TL;DR
This paper introduces "FairPlay," a novel dynamic pricing policy for hotels that aims to balance fairness for both customers and providers. By modeling the hotel market as a cooperative game and leveraging game-theoretic concepts like Owen values, FairPlay dynamically adjusts room prices based on supply, demand, and inter-hotel dependencies, preventing both over- and under-pricing.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The rise of online travel platforms has revolutionized the hotel industry, but current dynamic pricing policies (DPPs) often prioritize revenue maximization over fairness. This can lead to "overtourism" issues in popular destinations, where hotels drastically inflate prices during peak demand, making accommodation unaffordable for many and potentially harming local economies. Simultaneously, existing DPPs can disadvantage hotel providers by not fairly distributing exposure opportunities, leading to a concentration of business with a few providers and potentially causing others to leave the platform. This paper addresses the critical need for a pricing policy that ensures fairness for both customers (fair prices) and providers (fair exposure and profit opportunities) in the dynamic hotel market.
Methods
The core of FairPlay lies in its application of cooperative game theory, specifically the Owen value, to model and determine fair pricing and exposure.
- Dynamic Hotel-Rooms Game (DHRG): The hotel market is modeled as a dynamic cooperative game where each room is a player. The game's structure accounts for dependencies between rooms within the same hotel and between rooms of the same type across different hotels.
- Graph-Based Representation: To make the complex game tractable, an Induced Subgraph Game (ISG) representation is used. This allows for efficient computation of the Owen values.
- Fair Pricing Policy: Room prices are determined by a linear relationship with the room's Owen value and its Minimum Expected Price (MEP). The formula $C_s = u_s \cdot (1 + Ows)$ ensures that prices reflect the room's "power" (derived from demand and dependencies) and prevent profiteering.
- Provider Exposure Metric: An Exposure-Owen Ratio is introduced to fairly distribute exposure opportunities among hotels. This metric leverages the computed Owen values to ensure that hotels with higher collective room power receive proportional exposure, while guaranteeing every hotel gets at least some visibility.
Datasets
The authors evaluated their model using real-world datasets for three cities: Athens, Barcelona, and Rome. These datasets contain information on hotel names, cities, hotel stars, ratings, room types, prices, and location details. No new benchmarks were introduced; existing data was curated and prepared for the simulation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Simple Supply/Demand: FairPlay moves beyond basic supply and demand by incorporating inter-hotel and inter-room-type dependencies, leading to more nuanced and fair pricing.
- Preventing Profiteering: The model actively prevents hotels from exploiting peak demand by quadrupling prices, ensuring prices remain more aligned with overall market conditions and customer perception.
- Rewarding Quality: The pricing mechanism implicitly rewards higher-quality providers by allowing them to capture larger profit margins when their rooms are more in demand, reflecting their superior product.
- Fair Exposure is Crucial: Simply having a fair pricing policy isn't enough; providers also need fair opportunities to be seen by customers. The Exposure-Owen Ratio addresses this critical aspect.
- Game Theory as a Practical Tool: The paper demonstrates how sophisticated game-theoretic concepts like Owen values, often considered computationally intensive, can be made tractable and practically applicable through graph-based representations.
Key Results
- Fair Pricing: Simulations showed that FairPlay's dynamic pricing policy effectively reflects market supply and demand, avoiding the overpricing or underpricing tendencies observed with a static 17% profit margin policy. For instance, on "Day 5" in the Athens dataset, FairPlay allowed a 51.5% profit margin for a triple room, reflecting high demand, while a static policy would have offered a fixed 17%.
- Provider-Side Fairness: The Exposure-Owen Ratio metric demonstrated high similarity (over 85%) with rankings based on collective room power, indicating that hotels with stronger collective room power received proportional exposure.
- Quality Discrimination: The model successfully identified and rewarded higher-quality providers by assigning them larger profit margins, while penalizing lower-quality providers with tighter margins, thus promoting overall platform quality.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The current model's dependencies are primarily based on room types and availability.
- The simulation exposes only a subset of hotels (k) at a time, which can affect the dynamics and Owen value calculations.
- The model assumes a 30-day simulation period.
- Future Work:
- Extend the model to consider a wider range of features beyond room types, such as breakfast, hotel stars, and ratings.
- Apply the framework to other sectors of the hospitality industry (restaurants, bars) and beyond (e.g., airline tickets, salaries across companies).
- Incorporate neighborhood cost of living for fair pricing in long-term rentals.
- Explore more general graph-based representations for complex dependency structures.
Summary updated