Farmers’ Attitudes and Perceptions and the Effects of the Grain for Green Project in China: A Case Study in the Loess Plateau

Xiang Li, Huifeng Guo, Guowei Feng, Bangbang ZhangLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates farmers' perspectives on China's "Grain for Green Project" (GGP), revealing that while the project has improved soil erosion and air quality, many farmers are dissatisfied due to insufficient subsidies and unmet needs. The findings highlight the critical role of understanding farmers' ecological awareness and individual needs for the successful implementation of future environmental policies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "Grain for Green Project" (GGP) is a large-scale ecological restoration initiative in China aimed at combating land degradation by converting farmland back to forest or grassland. While the project has been widely implemented for over two decades, there's a significant gap in understanding its impact from the perspective of the primary stakeholders: the farmers. Most evaluations focus on the physical outcomes (e.g., hectares reforested) rather than the socio-economic and perceptual impacts on the local population. This lack of farmer-centric evaluation hinders effective participatory planning and the long-term success of such environmental policies. The paper addresses this by exploring farmers' attitudes, satisfaction levels, and perceptions of ecosystem service changes resulting from the GGP, aiming to inform future policy design.

Methods

The study employed a mixed-methods approach, primarily relying on semi-structured interviews with 262 farmers across eight villages in Zhidan and Yanchang Counties, Shaanxi Province. This qualitative approach allowed for in-depth exploration of farmers' feelings and perceptions, going beyond simple yes/no answers. The interviews were structured around five key areas: personal characteristics, satisfaction with the GGP and reasons for acceptance, perceived changes after GGP implementation, ecological awareness, and willingness to participate in future GGPs. Statistical analysis, including descriptive statistics and an ordered probit model, was used to identify factors influencing farmers' satisfaction and willingness to participate.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected through semi-structured interviews with 262 farmers in Zhidan and Yanchang Counties, Shaanxi Province, China. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; the data was generated specifically for this research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Farmer dissatisfaction is a significant issue: Contrary to the assumption that a large-scale government project would be universally welcomed, a substantial portion of farmers expressed dissatisfaction with the GGP.
  • Subsidies are crucial, but not the only factor: While insufficient subsidies were a major reason for dissatisfaction, farmers also cited the "dense and uninteresting" nature of the reforested areas and a preference for traditional farming as contributing factors.
  • Perception of ecosystem services varies: Farmers clearly recognized improvements in soil erosion and air quality. However, their perceptions of improvements in water quality and biodiversity were mixed, with many reporting no change or even negative impacts on biodiversity.
  • Education and gender play a role: Higher levels of education correlated with greater satisfaction, while male farmers showed a higher willingness to participate in future GGP initiatives.
  • Ecological cognition matters: Farmers who understood the GGP's environmental benefits and believed in the responsibility to protect nature were more satisfied and willing to participate, especially if they also believed in protecting other living things.

Key Results

  • Satisfaction: 52% of farmers expressed satisfaction with the GGP, citing reduced flooding, improved environment, and increased income from working elsewhere. However, 34% were dissatisfied, primarily due to the density of reforested areas, preference for farming, and insufficient subsidies.
  • Perceived Ecological Benefits: 73% of respondents reported improvements in soil erosion, and 69% noted improvements in air quality. Conversely, only 38% perceived improvements in water quality, and 57% reported negative impacts on biodiversity.
  • Willingness to Participate: While willingness to participate in future GGPs was mixed (36% agreed, 33% disagreed), nearly 90% disagreed with participating in the GGP on abandoned farmland without subsidies, indicating a strong expectation of compensation.
  • Statistical Significance: The ordered probit analysis revealed that sex and education significantly influenced willingness to participate. Perceptions of biodiversity loss and soil erosion improvements positively impacted satisfaction. Ecological cognition, particularly believing the GGP to be beneficial, also strongly correlated with satisfaction and willingness to participate.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the sample size for their case study was relatively small, limiting the generalizability of findings to broader populations. They suggest that future research should involve a larger number of farmers and potentially explore more diverse regions. Additionally, the study highlights the need for policymakers to move beyond solely relying on subsidies and to better understand and address the specific needs and ecological perceptions of farmers to ensure the effectiveness and sustainability of environmental restoration projects. Future work could focus on developing more nuanced participatory planning frameworks that integrate these farmer-centric insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Grain for Green Project (GGP) aims to protect and improve the ecological environment, end farming on sloping farmland, and plant trees and restore forest vegetation. China’s GGP has been widely implemented, but its impact on the environment is rarely evaluated from farmers’ perspectives. This study took place in Zhidan and Yanchang Counties, Shaanxi Province. Farmers’ attitudes towards the GGP were investigated through semi-structured interviews to understand their perceptions of changes in ecosystem services and their level of ecological awareness, as well as analyzing which factors had the greatest impact on them. Our results indicate that some farmers are not satisfied with the GGP and are unwilling to participate in future GGPs, which is not only due to the dissatisfaction with subsidies offered but also because the needs of the farmers have been ignored. From the perspective of farmers, the GGP has greatly reduced soil erosion and air pollution but has had no effect on improving water quality and protecting biodiversity. More male farmers are willing to participate, and farmers with higher levels of education are more satisfied with the GGP. We also found that the level of understanding of ecological cognition affected farmers’ attitudes, and farmers with different levels of knowledge differ in their willingness to participate. Our research found that many farmers were dissatisfied with the GGP. To improve this situation, it is necessary to improve the ecological awareness of farmers. At the same time, policy makers should also further understand the needs of farmers in order to make reasonable management strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022farmers,
  author = {Xiang Li and Huifeng Guo and Guowei Feng and Bangbang Zhang},
  title = {{Farmers’ Attitudes and Perceptions and the Effects of the Grain for Green Project in China: A Case Study in the Loess Plateau}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11030409},
}
Figure