Feasibility and Acceptance of Self-Guided Mobile Ultrasound among Pregnant Women in Routine Prenatal Care

Constanza Pontones, Adriana Titzmann, Hanna Huebner, Nina Danzberger, Matthias Ruebner, Lothar Häberle, Bjoern M. Eskofier, Michael Nissen, Sven Kehl, Florian Faschingbauer, Matthias W. Beckmann, Peter A. Fasching, Michael SchneiderJournal of Clinical Medicine 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the feasibility and acceptance of pregnant women performing self-guided mobile ultrasounds at home. While generally accepted, with good image quality for amniotic fluid and fetal heartbeat, live professional support is highly desired, and fetal profile imaging remains challenging. This research paves the way for exploring mobile ultrasound's role in routine prenatal care.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Routine prenatal care relies heavily on ultrasound examinations performed by trained professionals to monitor fetal development and detect abnormalities. However, these examinations can be complex and require significant expertise. The increasing availability of mobile ultrasound devices, coupled with the need for accessible and potentially more patient-friendly healthcare solutions (accelerated by events like the COVID-19 pandemic), raises the question of whether pregnant women could effectively and safely perform self-guided ultrasounds at home. This paper investigates the practicalities, user acceptance, and success rates of such self-examinations, aiming to understand their potential role in future prenatal care.

Methods

The study employed a prospective, single-center, interventional cohort design. Forty-six pregnant women, aged 18-50 and between 17+0 and 29+6 weeks of gestation, were enrolled. They were divided into two cohorts, each using a different mobile ultrasound device: the Instinct (PulseNmore Ltd.) and the Butterfly iQ (Butterfly Network Inc.). After a standard ultrasound examination by an experienced professional, participants received brief (5-10 minute) instructions on using the mobile device. They were then tasked with recording specific ultrasound videos and images: a 30-second video of the fetal heartbeat, a 60-second video and image of the fetal profile, and 15-second videos of the amniotic fluid in each of the four abdominal quadrants. Feasibility and acceptance were assessed via a questionnaire, and the success rate of image and video quality was evaluated by an experienced sonographer.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved data collection from participants' self-performed ultrasound scans and questionnaire responses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Acceptance, but with a Caveat: A significant majority of women were open to the idea of performing self-guided ultrasounds at home. However, this acceptance is strongly coupled with a desire for live support from a healthcare professional, highlighting a need for guidance and reassurance.
  • Safety Concerns are Minimal: Most participants did not express significant concerns about their own safety or that of their child during the self-examination, suggesting that with proper instruction, the perceived risks are low.
  • Targeted Structures Matter: The success rates varied considerably depending on what was being imaged. Amniotic fluid and fetal heartbeat were more successfully captured than the fetal profile, indicating that some anatomical structures are inherently easier for untrained individuals to locate and image.
  • The "Face" is Tricky: Imaging the fetal profile proved to be the most challenging task, with low success rates. This aligns with the understanding that even experienced sonographers can struggle with visualizing the fetal face due to fetal position and other factors.
  • Technology is Maturing: The availability and increasing affordability of mobile ultrasound devices are making these explorations possible, pushing the boundaries of remote and patient-driven healthcare.

Key Results

  • Willingness to Self-Examine: Two-thirds of the women could imagine performing the self-guided examination at home.
  • Preference for Support: A substantial 87.0% of participants would prefer live support from their attending physician via video telephony if performing the examination at home.
  • Safety Confidence: 71.7% of participants did not believe the examinations could be harmful, while 23.9% expressed slight concerns about their safety and that of the child.
  • Success Rates:
    • Fetal Heartbeat Videos: 52.2% of participants successfully located the target structure.
  • Amniotic Fluid Videos: 93.5% located amniotic fluid in at least one quadrant, with 52.2% successfully locating it in all four quadrants.
  • Fetal Profile Videos: Only 17.9% successfully located the fetal profile.
  • Image Quality: Image quality was generally adequate for assessing amniotic fluid and fetal heartbeat in most participants.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge the small study population in each cohort as a limitation. They also note that the high educational level of participants might have positively influenced their success rates. The immediate post-presentation training might also have contributed to the success rates, suggesting that the learning curve for these devices needs further investigation.

Future work should focus on:

  • Clinical Implementation: Determining how self-guided ultrasound examinations can be integrated into routine prenatal care.
  • Fetomaternal Outcomes: Investigating the impact of such self-examinations on both maternal and fetal health outcomes.
  • Live Support Trials: Conducting clinical trials that incorporate additional live support from physicians via video telephony, as this was a strong preference among participants.
  • Longitudinal Studies: Exploring the influence of self-monitoring on maternal anxiety and potential impacts on postnatal depression.
  • Safety and Efficacy: Further prospective randomized trials are needed to compare the sensitivity and specificity of self-guided examinations with those performed by professionals.

Summary updated

Abstract

These results show wide acceptance of self-examination using mobile systems for fetal ultrasonography during pregnancy. Image quality was adequate for assessing the amniotic fluid and fetal heartbeat in most participants. Further studies are needed to determine whether ultrasound self-examinations can be implemented in prenatal care and how this would affect the fetomaternal outcome.
BibTeX
@article{pontones2023feasibility,
  author = {Constanza Pontones and Adriana Titzmann and Hanna Huebner and Nina Danzberger and Matthias Ruebner and Lothar Häberle and Bjoern M. Eskofier and Michael Nissen and Sven Kehl and Florian Faschingbauer and Matthias W. Beckmann and Peter A. Fasching and Michael Schneider},
  title = {{Feasibility and Acceptance of Self-Guided Mobile Ultrasound among Pregnant Women in Routine Prenatal Care}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm12134224},
}
Figure