TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel fault-tolerant control (FTC) strategy for autonomous vehicles with independent steering actuators. By modeling actuator degradation and its impact on tire force capabilities, the system can maintain stable vehicle control even when steering components begin to fail, a crucial step for the safety of future autonomous driving.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The increasing complexity of autonomous vehicles, particularly those employing "X-by-wire" systems like integrated autonomous wheel modules (IAWMs), introduces new challenges in reliability and safety. While these systems offer enhanced maneuverability and efficiency, they are also more susceptible to failures, especially in steering actuators. Traditional fault-tolerant control methods often simplify actuator failures or treat them as uncertainties, leading to conservative performance. This paper tackles the problem of independent steering actuator degradation, where actuators don't completely fail but lose effectiveness. The challenge is to maintain precise vehicle control by intelligently reallocating forces and leveraging the remaining capabilities of both healthy and degraded actuators, without compromising safety or stability.
Methods
The core of this paper lies in its integrated approach to fault-tolerant motion control.
- Fault-Dynamics Modeling: They first develop a detailed model of the independent steering system (ISS) that explicitly incorporates a "degradation coefficient" representing the reduced output torque of the steering actuator. This coefficient is then mathematically mapped to a contraction of the "feasible tire-force region," essentially quantifying how actuator degradation limits the forces a wheel can generate.
- Model Predictive Control (MPC) for Generalized Forces: A Model Predictive Controller is employed to determine the vehicle's required generalized forces and moments (longitudinal, lateral, and yaw). Crucially, this MPC incorporates the degraded actuator capabilities by adjusting the boundary values of these generalized forces. This ensures that the demanded forces remain within the physically achievable limits, even with faulty actuators.
- Adaptive Tire Force Allocation: For distributing these generalized forces among the individual wheels, an adaptive weighting scheme is proposed. This scheme explicitly includes the steering fault factor (derived from the degradation coefficient) into the objective function. This allows the system to dynamically adjust tire force allocation based on the severity of the actuator degradation.
- Sequential Quadratic Programming (SQP): To achieve optimal utilization of tire forces under these constraints, Sequential Quadratic Programming (SQP) is used to solve the tire force allocation problem.
Datasets
The paper utilizes a CarSim 2019 and Simulink 2021B co-simulation platform for evaluation. Specific vehicle parameters are provided in Table 1, based on recent studies and Chinese-market specifications for compact electric vehicles. The simulations involve two fault scenarios: diagonal wheel steering failure and unilateral wheel steering failure, under both high-friction and split-friction road conditions. No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing simulation environments and vehicle parameters were used to validate the proposed controller.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Degradation is Key: The paper highlights that focusing solely on complete actuator failure is insufficient. Modeling and accounting for gradual degradation of steering actuators is critical for realistic fault-tolerant control in autonomous vehicles.
- Mapping Actuator Health to Tire Forces: The novel approach of mapping steering actuator degradation directly to a contraction of the feasible tire-force region is a significant contribution. This provides a concrete way to quantify the impact of actuator faults on vehicle dynamics.
- Integrated Control is Essential: The success of the proposed method stems from its integration of generalized force generation and tire force allocation. By ensuring that the demanded forces are feasible before allocation, and then adaptively allocating them based on fault information, the system achieves robust control.
- Avoiding Excessive Actuator Use: In fault scenarios, the proposed method intelligently limits the steering angle of faulty wheels, preventing conflicts and avoiding the need for excessive torque from other actuators (like hub motors) to compensate. This leads to more stable and predictable behavior.
Key Results
The simulations demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed fault-tolerant control strategy:
- Improved Longitudinal Speed Tracking: In diagonal steering failure scenarios, the proposed method achieved significantly better tracking of the target longitudinal speed with less fluctuation compared to a standard comparison method.
- Superior Yaw Rate Tracking: The controller exhibited superior yaw rate tracking performance, with faster oscillation decay, particularly during critical transient periods.
- Controlled Steering Angle Response: The proposed method successfully restricted the faulty wheel's angle within normal ranges, preventing instability and conflicts with differential steering.
- Reduced Hub Motor Torque: In fault conditions, the proposed method required less hub motor torque to achieve comparable or better performance than the comparison method.
- Robustness to Split-Friction: Under split-friction conditions, the controller maintained stable longitudinal speed and yaw rate tracking, with less pronounced speed dips and oscillations compared to the baseline method. The tire load ratios indicated effective utilization of available forces, even on the faulty side.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the current model simplifies some aspects, such as neglecting the friction moment around the kingpin and the effect of lateral translating deformation of the carcass. The coupling between generalized forces under tire friction constraints is also temporarily ignored.
- Future Work: The authors suggest several avenues for future research:
- Incorporating factors like tire surface temperature and wear into the aligning-torque model to enhance its applicability.
- Evaluating the control strategy through vehicle-in-the-loop testing on a real vehicle.
- Exploring prescribed finite-time control combined with the proposed optimization-based FTC.
- Extending the approach to multi-vehicle platooning within a multi-agent framework.
Summary updated