Fault Diagnosis of Pumped Storage Units—A Novel Data-Model Hybrid-Driven Strategy

Jie Bai, Chuanqiang Che, Xuan Liu, Lixin Wang, Zhiqiang He, Fucai Xie, Bingjie Dou, Haonan Guo, Ruida Ma, Hongbo ZouProcesses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid data-model strategy for accurately diagnosing faults in pumped storage units using vibration signals. By enhancing traditional signal decomposition with spectral kurtosis and employing a CNN-LSTM model, the approach achieves over 95% fault diagnosis accuracy, crucial for maintaining the reliability of these vital power grid components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pumped storage units are essential for grid stability, especially with the rise of renewable energy. However, their complex internal dynamics, influenced by hydraulic, mechanical, and electrical factors, make them prone to faults. Diagnosing these faults is challenging due to intricate fault characteristics, signal interference, and high noise levels. Existing methods often struggle with early fault detection, rely heavily on human expertise, and lack robust generalization capabilities, leading to inaccurate and untimely diagnoses. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more accurate and automated fault diagnosis system.

Methods

The proposed strategy is a "data-model hybrid-driven" approach that combines advanced signal processing with a deep learning model.

  • Enhanced Signal Decomposition: The core of the signal processing involves improving the traditional Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) method. The authors integrate spectral kurtosis theory into EMD. This enhancement aims to achieve better decomposition of vibration signals and more effective noise reduction.
  • Feature Extraction: After decomposition, the intrinsic mode functions (IMFs) are reconstructed. The entropy values of these effective IMFs are then calculated. These entropy values serve as the fault feature vectors, capturing dynamic changes and nonlinear characteristics of the signals.
  • Fault Classification: A Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) hybrid model (CNN-LSTM) is employed for fault diagnosis. CNNs are used for feature extraction, while LSTMs are adept at processing sequential data, making them suitable for analyzing time-series vibration signals and capturing long-term dependencies.

Datasets

The paper utilizes actual operational data from pumped storage units in a specific region for verification and validation of the proposed method. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of EMD and Spectral Kurtosis: Combining spectral kurtosis with EMD proves effective in isolating critical fault features from noisy vibration signals, overcoming limitations of traditional EMD in complex mechanical systems.
  • Entropy as a Robust Feature: Using entropy values of reconstructed IMFs as feature vectors provides a rich representation of signal complexity and dynamics, proving more effective than traditional feature engineering.
  • CNN-LSTM for Temporal and Spatial Features: The CNN-LSTM architecture effectively leverages both the spatial feature extraction capabilities of CNNs and the temporal dependency modeling of LSTMs, leading to superior fault diagnosis performance for time-series vibration data.
  • Hybrid Approach Advantage: The integration of data-driven (deep learning) and model-driven (enhanced signal processing) aspects creates a more comprehensive and intelligent diagnostic system.

Key Results

The proposed data-model hybrid-driven strategy demonstrated fault diagnosis accuracy consistently above 95% on actual operational data from pumped storage units. This high accuracy was maintained even in complex engineering environments, significantly outperforming traditional methods like CNN, LSTM, and SVM in comparative tests.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Computational Complexity: The MCNN-LSTM model has high computational complexity and resource requirements, which might limit its applicability in scenarios demanding extremely high real-time performance.
  • Data Dependency: The model's performance is highly dependent on the quantity and quality of training data. Insufficient or biased data can compromise generalization ability.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: Optimizing the numerous parameters within the CNN-LSTM model (e.g., kernel size, stride, LSTM units) can be a complex and time-consuming process.
  • Known Fault Types: While effective for known fault types, the model's recognition capabilities for entirely new, unknown faults might be limited, requiring continuous updates to the fault feature library.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Exploring advanced algorithms like deep learning and reinforcement learning for enhanced accuracy and efficiency.
  • Investigating unsupervised learning for anomaly detection to identify potential faults without explicit labels.
  • Integrating multi-source data (vibration, temperature, pressure, flow rate, etc.) for a more comprehensive health monitoring system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pumped storage units serve as a crucial support for power systems to adapt to large-scale and high-proportion renewable energy sources by providing a stable and flexible energy supply. However, due to the coupling effects of electric power load demands and the complex multi-source factors within the water–mechanical–electrical system, the interrelationship between unit parameters becomes more intricate, posing significant threats to the operational reliability and health status of the units. The complexity of fault diagnosis is further aggravated by the intricate and varied nature of fault characteristics, as well as the challenges in signal extraction under conditions of strong electromagnetic interference and high noise levels. To address these issues, this paper proposes a novel data-model hybrid-driven strategy that analyzes vibration signals to achieve rapid and accurate fault diagnosis of the units. Firstly, the spectral kurtosis theory is employed to enhance the traditional empirical mode decomposition, achieving optimal decomposition and noise reduction effects for vibration signals. Secondly, the intrinsic mode functions (IMFs) obtained from the decomposition are reconstructed, and the entropy values of effective IMFs are calculated as fault feature vectors. Subsequently, the CNN-LSTM model is utilized for fault diagnosis. The effectiveness and feasibility of the proposed method are verified through actual operational data from pumped storage units in a specific region. Through analysis, the fault diagnosis accuracy of the method proposed in this paper can be maintained above 95%, demonstrating robustness in complex engineering environments and effectively ensuring the safe and stable operation of pumped storage units.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2024fault,
  author = {Jie Bai and Chuanqiang Che and Xuan Liu and Lixin Wang and Zhiqiang He and Fucai Xie and Bingjie Dou and Haonan Guo and Ruida Ma and Hongbo Zou},
  title = {{Fault Diagnosis of Pumped Storage Units—A Novel Data-Model Hybrid-Driven Strategy}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12102127},
}
Figure