Fatigue EEG Feature Extraction Based on Tasks With Different Physiological States for Ubiquitous Edge Computing

Xin Xu, Hong Gu, Shancheng Yan, Guihong Pang, Guan GuiIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Mental fatigue is a cumulative phenomenon that significantly impairs physiological activities, posing risks in ubiquitous edge computing environments like the Internet of Things. This study investigates fatigue induction through two levels of Stroop tasks and evaluates the resulting electroencephalogram (EEG) signals. Using wavelet packet decomposition and sample entropy, the research identifies key physiological markers. Results indicate that fatigue states exhibit higher $\alpha$ and $\theta$ wave relative energy and significantly lower $\beta$ wave energy. Notably, low-difficulty tasks induced more pronounced fatigue markers than high-difficulty tasks, suggesting that task engagement may inversely correlate with fatigue onset.

Introduction

Mental fatigue is a critical factor in high-stakes environments, including long-haul transportation and industrial monitoring. It manifests as a gradual decline in cognitive performance, leading to slower response times and coordination errors. To develop effective "ubiquitous edge computing" systems—such as real-time drowsiness detection in smart vehicles—objective physiological markers are essential. While subjective reports are common, they are often unreliable. This paper seeks to identify robust EEG features that signal the transition from alertness to fatigue under varying cognitive loads.

Methodology

The study employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze EEG data collected during cognitive performance tests.

Task Design

Participants performed two variations of the Stroop task:

  1. Low-Difficulty: Consistent colors and fonts (e.g., the word "Red" in red ink).
  2. High-Difficulty: Contradictory colors and fonts (e.g., the word "Red" in green ink), requiring higher cognitive interference resolution.

Signal Processing

  • Wavelet Packet Decomposition (WPD): Used to decompose non-stationary EEG signals into specific frequency bands: $\alpha$ (8–13Hz), $\beta$ (14–30Hz), $\theta$ (4–8Hz), and $\delta$ (0.5–4Hz).
  • Sample Entropy (SampEn): A non-linear algorithm used to measure signal complexity. High entropy reflects an alert, complex brain state, while lower entropy indicates the more rhythmic, predictable patterns associated with fatigue.
  • Feature Extraction: The researchers focused on energy ratios, specifically $F = \alpha/\beta$ and $R = (\alpha + \theta)/\beta$, as primary fatigue indices.

Datasets and Experimental Setup

The study involved 10 healthy volunteers (6 male, 4 female) aged 19–25. EEG recordings were captured from 10 specific channels (FP1, FP2, F7, F8, T7, T8, C3, C4, O1, O2) based on the international 10-20 system.

Standard 10-20 EEG electrode placement system used for data collection.

Subjective fatigue scales and behavioral metrics (accuracy and reaction time) were recorded every five minutes to provide ground-truth validation for the physiological data.

Key Insights and Results

The Boredom Paradox

One of the most significant findings was that low-difficulty tasks induced fatigue more rapidly and noticeably than high-difficulty tasks. The physiological shifts in EEG were more pronounced in the "easy" group, suggesting that higher cognitive engagement might actually delay the onset of mental fatigue.

Signal Simplification and Frequency Shifting

As fatigue progressed, brain activity became less complex, evidenced by a universal decrease in Sample Entropy across all monitored brain regions. For instance, in the low-difficulty group, mean entropy in the O1 (occipital) region dropped from 1.438 to 1.208. Simultaneously, energy shifted from "fast" $\beta$ waves (alertness) to "slow" $\alpha$ and $\theta$ waves (drowsiness).

Statistical Significance

The ratios $\alpha/\beta$ and $(\alpha + \theta)/\beta$ increased significantly ($P < 0.05$) during the transition to fatigue. These physiological changes correlated strongly with behavioral declines, such as increased reaction times and decreased accuracy.

Conclusion

The ratios $\alpha/\beta$ and $(\alpha + \theta)/\beta$ serve as effective indicators for measuring mental fatigue. The study highlights that task difficulty is inversely related to fatigue generation to a certain extent. Future work will focus on expanding the sample size and utilizing Deep Learning techniques to develop automated, high-accuracy fatigue recognition systems suitable for low-power IoT edge devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mental fatigue is a gradual and cumulative phenomenon that manifests in the weakening of human physiological activities for ubiquitous edge computing in the Internet of Things. In this paper, two groups of Stroop tasks with different difficulty levels are proposed to induce fatigue, which is evaluated via electroencephalogram (EEG). Wavelet packet decomposition and sample entropy algorithm are utilized to analyze the EEG signals in both sober and fatigue state. The experiment results show that compared with the sober state, the fatigue state has a higher α wavelet relative energy and 8 wavelet relative energy and significantly lower β wave relative energy (P <; 0.05). The ratio of parameters α/β and (α + 8)/β increases with the fatigue degree, and the sample entropy of each brain region shows a decreasing trend. Compared with the more difficult task group, the change of parameters in the low-difficulty task are more obvious. Hence, the suggested parameters α/β and (α + 8)/β can be used as potential indicators to measure mental fatigue, and the appropriate increase in the difficulty of the tasks may be inversely related to the generation of mental fatigue to some extent.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2019fatigue,
  author = {Xin Xu and Hong Gu and Shancheng Yan and Guihong Pang and Guan Gui},
  title = {{Fatigue EEG Feature Extraction Based on Tasks With Different Physiological States for Ubiquitous Edge Computing}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2920014},
}
Figure