OCT can identify changes in tissue scattering and layer thickness consistent with ARIED, offering a promising tool for preclinical research and potential future clinical applications in radiation therapy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Radiation therapy (RT) is a cornerstone of cancer treatment, particularly for lung cancer. However, a significant challenge is the potential for RT to damage nearby healthy tissues, leading to side effects that can limit treatment efficacy and patient quality of life. The esophagus is particularly vulnerable to radiation, and acute radiation-induced esophageal damage (ARIED), or acute esophagitis, is a common and dose-limiting toxicity. Current methods for detecting ARIED, such as endoscopy, are invasive and may not provide the detailed, real-time imaging needed for precise monitoring. This gap in non-invasive, high-resolution imaging of radiation-induced damage in the esophagus is what the authors aim to address, seeking a method that can detect and track ARIED in preclinical models, with the ultimate goal of translating this to human patients.

Methods

The researchers employed optical coherence tomography (OCT) for its high-resolution, cross-sectional imaging capabilities (10 µm resolution). They used a commercially available intravascular OCT system adapted for esophageal imaging in mice. Mice were subjected to varying doses of radiation (4.0, 10.0, 16.0, and 20.0 Gy) delivered to specific spots in the esophagus. Post-irradiation, mice were repeatedly imaged with OCT over a three-month period. To validate the OCT findings, histopathology was performed at the end of the study. The researchers quantitatively analyzed the OCT data by calculating the contrast-to-background-noise ratio (CNR) to differentiate between healthy tissue, edema, and inflammatory infiltration. They also measured changes in tissue layer thickness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized 30 SPF FVB mice as the experimental subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OCT as a Non-Invasive Window: The study highlights OCT's potential as a non-invasive tool to visualize and quantify subtle changes in esophageal tissue that occur due to radiation damage, circumventing the need for more invasive procedures.
  • Distinguishing Radiation vs. Procedure Damage: By including control groups (radiation-only and OCT-only), the researchers were able to differentiate between damage caused by radiation itself and damage potentially induced by the OCT probe insertion. This is crucial for accurately attributing observed changes.
  • Edema as a Probe-Induced Artifact: A key finding was that edema (swelling) in the esophageal wall was more prevalent in groups that underwent repeated OCT probe insertions, suggesting it might be an artifact of the imaging procedure rather than solely a direct result of radiation at the doses used. This has important implications for experimental design.
  • Inflammatory Infiltration as a Radiation Biomarker: Conversely, inflammatory infiltration was strongly linked to higher radiation doses, reinforcing its role as a direct indicator of radiation-induced damage.
  • Quantitative Metrics for Damage Assessment: The use of CNR and layer thickness measurements provided objective, quantitative data to support the qualitative visual assessments of ARIED, making the findings more robust and reproducible.

Key Results

  • Agreement with Histopathology: OCT findings were in good agreement with histopathology results obtained three months post-irradiation, with OCT successfully identifying areas of inflammatory infiltration and edema.
  • Quantitative Differences: Statistical analysis revealed significant differences in CNR values between healthy esophageal tissue, edema, and inflammatory infiltration.
  • Inflammatory infiltration showed a CNR that was, on average, 1.6-fold higher than healthy esophageal tissue.
  • Edema showed a CNR that was, on average, 1.6-fold lower than healthy esophageal tissue.
  • Detection Rates: OCT detected 85.7% of inflammatory infiltration and 81.3% of edema cases that were reported in histopathology.
  • Edema Measurement: The distance between the muscularis mucosa and lamina propria was significantly larger in edematous tissue compared to healthy tissue (1.7-fold increase).
  • Dose-Dependent Inflammation: Inflammatory infiltration was predominantly observed in the higher dose regions of the esophagus.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Undersampling: The study acknowledges that the histopathology analysis might have undersampled the esophageal specimens, meaning some damage detected by OCT might not have been validated. Future work could involve embedding the entire esophagus for more comprehensive histopathological analysis.
  • Small Spot Size and Dose: The researchers suggest that the small spot size used for irradiation and the chosen dose levels might have contributed to limited acute damage observed. They hypothesize that this might differ from human tolerance levels and that the esophagus, being a serial organ, could exhibit different responses.
  • Probe-Induced Edema: While edema was observed, the study suggests it may be partly due to repeated OCT probe insertions. Future studies could aim to minimize this by reducing the frequency of OCT imaging.
  • Translation to Humans: The authors propose future work to modify protocols to induce more substantial ARIED and to investigate the feasibility of OCT for detecting and monitoring ARIED in human patients undergoing RT. They believe their findings are translatable due to the similar esophageal wall layering between mice and humans.
  • Artifacts: Imaging artifacts, such as those caused by non-uniform rotational distortion (NURD), breathing, and probe movement, affected visual quality and interpretation in some OCT images.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lung cancer survival is poor, and radiation therapy patients often suffer serious treatment side effects. The esophagus is particularly sensitive leading to acute radiation-induced esophageal damage (ARIED). We investigated the feasibility of optical coherence tomography (OCT) for minimally invasive imaging of the esophagus with high resolution (10 μm) to detect ARIED in mice. Thirty mice underwent cone-beam computed tomography imaging for initial setup assessment and dose planning followed by a single-dose delivery of 4.0, 10.0, 16.0, and 20.0 Gy on 5.0-mm spots, spaced 10.0 mm apart in the esophagus. They were repeatedly imaged using OCT up to three months postirradiation. We compared OCT findings with histopathology obtained three months postirradiation qualitatively and quantitatively using the contrast-to-background-noise ratio (CNR). Histopathology mostly showed inflammatory infiltration and edema at higher doses; OCT findings were in agreement with most of the histopathological reports. We were able to identify the ARIED on OCT as a change in tissue scattering and layer thickness. Our statistical analysis showed significant difference between the CNR values of healthy tissue, edema, and inflammatory infiltration. Overall, the average CNR for inflammatory infiltration and edema damages was 1.6-fold higher and 1.6-fold lower than for the healthy esophageal wall, respectively. Our results showed the potential role of OCT to detect and monitor the ARIED in mice, which may translate to humans.
BibTeX
@article{jelvehgaran2018feasibility,
  author = {Pouya Jelvehgaran and Daniël M. de Bruin and Francisco J. Salguero and Gerben R. Borst and Ji‐Ying Song and Ton G. van Leeuwen and Johannes F. de Boer and Tanja Alderliesten and Marcel van Herk},
  title = {{Feasibility of using optical coherence tomography to detect acute radiation-induced esophageal damage in small animal models}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.23.4.046004},
}
Figure