Fault zone Q values derived from Taiwan Chelungpu Fault borehole seismometers (TCDPBHS)

Yu-Ju Wang, Yen‐Yu Lin, Meng-Chieh Lee, Kuo‐Fong MaTectonophysics 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses data from a dense array of borehole seismometers installed in the Taiwan Chelungpu Fault to precisely measure seismic attenuation (Q values) within and below the fault zone. The findings reveal significantly lower Q values within the fault zone compared to surrounding rock, suggesting intense fracturing and the presence of fluids, which are key factors influencing seismic wave energy loss.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding seismic attenuation, or how seismic waves lose energy as they travel through the Earth, is crucial for characterizing subsurface structures and processes, especially within fault zones. The Chelungpu Fault, responsible for the devastating 1999 Chi-Chi earthquake in Taiwan, is a prime example of a complex fault system where detailed knowledge of its physical properties is vital for seismic hazard assessment and understanding earthquake mechanics. While previous studies have provided broad-scale attenuation maps, the precise attenuation structure within the fault zone itself, particularly at depth, remained poorly constrained. This paper aims to fill that gap by leveraging data from the Taiwan Chelungpu Fault Drilling Project (TCDP) borehole seismometer array (TCDPBHS) to provide high-resolution Q value estimates for different segments of the fault zone.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary methods to estimate seismic attenuation (Q values):

  • Spectral Ratio Method: This technique involves comparing the seismic wave spectra recorded at two different depths. By analyzing the ratio of these spectra, particularly the slope of the log-linear plot, researchers can infer the attenuation along the path between the two sensors. This method assumes a frequency-independent Q.
  • Spectral Fitting (LSQENP): This approach involves fitting a theoretical seismic source model to the observed spectra from individual seismometers. By minimizing the residuals between the observed and theoretical spectra, researchers can estimate parameters like the corner frequency and, importantly, the attenuation operator (t*), which is directly related to Q.

Both methods were applied to microearthquake data recorded by the TCDPBHS array. The researchers also performed a synthetic modeling test to validate their methods' ability to resolve attenuation in thin layers, confirming their approach's reliability.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of seismic waveforms recorded by the 7-level Taiwan Chelungpu Fault Borehole Seismometer Array (TCDPBHS). This array was installed in Hole A of the TCDP at depths ranging from 945 to 1270 meters, specifically targeting the 1999 rupture zone at 1111 meters. The data comprises recordings of microearthquakes (Mw 0.28 to 1.5) that occurred in the vicinity of the borehole.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fault Zone is a "Low-Q" Zone: The most striking finding is the significantly lower Q values (both Qp and Qs) within the Chelungpu Fault zone (specifically between BHS1 and BHS4) compared to the rock layers below the fault zone. This directly indicates a much higher rate of seismic wave energy loss within the fault.
  • Fracturing and Fluids are Key Attenuators: The low Q values are strongly interpreted as evidence of intense fracturing and the presence of fluids within the fault zone. These factors are well-known to enhance seismic attenuation.
  • Consistency Across Methods: The agreement between the spectral ratio and spectral fitting methods for estimating Q values provides strong confidence in the results. This cross-validation is crucial for robust scientific findings.
  • Sedimentary Rock Independence: The Q values observed in the Chelungpu Fault zone are comparable to those found in similar depths of the San Andreas Fault, suggesting that the attenuation characteristics at these depths might be more dependent on the presence of fractures and fluids rather than specific rock types, even within sedimentary sequences.
  • Negative Ats* Anomalies: The study also observed intriguing negative Ats* values for some events, which are not fully explained by standard attenuation models. These anomalies are tentatively attributed to complex structural variations, multi-reflective effects, or sharp changes in lithological properties within the fault zone.

Key Results

  • Fault Zone Attenuation: Qs values within the Chelungpu Fault zone (Qs₁) were found to be in the range of 21-22, while Qp values (Qp₁) were estimated at 27-35.
  • Below Fault Zone Attenuation: Below the slip zone, Qs values (Qs₄) were approximately 45, and Qp values (Qp₄) were around 85. This shows a significant increase in attenuation as one moves away from the immediate fault zone.
  • Comparison to San Andreas Fault: The derived Q values are consistent with those reported for the San Andreas Fault at comparable depths.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Seismometer Coverage: While the TCDPBHS array is a valuable tool, the analysis was primarily limited to data from BHS1 and BHS4 due to noise issues in other sensors for the analyzed microearthquakes.
  • Negative Ats* Anomalies: The interpretation of negative Ats* values requires further investigation, potentially involving more detailed structural modeling or advanced waveform analysis.
  • Frequency Independence Assumption: The study assumes frequency-independent Q, which is a common simplification but may not hold true across all frequency ranges or for all geological settings.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further analysis of seismic reflection data and detailed geological logs could help to better understand the relationship between lithology, fracturing, fluid content, and the observed attenuation features. Investigating the influence of different rock types on attenuation in more detail would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2011fault,
  author = {Yu-Ju Wang and Yen‐Yu Lin and Meng-Chieh Lee and Kuo‐Fong Ma},
  title = {{Fault zone Q values derived from Taiwan Chelungpu Fault borehole seismometers (TCDPBHS)}},
  booktitle = {Tectonophysics},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1016/j.tecto.2011.12.027},
}
Figure