Fast First-Order Methods for Monotone Strongly DR-Submodular Maximization

Maryam Fazel, Omid SadeghiACDA 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and analyzes algorithms for maximizing a specific class of functions called "strongly DR-submodular" functions. These functions, which appear in areas like graph stability and machine learning inference, possess a "diminishing returns" property that is even stronger than usual. The authors propose new algorithms (SDRFW and an improved PGA) that exploit this stronger property to achieve faster convergence and better approximation guarantees than existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world optimization problems involve maximizing functions that exhibit "diminishing returns." This means that as you add more resources or elements, the additional benefit you get from each new addition decreases. Mathematically, this is captured by the "DR-submodular" property. While algorithms exist for maximizing these functions, this paper focuses on a more specialized, "strongly DR-submodular" class. These functions have an even more pronounced diminishing returns property, which implies they are "strongly concave along non-negative directions." This stronger structure is present in important applications like computing the stability number of a graph and in mean-field inference for probabilistic models. The challenge is to develop algorithms that can efficiently leverage this extra structure to achieve better performance (faster convergence and tighter approximation bounds) than general DR-submodular optimization methods.

Methods

The paper introduces two main algorithmic contributions:

  • SDRFW (Strongly DR-submodular Frank-Wolfe): This is a novel variant of the Frank-Wolfe algorithm. It's designed to exploit the strong DR-submodularity and bounded curvature of the objective function. A key aspect is its update rule, which involves a strongly concave maximization problem instead of the linear maximization typically found in standard Frank-Wolfe.
  • Projected Gradient Ascent (PGA) with Refined Analysis: The authors also analyze the standard Projected Gradient Ascent (PGA) algorithm but provide a sharper analysis that specifically leverages the strong DR-submodularity. This leads to improved approximation guarantees and a linear convergence rate, which is faster than the sub-linear rates typically seen for DR-submodular problems.

Additionally, the paper addresses a practical challenge:

  • Efficient Smoothness Parameter Estimation: Both SDRFW and PGA require knowledge of the "smoothness" parameter (L) of the objective function. The authors show how to formulate the computation of L as a convex optimization problem (specifically, a Geometric Program), which can be solved efficiently. This makes their algorithms more practical to implement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm development and analysis, with numerical experiments conducted on synthetic quadratic functions and graph-based problems (stability number).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stronger Structure, Better Algorithms: The core insight is that the "strong" DR-submodularity property isn't just a theoretical curiosity; it can be actively exploited by algorithms to achieve superior performance. This is analogous to how strong convexity leads to faster convergence in convex optimization.
  • SDRFW's Novel Update: The modification of the Frank-Wolfe update to involve a strongly concave maximization is a key algorithmic innovation. This allows the algorithm to "pull" towards the optimum more aggressively.
  • PGA's Hidden Potential: The refined analysis of PGA reveals that it can achieve linear convergence rates for strongly DR-submodular functions, which is a significant improvement over its performance on general DR-submodular functions.
  • Practicality through Parameter Estimation: The method for efficiently computing the smoothness parameter L is crucial for making these algorithms usable in practice, as estimating L can be a bottleneck.

Key Results

  • SDRFW Guarantee: The SDRFW algorithm achieves a provably optimal $(1 - \frac{1}{e})$ approximation ratio after $O(\frac{L}{\mu})$ iterations, where $\mu$ is the strong DR-submodularity parameter. This is a significant speedup compared to standard Frank-Wolfe variants.
  • PGA Guarantee: The analyzed PGA algorithm achieves an improved approximation ratio of $\frac{1}{1+c_f}$ and a linear convergence rate. For the DR-submodular case ($\mu=0$), it provides a better approximation ratio than prior work.
  • Online Setting: The paper also extends these ideas to the online setting, providing improved regret bounds for the Online Gradient Ascent (OGA) algorithm.
  • Numerical Validation: Experiments on synthetic quadratic functions and the graph stability number problem demonstrate that SDRFW and PGA outperform a standard Frank-Wolfe variant, validating the theoretical findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact Gradients: The algorithms assume access to exact gradients. The authors suggest extending this work to stochastic gradient methods, which would be more applicable when exact gradients are hard to compute.
  • Norm Dependence: The current analysis is primarily based on the Euclidean norm ($L_2$). The authors propose exploring extensions to other norms (e.g., $L_1$) and using mirror descent methods to adapt to different norms and potentially improve scalability for large-dimensional problems.
  • Domain Constraints: While the paper handles convex constraints, future work could explore more complex constraint sets.
  • Specific Applications: Further investigation into the application of these algorithms to specific real-world problems beyond those mentioned (graph stability, mean-field inference) could be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{fazel2023fast,
  author = {Maryam Fazel and Omid Sadeghi},
  title = {{Fast First-Order Methods for Monotone Strongly DR-Submodular Maximization}},
  booktitle = {ACDA},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1137/1.9781611977714.15},
}
Figure