Fast and Stronger Lower Bounds for Planar Euclidean Shortest Paths

Stefan Funke, Daniel Koch, Claudius Proissl, Christian Staib, Felix WeitbrechtIJCAI 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently computing Euclidean shortest paths (ESPs) in complex environments by introducing two key innovations: a method to simplify complex environments into smaller, "shrunken" versions that provide strong lower bounds for the original problem, and a highly efficient hub labeling technique for fast distance queries on the resulting visibility graphs. These advancements enable faster and more accurate pathfinding in large-scale digital models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Computing the exact Euclidean shortest path (ESP) in a plane with polygonal obstacles is a fundamental problem with applications ranging from robotics to navigation. However, for large and complex environments (like detailed 3D models of production halls or country-wide elevation maps), the standard approach of constructing a visibility graph becomes computationally infeasible due to the sheer number of vertices and edges. This makes it difficult to find optimal paths or even to assess the quality of approximate solutions. Existing methods either struggle with the scale of the problem or require significant computational resources. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing techniques to both simplify the problem instances and speed up the query process on the resulting structures.

Methods

The paper introduces two main contributions:

  • Shrinking ESP Instances for Lower Bounds: The core idea is to simplify complex obstacle polygons by "shrinking" them. This is achieved by iteratively cutting off convex corners of polygons until a desired level of simplification is reached. The crucial property is that the resulting simplified instance guarantees that any path distance in the simplified instance is a lower bound for the corresponding path distance in the original, more complex instance. This is achieved through a process that ensures the cut-off areas are within the polygon and uses a priority queue to manage which corners to cut. This allows for the construction of a visibility graph on a much smaller set of vertices, providing valuable lower bounds for approximate pathfinding algorithms.
  • Hub Labeling for Fast Queries: To efficiently query distances on these (potentially still large) visibility graphs, the authors adapt and optimize the hub labeling (HL) technique. Standard HL methods, while fast, have a significant space overhead. This paper proposes a novel reach-based level function to determine the "importance" of vertices, leading to significantly smaller hub labels. This approach, combined with an efficient one-to-all query scheme (Hub-Label-Scan or HLS), achieves query times orders of magnitude faster than Dijkstra's algorithm, with a space overhead comparable to the original visibility graph itself.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its methods on several datasets:

  • Coastline Data: Used for both shrinking and query performance evaluation, including a large instance with over 15 million obstacle vertices and subgraphs.
  • Urban Environment (Tokyo): Used to test shrinking, noting that its characteristics (many obstacles with few vertices) might make shrinking less impactful.
  • Game Maps: Several benchmark sets derived from game maps (Labyrinth, Expedition, Cauldron) were used for query performance evaluation.
  • Koch Snowflakes: An arrangement of Koch snowflakes was used as a benchmark.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but utilizes existing ones and refers to a companion page for source code and data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shrinking as a Lower Bounding Tool: The insight that simplifying geometry by removing vertices can provide mathematically guaranteed lower bounds is powerful. This is crucial for validating approximate pathfinding algorithms without needing to compute the exact (and often intractable) shortest path.
  • Reach as a Proxy for Importance: Using a "reach" metric (how "central" a node is in shortest paths) to determine vertex importance for hub labeling is a clever way to create more compact and efficient labels. This moves beyond simple degree-based heuristics.
  • Hub Labeling's Space Efficiency for Visibility Graphs: A key finding is that for visibility graphs, the space overhead of hub labeling is surprisingly manageable, often comparable to the visibility graph itself. This counters the common perception that HL is too space-intensive for practical use in such dense graph structures.
  • HLS for One-to-All Queries: The development of the Hub-Label-Scan (HLS) method provides a significant speedup for one-to-all distance queries, addressing a common bottleneck in applications requiring multiple path computations from a single source.

Key Results

  • Lower Bound Quality: The shrinking strategy, particularly with global shrinking and locking important vertices, achieved very low average errors (e.g., 0.083% for 1/200th of vertices) for lower bounds on coastline data. Locking 2% of important vertices further reduced errors by nearly half.
  • Query Speedup (Point-to-Point): The optimized hub labeling scheme achieved query times orders of magnitude faster than Dijkstra. For the largest "fullCoast" instance, queries dropped from 237ms to 3µs, a speedup of over 4 orders of magnitude.
  • Query Speedup (One-to-All): The HLS scheme provided a speedup of more than 30x compared to plain Dijkstra for one-to-all queries on the largest instance, reducing time from 479ms to 14ms.
  • Space Efficiency: The hub labeling approach achieved an average label size that allowed for space consumption comparable to the original visibility graph, making it practical for large instances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Shrinking Complexity: While the shrinking process is efficient (under 1 minute for tested instances), the paper notes that identifying "important" vertices by computing many shortest paths can be computationally expensive if exact pathfinding is used. They rely on approximate methods for this step.
  • Hub Labeling Construction Time: While query times are extremely fast, the construction time for hub labels can still be significant (e.g., 5 hours for the largest instance on their workstation).
  • Future Work: The paper suggests exploring further optimizations for hub label construction and investigating the application of these techniques to 3D environments, where shortest path problems become NP-hard and lower bounds are even more critical. The authors also hint at the potential for parallelizing parts of their algorithms.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{funke2025fast,
  author = {Stefan Funke and Daniel Koch and Claudius Proissl and Christian Staib and Felix Weitbrecht},
  title = {{Fast and Stronger Lower Bounds for Planar Euclidean Shortest Paths}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2025/946},
}
Figure