Fairness-aware Graph Attention Networks

Öykü Deniz Köse, Yanning ShenIEEECONF 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces FairGAT, a novel Graph Attention Network (GAT) architecture designed to mitigate algorithmic bias in graph-based machine learning. By analyzing the theoretical underpinnings of bias in GATs and proposing a fairness-aware attention mechanism, FairGAT achieves improved group fairness without sacrificing predictive performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), particularly Graph Attention Networks (GATs), have become powerful tools for analyzing interconnected data. However, like many machine learning models, GNNs can inherit and even amplify existing biases present in the data, leading to unfair outcomes for different demographic groups. This bias often stems from the way GNNs aggregate information from neighboring nodes, which can inadvertently reinforce correlations between sensitive attributes (like gender or ethnicity) and node representations. While GATs offer flexibility by learning attention weights for neighbors, the impact of this attention mechanism on algorithmic bias has remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by theoretically analyzing the sources of bias in GATs and proposing a practical solution to mitigate it.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the development of FairGAT, a fairness-aware GAT framework. The approach is built upon a theoretical analysis that identifies specific factors within GATs contributing to algorithmic bias. Based on these findings, FairGAT incorporates three key components:

  1. Fair Attention Learning: This is the central innovation. Instead of a standard softmax attention mechanism, FairGAT employs a modified attention mechanism that optimizes for a fairness-related objective. This involves learning to distribute attention weights such that the influence of inter-group connections is balanced, thereby reducing bias amplification. This is achieved by solving an optimization problem to determine the optimal attention allocation between nodes with the same and different sensitive attributes.
  2. Spectral Normalization: To prevent the amplification of existing disparities, FairGAT applies spectral normalization to the weight matrices of the GAT layers. This technique constrains the largest singular value of these matrices to 1, effectively limiting how much the model can amplify input variations, including those related to sensitive attributes.
  3. Representation Scaling: The paper's theoretical analysis also highlights the role of maximal deviations in node representations. FairGAT addresses this by scaling the aggregated representations at each layer by a hyperparameter, allowing for a trade-off between fairness and utility.

Datasets

The proposed FairGAT framework was evaluated on several real-world datasets for both node classification and link prediction tasks:

  • Node Classification:
    • Pokec-z and Pokec-n: Social networks sampled from a larger dataset, where user region is used as the sensitive attribute.
  • Recidivism: A graph representing defendants released on bail, where ethnicity is the sensitive attribute.
  • Link Prediction:
    • Cora, Citeseer, and Pubmed: Citation networks where article categories are used as sensitive attributes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bias Amplification in GATs: The paper provides a theoretical analysis demonstrating that the attention mechanism in GATs, while beneficial for learning, can inadvertently amplify existing biases in graph data.
  • Fair Attention as a Solution: The core insight is that by carefully designing the attention mechanism to balance information flow between nodes with different sensitive attributes, algorithmic bias can be effectively mitigated.
  • Synergy of Fairness Techniques: FairGAT combines multiple fairness-enhancing strategies (fair attention, spectral normalization, representation scaling) to achieve robust fairness improvements.
  • Trade-off Management: The framework explicitly incorporates hyperparameters that allow for a controlled trade-off between fairness and predictive utility, acknowledging that perfect fairness might come at the cost of performance.

Key Results

  • Node Classification: FairGAT significantly improved fairness metrics (statistical parity and equal opportunity) by 30-60% compared to the naive GAT baseline across all datasets. It also consistently outperformed other fairness-aware baselines (FairGNN, EDITS, NIFTY) in terms of equal opportunity. While FairGAT achieved the best statistical parity on Pokec-n, it showed comparable or slightly better performance on other datasets, often with lower standard deviations, indicating better robustness.
  • Link Prediction: FairGAT demonstrated promising results for link prediction, outperforming the FairDrop baseline in fairness measures while maintaining similar or better utility.
  • Efficiency: The proposed fair attention mechanism adds negligible computational overhead compared to standard GATs, making it an efficient solution.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Multiple Sensitive Attributes: The current analysis and framework primarily focus on binary sensitive attributes. The authors suggest extending the analysis to cases with multiple, non-binary sensitive attributes as a future direction.
  • Aggregation Schemes: The theoretical analysis is based on mean aggregation. Future work could explore bias analysis for other aggregation schemes in GNNs.
  • Nodal Feature Bias: The paper acknowledges that the disparity in nodal features (δx) is not directly addressed by FairGAT but suggests it can be mitigated by combining FairGAT with existing fairness-aware nodal feature manipulation strategies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kose2022fairness,
  author = {Öykü Deniz Köse and Yanning Shen},
  title = {{Fairness-aware Graph Attention Networks}},
  booktitle = {IEEECONF},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/ieeeconf56349.2022.10052007},
}
Figure