Feasibility and Acceptability of Wearable Sleep Electroencephalogram Device Use in Adolescents: Observational Study (Preprint)

Jessica R. Lunsford‐Avery, Casey Keller, Scott H. Kollins, Andrew D. Krystal, Leah Jackson, Matthew Engelhard2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the feasibility and acceptability of using wearable sleep electroencephalogram (EEG) devices for adolescents at home. The findings suggest that these devices are a viable and well-tolerated option for assessing sleep in this age group, paving the way for broader use in clinical and research settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescence is a critical period for developing healthy habits, and sleep plays a crucial role in physical and mental well-being. However, sleep is often overlooked in routine healthcare for adolescents. Traditional sleep assessments like polysomnography (PSG) are expensive, invasive, and not practical for widespread use. While wrist-worn activity trackers are common, they provide indirect measures of sleep. This paper addresses the need for accessible, user-friendly methods to assess adolescent sleep by evaluating the feasibility and acceptability of wearable sleep EEG devices for at-home use.

Methods

The researchers conducted an observational study involving 104 adolescents aged 11-17. Participants used a wearable sleep EEG device (Zmachine Insight+) and a wristworn actigraph for 7 days at home. Feasibility was measured by the number of successful sleep recordings, and acceptability was assessed using a custom survey (Wearable Acceptability Survey for Sleep - WASS). The WASS evaluated comfort, sleep disturbances, and overall satisfaction with the devices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: Wearable EEG devices offer a promising solution to the limitations of traditional sleep assessments, providing direct physiological data in a convenient, at-home setting.
  • Adolescent Acceptance: The study demonstrates that adolescents are generally willing and able to use wearable sleep EEG technology, which is crucial for its adoption in this age group.
  • Comfort is Key: While generally well-received, understanding factors contributing to discomfort (like wires or adhesive) is vital for future device design and user experience.
  • Individual Differences Matter: Certain sleep positions or habits might influence the experience with wearable devices, suggesting a need for personalized guidance.

Key Results

  • Feasibility: A high percentage of adolescents (94.2%) successfully recorded at least one night of sleep EEG data, with an average of 5.42 nights recorded. Similarly, 91.3% successfully recorded at least one night with the actigraph.
  • Acceptability - Comfort: The majority of adolescents found the devices comfortable to mildly uncomfortable while awake (EEG: 81.6%, Actigraphy: 92.2%) and sleeping (EEG: 66.0%, Actigraphy: 81.6%).
  • Acceptability - Sleep Disturbances: Most adolescents reported typical sleep (EEG: 40.8%) or minimal to mild sleep disturbances (EEG: 39.8%) while using the EEG device. Similar patterns were observed for the actigraph.
  • Acceptability - Satisfaction: Over half of the adolescents reported being satisfied with their study experience (EEG: 51.5%, Actigraphy: 68.9%). Dissatisfaction was low, with only 10.7% expressing it for the EEG device.
  • Recommendation: A significant majority would recommend the study to a friend (EEG: 79%, Actigraphy: 90%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • The study focused on generally healthy adolescents, and the feasibility and acceptability in clinical populations (e.g., those with obstructive sleep apnea) are unknown.
  • The selected device did not measure respiratory function, which is a key component of sleep assessment.
  • The study did not compare the wearable EEG device's performance against the gold standard, polysomnography (PSG).

Future work should focus on:

  • Evaluating strategies to further improve device usability.
  • Assessing the relationship between sleep EEG-derived metrics and health outcomes.
  • Investigating methods for integrating data from these devices into digital interventions and applications.
  • Exploring wireless EEG systems and other design refinements to enhance comfort and reduce issues like wire tangling.
  • Facilitating direct communication of sleep EEG data to adolescents and healthcare providers.

Summary updated

Abstract

<sec> <title>BACKGROUND</title> Adolescence is an important life stage for the development of healthy behaviors, which have a long-lasting impact on health across the lifespan. Sleep undergoes significant changes during adolescence and is linked to physical and psychiatric health; however, sleep is rarely assessed in routine health care settings. Wearable sleep electroencephalogram (EEG) devices may represent user-friendly methods for assessing sleep among adolescents, but no studies to date have examined the feasibility and acceptability of sleep EEG wearables in this age group. </sec> <sec> <title>OBJECTIVE</title> The goal of the research was to investigate the feasibility and acceptability of sleep EEG wearable devices among adolescents aged 11 to 17 years. </sec> <sec> <title>METHODS</title> A total of 104 adolescents aged 11 to 17 years participated in 7 days of at-home sleep recording using a self-administered wearable sleep EEG device (Zmachine Insight+, General Sleep Corporation) as well as a wristworn actigraph. Feasibility was assessed as the number of full nights of successful recording completed by adolescents, and acceptability was measured by the wearable acceptability survey for sleep. Feasibility and acceptability were assessed separately for the sleep EEG device and wristworn actigraph. </sec> <sec> <title>RESULTS</title> A total of 94.2% (98/104) of adolescents successfully recorded at least 1 night of data using the sleep EEG device (mean number of nights 5.42; SD 1.71; median 6, mode 7). A total of 81.6% (84/103) rated the comfort of the device as falling in the comfortable to mildly uncomfortable range while awake. A total of 40.8% (42/103) reported typical sleep while using the device, while 39.8% (41/103) indicated minimal to mild device-related sleep disturbances. A minority (32/104, 30.8%) indicated changes in their sleep position due to device use, and very few (11/103, 10.7%) expressed dissatisfaction with their experience with the device. A similar pattern was observed for the wristworn actigraph device. </sec> <sec> <title>CONCLUSIONS</title> Wearable sleep EEG appears to represent a feasible, acceptable method for sleep assessment among adolescents and may have utility for assessing and treating sleep disturbances at a population level. Future studies with adolescents should evaluate strategies for further improving usability of such devices, assess relationships between sleep EEG–derived metrics and health outcomes, and investigate methods for incorporating data from these devices into emerging digital interventions and applications. </sec> <sec> <title>CLINICALTRIAL</title> ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03843762; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03843762 </sec>
BibTeX
@misc{lunsfordavery2020feasibility,
  author = {Jessica R. Lunsford‐Avery and Casey Keller and Scott H. Kollins and Andrew D. Krystal and Leah Jackson and Matthew Engelhard},
  title = {{Feasibility and Acceptability of Wearable Sleep Electroencephalogram Device Use in Adolescents: Observational Study (Preprint)}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2196/preprints.20590},
}
Figure