Fast Convergence Rates of Distributed Subgradient Methods with Adaptive\n Quantization

Thinh T. Doan, Siva Theja Maguluri, Justin RombergarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In distributed optimization, communication bandwidth often limits the efficiency of network-wide coordination. While quantization reduces the data volume exchanged between nodes, it typically degrades convergence rates compared to unquantized communication. This paper introduces an adaptive quantization scheme that adjusts the quantizer's resolution as the algorithm progresses. We demonstrate that this approach allows distributed subgradient methods to match the convergence rates of perfect-communication scenarios, with the quantization penalty appearing only as a constant factor. Our analysis covers both convex and strongly convex objective functions, supported by numerical simulations in distributed regression tasks.

Introduction

Distributed optimization is a cornerstone of modern large-scale machine learning and sensor networks. In these systems, a network of nodes collaborates to minimize a global objective function, where each node possesses only a local component of the data. To reach a global consensus, nodes must iteratively exchange state estimates with their neighbors.

However, the physical reality of these networks involves significant communication constraints. High-precision data transmission is costly in terms of both time and energy. To mitigate this, quantization—the process of mapping continuous values to a finite set of discrete levels—is employed. Traditional fixed-resolution quantization schemes, however, introduce a fundamental trade-off: they either result in a persistent "steady-state error" or significantly slower convergence rates. This paper addresses the question: can we achieve the same convergence speed as unquantized systems while using only a few bits of communication?

The Adaptive Quantization Mechanism

The core innovation presented is the Adaptive Quantization scheme integrated into the Distributed Subgradient (DSG) method. This approach relies on two primary mechanisms:

1. The "Zoom-In" Strategy

Unlike static quantizers that use a fixed grid, the adaptive quantizer dynamically adjusts its range. As the optimization algorithm approaches the optimal solution, the step size $\alpha(k)$ decreases. Simultaneously, the adaptive scheme "zooms in" the quantization interval. By shrinking the grid as the nodes' estimates become more localized, the relative precision of the communication is maintained even as the absolute values of the updates become smaller.

2. Error Compensation

To prevent the accumulation of quantization noise, the algorithm incorporates an error compensation step. Each node tracks the difference between its actual state and the quantized value it transmits. This residual error is then factored back into the node's subsequent local update, ensuring that the quantization process does not introduce a permanent bias into the optimization trajectory.

Theoretical Convergence Rates

The paper provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for the performance of adaptive quantization across different classes of objective functions.

  • Convex Functions: For general convex objectives, the method achieves a convergence rate of $O(\frac{\ln k}{\sqrt{k}})$.
  • Strongly Convex Functions: For objectives with strong convexity (e.g., least squares regression), the rate improves to $O(\frac{\ln k}{k})$.

Crucially, these are the same orders of convergence achieved by unquantized distributed subgradient methods. The "cost" of using limited bandwidth is reduced to a constant factor that depends on the number of bits $b$ and the spectral gap of the network (a measure of how well-connected the nodes are). This implies that as long as a minimum bit-depth is maintained, the network will converge at the same fundamental speed as an infinite-bandwidth system.

Numerical Evaluation

The authors validated their theoretical findings through simulated distributed linear regression problems on a 50-node random undirected graph.

  • Quadratic Loss: Testing the strongly convex case, the adaptive method showed rapid convergence to the exact solution.
  • Absolute Loss: Testing the general convex case (robust regression), the method maintained its predicted $O(\frac{\ln k}{\sqrt{k}})$ rate.

The simulations revealed that using just 8 bits per transmission yielded results nearly identical to 64-bit floating-point precision. Even at lower resolutions (4-5 bits), the algorithm remained robust, requiring only a slight increase in total iterations to reach the same level of accuracy as unquantized methods.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research demonstrates that communication-constrained distributed optimization does not inherently require a sacrifice in convergence speed. By synchronizing the quantization resolution with the optimization step size, adaptive quantization bridges the gap between finite-bandwidth practicalities and theoretical ideal-communication performance.

While these results are promising, several avenues for future research remain. The current analysis assumes a static, doubly stochastic communication matrix, which may not hold in dynamic or directed real-world networks. Furthermore, extending this adaptive framework to other optimization algorithms, such as ADMM or Primal-Dual methods, could further broaden the applicability of high-efficiency distributed learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study distributed optimization problems over a network when the\ncommunication between the nodes is constrained, and so information that is\nexchanged between the nodes must be quantized. Recent advances using the\ndistributed gradient algorithm with a quantization scheme at a fixed resolution\nhave established convergence, but at rates significantly slower than when the\ncommunications are unquantized.\n In this paper, we introduce a novel quantization method, which we refer to as\nadaptive quantization, that allows us to match the convergence rates under\nperfect communications. Our approach adjusts the quantization scheme used by\neach node as the algorithm progresses: as we approach the solution, we become\nmore certain about where the state variables are localized, and adapt the\nquantizer codebook accordingly.\n We bound the convergence rates of the proposed method as a function of the\ncommunication bandwidth, the underlying network topology, and structural\nproperties of the constituent objective functions. In particular, we show that\nif the objective functions are convex or strongly convex, then using adaptive\nquantization does not affect the rate of convergence of the distributed\nsubgradient methods when the communications are quantized, except for a\nconstant that depends on the resolution of the quantizer. To the best of our\nknowledge, the rates achieved in this paper are better than any existing work\nin the literature for distributed gradient methods under finite communication\nbandwidths. We also provide numerical simulations that compare convergence\nproperties of the distributed gradient methods with and without quantization\nfor solving distributed regression problems for both quadratic and absolute\nloss functions.\n
BibTeX
@misc{doan2018fast,
  author = {Thinh T. Doan and Siva Theja Maguluri and Justin Romberg},
  title = {{Fast Convergence Rates of Distributed Subgradient Methods with Adaptive\textbackslash\{\}n Quantization}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1810.13245},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.13245},
}
Figure