TL;DR
This study uses Fe and Mg isotope compositions of Chang'E 5 (CE-5) mare basalts to reveal their origin from a hybrid mantle source. This hybrid source, a mix of early and late-stage lunar magma ocean (LMO) cumulates, is crucial for understanding the prolonged volcanic activity on the Moon.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Chang'E 5 mission returned the youngest mare basalts ever found on the Moon, offering a unique window into its late-stage evolution. However, the exact nature of the mantle source for these basalts has been a subject of debate. Previous analyses of major and trace elements have been complicated by extensive fractional crystallization, making it difficult to pinpoint the source. While some studies suggest a non-KREEP origin, others propose a clinopyroxene-rich source with a small KREEP component. This paper aims to resolve this ambiguity by employing Fe and Mg isotope geochemistry, which are less affected by fractional crystallization, to decipher the CE-5 basalts' mantle source.
Methods
The researchers analyzed two CE-5 basalt clasts using a multi-faceted approach:
- Petrology and Mineralogy: 3D tomography and high-resolution microscopy were used to examine the texture and mineral composition of the basalt clasts.
- Bulk Major and Trace Element Analysis: ICP-MS was employed to determine the elemental composition of the bulk rock samples.
- Fe and Mg Isotope Geochemistry: High-precision measurements of Fe and Mg isotopes were performed using MC-ICP-MS.
- LMO Differentiation Modeling: A sophisticated model was used to simulate the evolution of the lunar magma ocean (LMO) during its solidification, predicting the Fe-Mg isotope compositions of cumulates and residual melts at different stages.
- Mixing Modeling: The Fe-Mg isotope data from the modeled LMO cumulates were used in mixing models to test potential source compositions for the CE-5 basalts.
Datasets
The primary dataset consists of two CE-5 basalt clasts (CE-5-01 and CE-5-02) provided by the China National Space Administration. These samples were analyzed for their petrology, mineral chemistry, bulk major and trace elements, and Fe-Mg isotopes. The study also references and compares its findings with existing data from Apollo and Luna mare basalts, as well as KREEP basalt meteorites. The LMO differentiation model utilized parameters from previous studies, and the Fe-Mg isotope data for comparison were sourced from established literature.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Isotopic Fingerprints of a Hybrid Source: The Fe and Mg isotope compositions of the CE-5 basalts fall between those of Apollo low-Ti and high-Ti basalts, suggesting a mixed mantle source rather than a single, homogeneous one.
- LMO Cumulates as the Key: The study strongly supports the idea that the CE-5 basalts originated from a hybrid mantle source composed of cumulates formed during different stages of the Lunar Magma Ocean (LMO) solidification.
- Late-Stage Cumulates are Crucial: The data points towards the significant involvement of late-stage LMO cumulates, which are enriched in clinopyroxene and ilmenite, in generating these young basalts. This contrasts with earlier models that often focused on early-stage olivine-rich cumulates.
- Explaining the KREEP-like Signature: The KREEP-like Rare Earth Element (REE) pattern observed in CE-5 basalts can be explained by the melting of this hybrid cumulate source, without necessarily requiring the direct incorporation of KREEP material. This suggests that the REE signature is a consequence of the source lithology rather than a direct signature of KREEP-rich source rocks.
- Prolonged Volcanism Mechanism: The involvement of these more fusible late-stage cumulates could have lowered the mantle melting point, providing a mechanism for sustained volcanic activity on the Moon for billions of years.
Key Results
- CE-5 basalts exhibit a low Mg# (average ~29), indicating they are highly evolved.
- Their Fe isotope compositions (δ⁵⁷Fe ≈ 0.161 ± 0.010‰) are at the upper end of low-Ti basalts and lower than high-Ti basalts.
- Their Mg isotope compositions (δ²⁶Mg ≈ -0.264 ± 0.015‰) are similar to low-Ti basalts and heavier than high-Ti basalts.
- The LMO modeling indicates that early cumulates have lower FeO and higher MgO, while late cumulates have higher FeO and lower MgO, with distinct Fe-Mg isotopic signatures.
- Mixing models suggest that a combination of melts from early (e.g., 50 PCS) and late (e.g., 98 PCS) LMO cumulates, with a contribution of 20-30% from the late cumulates, can reproduce the observed Fe-Mg isotope compositions of CE-5 basalts.
- REE mixing models demonstrate that the KREEP-like REE pattern can be reproduced by mixing melts from early and late cumulates.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Representation: While the two analyzed clasts are considered representative of the local mare basalt at the CE-5 landing site, further analysis of a larger suite of CE-5 samples would strengthen the conclusions.
- LMO Model Simplifications: The LMO differentiation model, while sophisticated, involves certain assumptions and simplifications regarding crystallization processes and phase proportions.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that further investigation into the precise timing and mechanisms of mantle overturn and the subsequent melting of these hybrid cumulates could provide deeper insights into the prolonged lunar volcanism. Additionally, exploring the role of other isotopic systems in conjunction with Fe-Mg isotopes could further refine our understanding of lunar mantle evolution.
Summary updated