Fate-mapping lymphocyte clones and their progenies from induced antigen-signals identifies temporospatial behaviours of T cells mediating tolerance

Munetomo Takahashi, Tsz Y. So, Kate E. Williamson, Zhaleh Hosseini, Katarzyna Kania, Michelle Ruhle, Tiffeney Mann, Martijn J. Schujis, Paul Coupland, Dean J. Naisbitt, Timotheus Y.f. Halim, Paul Lyons, Píetro Lió, Klaus Okkenhaug, David J. Adams, Kenneth G. C. Smith, Duncan I. Jodrell, Michael A. Chapman, James ThaventhiranbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "time-stamped" fate-mapping mouse model (AgRSR) that permanently marks immune cells the moment they receive an antigen signal. Using this tool, they discovered a striking "spatial partitioning" of immune tolerance: while regulatory T cells (Tregs) recirculate between tumors and the rest of the body to spread suppressive signals, killer CD8+ T cells become trapped within the tumor, where they sink into a permanent state of exhaustion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

To understand how the immune system responds to threats like cancer or autoimmunity, scientists need to track "clones"—groups of T cells descended from a single ancestor that all recognize the same target.

Current methods, like using fluorescent "tetramers," require researchers to already know exactly what the T cell is looking for (the antigen) and rely on high-affinity binding. This is a major hurdle in cancer and autoimmune research, where antigens are often "undefined" or "endogenous" (self-derived). Furthermore, existing tools struggle to track the progeny of these cells over time and across different tissues. We haven't had a clear way to see where a T cell was when it first "saw" its target and what happened to its descendants weeks later.

Methods

The authors created the AgRSR (Antigen-Receptor Signalling Reporter) mouse. This model uses the promoter of the Nur77 gene—which is only active when a T or B cell receives a signal through its antigen receptor—to drive two things:

  1. Katushka: A red fluorescent protein that acts as a "real-time" indicator of current signaling.
  2. Cre-ERT2: An enzyme that, when triggered by the drug tamoxifen, permanently switches on a yellow fluorescent reporter (EYFP) in the cell and all its future offspring.

By injecting tamoxifen at a specific time, the researchers can "highlight" every T cell active at that moment. They combined this fate-mapping with single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) and TCR sequencing to read the "molecular barcode" of individual clones and see their gene expression profiles across the spleen and the tumor.

Datasets

The study primarily utilized:

  • YUMMER1.7 Melanoma Model: A murine melanoma line used to study persistent immunological challenges.
  • scRNA-seq/scTCR-seq Data: High-resolution datasets capturing thousands of individual T cells from the spleen and tumors of AgRSR mice at 8 and 18 days post-activation.
  • Validation Models: OT-I TCR transgenic mice (for peptide specificity) and Listeria monocytogenes infection models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Recirculator" vs. "The Trapped": The most significant finding is the difference in "temporospatial" behavior between cell types. Tregs are highly mobile; they get activated in the tumor, differentiate into a potent suppressive state, and then head back into the blood and spleen. In contrast, CD8+ T cells that see antigen in the tumor stay there until they become exhausted.
  • Reversible vs. Irreversible States: When Tregs leave the tumor and move away from the antigen source, they transition back to a "lower tolerance" state. However, CD8+ T cells in the tumor move toward an "irreversible" state of exhaustion.
  • Localized Tolerance, Systemic Protection: This spatial partitioning explains a fundamental biological mystery: how the body can "tolerate" a tumor in one specific spot (via trapped exhausted CD8s and recirculating Tregs) without completely shutting down the immune system's ability to fight the same targets if they appear elsewhere as metastases.
  • Signal over Affinity: By tracking the signal (Nur77) rather than the receptor, the authors could see "low-avidity" clones that traditional tetramer methods would have missed, providing a much more complete picture of the immune repertoire.

Key Results

  • 100-fold Enrichment: The AgRSR system allowed for a 100-fold enrichment of antigen-responding cells in the spleen compared to standard sorting, making it possible to find rare "recirculating" clones.
  • Treg Dynamics: Almost all CD4+ T cell clones in the tumor were Tregs. While the majority of Treg clones were found in both the spleen and tumor, CD8+ clones were largely "tumor-exclusive."
  • Exhaustion Correlation: The study found that a clone's "tissue-residency" score (how much it stayed put) strongly correlated with its exhaustion score.
  • Temporal Shift: By day 18, the "cytotoxic" (killer) versions of T cell clones found on day 8 had vanished, replaced entirely by exhausted phenotypes within the tumor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on T cells: While the AgRSR mouse can also track B cells (which also use Nur77), this paper focused almost exclusively on T cell dynamics in a tumor context.
  • Tamoxifen Timing: The system relies on the timing of tamoxifen administration; if the drug isn't present during the window of antigen signaling, the "fate" won't be mapped.
  • Therapeutic Application: The authors suggest that promoting CD8+ recirculation or preventing Treg recirculation could synergize with existing immunotherapies, but these interventions haven't been tested yet.

The researchers envision this system being used to probe fundamental questions in autoimmunity and chronic infection, where the "where and when" of immune activation remains a black box.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Tissue homeostasis is maintained by the behaviours of lymphocyte clones responding to antigenic triggers in the face of pathogen, environmental, and developmental challenges. Current methodologies for tracking the behaviour of specific lymphocytes identify clones of a defined antigen-receptor—antigen binding affinity. However, lymphocytes can receive antigenic signals from undefined or endogenous antigens, and the strength of each signal, even for the same lymphocyte, varies with accessory signalling, across tissues and across time. We present a novel fate-mapping mouse, that, by tracking lymphocyte clones and their progenies from induced antigen signals, overcomes these hurdles and provides novel insights into the maintenance of tissue homeostasis. We demonstrate the systems use by investigating the maintenance of localised T cell tolerance in tumour immunity. In a murine tumour model, our system reveals how Tregs differentiate to a reversible, tolerance inducing state within the tumour, and recirculate, while CD8+ T cells failing to recirculate, differentiate to an increasingly exhausted, tolerant state in the tumour. These contrasting T cell behaviours provide means by which immunity can tolerate a particular anatomical niche while maintaining systemic clonal protection. Our system can thus explore lymphocyte behaviours that cannot be tracked by previous methods and will therefore provide novel insights into the fundamental mechanisms underlying immunity’s role in tissue homeostasis.
BibTeX
@misc{takahashi2023fate,
  author = {Munetomo Takahashi and Tsz Y. So and Kate E. Williamson and Zhaleh Hosseini and Katarzyna Kania and Michelle Ruhle and Tiffeney Mann and Martijn J. Schujis and Paul Coupland and Dean J. Naisbitt and Timotheus Y.F. Halim and Paul Lyons and Píetro Lió and Klaus Okkenhaug and David J. Adams and Kenneth G. C. Smith and Duncan I. Jodrell and Michael A. Chapman and James Thaventhiran},
  title = {{Fate-mapping lymphocyte clones and their progenies from induced antigen-signals identifies temporospatial behaviours of T cells mediating tolerance}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.16.532070},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure