Fast iterative regularization by reusing data

Cristian Vega, Cesare Molinari, Lorenzo Rosasco, Silvia VillaJournal of Inverse and Ill-Posed Problems 2022

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel iterative regularization methods for solving inverse problems with noisy data. The key innovation is the clever reuse of the linear data constraints within the iterative process, leading to significant speedups and improved reconstruction quality compared to existing methods, particularly for problems with non-smooth regularizers like L1-norm and total variation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world problems, such as image processing and compressed sensing, involve solving systems of linear equations where the available data is corrupted by noise. These are known as "inverse problems." A common approach to obtain a stable and meaningful solution is through regularization, which injects prior knowledge about the desired solution. While explicit regularization methods often require solving multiple optimization problems, iterative regularization methods offer a more efficient alternative by solving a single problem and stopping early. However, existing iterative methods can struggle with non-smooth or non-strongly convex regularizers. This paper addresses the challenge of developing efficient and robust iterative regularization methods that can handle such regularizers and achieve faster convergence by intelligently leveraging the available data constraints.

Methods

The authors propose two new iterative regularization methods based on primal-dual algorithms. The core novelty lies in "reusing data constraints," meaning the linear equations derived from the noisy measurements are utilized multiple times within each iteration. This is achieved by incorporating "activation operators" that project onto or otherwise utilize information from these linear constraints.

  • Primal-Dual Splitting with Activations (PDA): This method updates the dual variable, then performs a prox-step on the primal variable, followed by an activation step that reuses data constraints on the primal variable, and finally an extrapolation step.
  • Dual-Primal Splitting with Activations (DPA): This method is similar to PDA but activates operators on the dual variable instead of the primal.

The theoretical analysis provides convergence rates for the noise-free case and stability bounds and early-stopping rules for the noisy case. The authors also discuss various ways to implement these activation operators, including serial and parallel projections, and Landweber-type operators.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses standard synthetic data for experiments, specifically:

  • Sparse recovery: A sparse vector x* is generated, and a measurement vector b is created as b = Ax* + noise.
  • Image reconstruction: The "boat" image from the "Numerical tours" library is used for denoising and deblurring experiments, with synthetic blurring and noise added.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reusing Data Constraints is Powerful: The central idea that linear equations can be used multiple times within an iterative process is surprisingly effective. This "redundant information" is not just a minor tweak but leads to significant improvements.
  • Bridging the Gap for Non-Smooth Regularizers: The proposed methods show particular promise for convex but non-smooth regularizers (like L1-norm and Total Variation), which are common in many applications but challenging for some existing algorithms.
  • Early Stopping is Crucial for Stability: In the presence of noise, convergence to the exact solution is not expected. The paper rigorously derives early-stopping criteria that balance convergence and stability, providing theoretical guarantees for the quality of the reconstructed solution.
  • Primal-Dual Algorithms as a Flexible Framework: The primal-dual splitting framework proves to be a versatile platform for incorporating these data-reuse strategies, allowing for different activation operators and preconditioning techniques.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates significant improvements in both computational efficiency and reconstruction quality:

  • Speedup: The proposed methods, particularly PDAL (Primal-Dual Landweber with adaptive step), achieved substantial speedups. For instance, in the L1-norm regularization experiment, PDAL was significantly faster than Tikhonov regularization and Douglas-Rachford, while achieving comparable or better reconstruction error.
  • Reconstruction Quality: For image denoising and deblurring with Total Variation, PDAL and PDL (Primal-Dual Landweber) showed superior performance, reducing MSE by up to 94% compared to the noisy image.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical bounds for the Lagrangian gap and feasibility gap, along with early-stopping rules that offer stability and ensure the reconstructed solution is close to an ideal solution, even with noisy data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Noise Model: The theoretical analysis primarily considers a deterministic worst-case noise model (||b^ - b|| < δ). Extending the analysis to other noise models (e.g., stochastic noise) is a potential future direction.
  • Structured Convex Problems: The authors suggest extending the theoretical results to problems with more structured objective functions, such as those involving L-smooth terms and composite linear terms.
  • Random Updates: Investigating the analysis of random updates within the algorithms is another avenue for future research.
  • Strongly Convex Objectives: The paper mentions that the theoretical study of the impact of different preconditioners and the improvement of convergence and stability rates for strongly convex objective functions would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Discrete inverse problems correspond to solving a system of equations in a stable way with respect to noise in the data. A typical approach to select a meaningful solution is to introduce a regularizer. While for most applications the regularizer is convex, in many cases it is neither smooth nor strongly convex. In this paper, we propose and study two new iterative regularization methods, based on a primal-dual algorithm, to regularize inverse problems efficiently. Our analysis, in the noise free case, provides convergence rates for the Lagrangian and the feasibility gap. In the noisy case, it provides stability bounds and early stopping rules with theoretical guarantees. The main novelty of our work is the exploitation of some a priori knowledge about the solution set: we show that the linear equations determined by the data can be used more than once along the iterations. We discuss various approaches to reuse linear equations that are at the same time consistent with our assumptions and flexible in the implementation. Finally, we illustrate our theoretical findings with numerical simulations for robust sparse recovery and image reconstruction. We confirm the efficiency of the proposed regularization approaches, comparing the results with state-of-the-art methods.
BibTeX
@article{vega2022fast,
  author = {Cristian Vega and Cesare Molinari and Lorenzo Rosasco and Silvia Villa},
  title = {{Fast iterative regularization by reusing data}},
  journal = {Journal of Inverse and Ill-Posed Problems},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure