Families of DFAs as Acceptors of ω-Regular Languages

Dana Angluin, Udi Boker, Dana FismanLog. Methods Comput. sci 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Families of DFAs (FDFAs) as a novel and more succinct way to represent $\omega$-regular languages, which are crucial for modeling infinite behaviors in systems. The authors demonstrate that FDFAs offer a good balance between determinism and expressiveness, allowing for efficient Boolean operations and decision procedures, and bridging the gap between deterministic and nondeterministic $\omega$-automata in terms of succinctness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The theory of automata for infinite words ($\omega$-automata) is fundamental in areas like formal verification and synthesis of reactive systems. However, traditional $\omega$-automata, especially their deterministic variants, often suffer from a lack of a direct connection to the underlying algebraic structure of $\omega$-regular languages (like the Myhill-Nerode theorem for finite words). This gap has historically hindered the development of efficient learning algorithms for these languages. While recent work has proposed alternative representations, the authors investigate Families of DFAs (FDFAs) as a promising candidate that aims to bridge this gap, offering a more structured and potentially more succinct representation. The paper specifically asks:

  • How complex are Boolean operations (complementation, union, intersection) on FDFAs?
  • How complex are decision problems (emptiness, language containment) for FDFAs?
  • How do FDFAs compare in succinctness to standard $\omega$-automata?

Methods

The paper introduces and analyzes "saturated FDFAs," a specific type of FDFA that correctly characterizes $\omega$-regular languages. The core contributions and methods include:

  • FDFA Definition: An FDFA consists of a "leading" DFA that processes the prefix of an ultimately periodic word, and a set of "progress" DFAs, one for each state of the leading DFA, that process the periodic part. Acceptance is determined by the combined behavior on a normalized pair representing the $\omega$-word.
  • Boolean Operations: The authors provide algorithms for complementation, union, and intersection of saturated FDFAs. Complementation is shown to be a constant-space operation, similar to DFAs. Union and intersection are achieved through product constructions of the leading and progress automata.
  • Decision Procedures: Algorithms for membership, emptiness, and universality are presented. These are shown to be solvable in nondeterministic logarithmic space (NLOGSPACE).
  • Succinctness Analysis: The paper establishes the relative succinctness of FDFAs by providing polynomial translations from deterministic $\omega$-automata (DBA, DCA, DPA) to FDFAs and from FDFAs to nondeterministic $\omega$-automata (NBA). Crucially, they also show that the reverse translations (NBA to FDFA, FDFA to DPA) can involve an inevitable exponential blowup in the worst case.
  • Saturation Check: A method to determine if an arbitrary FDFA is saturated is presented, which can be solved in PSPACE.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical properties of automata and languages, rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Deterministic/Nondeterministic Gap: FDFAs offer a way to represent $\omega$-regular languages that is "mostly" deterministic but captures the expressiveness of nondeterministic automata. This is achieved by separating the processing of the prefix and the period of an ultimately periodic word.
  • Myhill-Nerode-like Property: Saturated FDFAs possess a property analogous to the Myhill-Nerode theorem for finite automata, which is crucial for learning algorithms.
  • Efficient Operations: The ability to perform Boolean operations and decision problems in NLOGSPACE is a significant practical advantage, making FDFAs computationally tractable.
  • Succinctness Trade-offs: FDFAs are shown to be exponentially more succinct than deterministic parity automata (DPAs) for certain languages, highlighting their power. However, translating from nondeterministic automata (like NBAs) to FDFAs can still lead to an exponential blowup, indicating that FDFAs don't entirely eliminate the complexity inherent in nondeterminism.
  • Saturation is Key: The concept of "saturation" for FDFAs is critical for them to accurately represent $\omega$-regular languages, and the paper provides a PSPACE algorithm to check for this property.

Key Results

  • Boolean Operations: Complementation, union, and intersection of saturated FDFAs can be performed in logarithmic space.
  • Decision Problems: Emptiness, universality, equality, and language containment for saturated FDFAs are NLOGSPACE-complete.
  • Translations:
    • Deterministic $\omega$-automata (DBA, DCA, DPA) can be translated to FDFAs with polynomial blowup.
  • FDFAs can be translated to Nondeterministic Büchi Automata (NBAs) with a polynomial blowup (specifically, $O(n^2k^3)$ states for an FDFA of size $(n,k)$).
  • Translating NBAs to FDFAs can involve an exponential blowup ($2^{\Omega(n \log n)}$).
  • Translating FDFAs to Deterministic Parity Automata (DPAs) can involve an exponential blowup.
  • Succinctness Example: A family of languages $\{L_n\}_{n \ge 1}$ is presented where an FDFA can be exponentially more succinct than a DPA. Specifically, an FDFA of size $(n+1, n^2)$ characterizes $L_n$, while any DPA recognizing $L_n$ requires at least $2^{n-1}$ states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Saturation Check Complexity: While the paper shows that checking if an FDFA is saturated is in PSPACE, it leaves open the question of whether it is PSPACE-complete.
  • Translating to DPAs: The paper notes that translating FDFAs to DPAs can involve an exponential blowup, and the complexity of this translation is a key aspect of their succinctness analysis.
  • Learning Algorithms: The paper builds upon prior work on learning algorithms using FDFAs and implicitly suggests that the efficient operations and succinctness of FDFAs further validate their use in learning. Future work could explore more advanced learning scenarios leveraging these properties.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{angluin2018families,
  author = {Dana Angluin and Udi Boker and Dana Fisman},
  title = {{Families of DFAs as Acceptors of ω-Regular Languages}},
  journal = {Log. Methods Comput. sci},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.23638/lmcs-14(1:15)2018},
}
Figure