Abstract
Course Recommendation Systems (CRS) often perpetuate historical biases present in educational data. This paper introduces FaiREO (Fairness for Equality of Opportunity), a framework that treats course recommendations as critical educational opportunities. By formulating the problem as a multi-objective optimization task, FaiREO balances recommendation quality with group-level fairness. We propose several Greedy Hill Climbing (GHC) algorithms, including a robust Tabu search variant, to navigate the trade-off between accuracy and equity. Evaluations on synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate that FaiREO can significantly reduce group bias with minimal impact on recommendation quality.
Introduction
Course Recommendation Systems (CRS) are essential for helping students navigate complex academic landscapes. However, these systems often rely on historical enrollment data, which can reflect and amplify societal biases. For instance, if certain demographics were historically discouraged from specific fields, a standard CRS might continue to under-recommend those courses to those groups, creating a self-reinforcing cycle of inequality.
The authors of FaiREO argue that a recommendation is more than just a prediction; it is an opportunity. If a student is never shown a specific course, they might never consider a career path that course could open. While previous research has focused on item-side or individual fairness, FaiREO addresses "user-group" fairness—ensuring that protected groups (based on gender, race, or socioeconomic status) receive equally high-quality and diverse opportunities.
Methodology
FaiREO (Fairness for Equality of Opportunity) balances two primary objectives: maintaining recommendation quality and ensuring equitable distribution of opportunities across student groups. These are combined into a single objective function $V = \alpha O + (1-\alpha)Q$, where $O$ represents the Opportunity Objective, $Q$ represents the Quality Objective, and $\alpha$ is a tunable trade-off parameter.
To solve this combinatorial optimization problem, the authors introduced several Greedy Hill Climbing (GHC) algorithms:
- GHC(NoNe): An exhaustive search that evaluates every possible course swap.
- GHC(Gc): A targeted heuristic that focuses on the most "unfairly" treated groups and courses to improve efficiency.
- GHC-Inc: An incremental approach that gradually increases the fairness weight ($\alpha$) to find stable solutions.
- GHC-Tabu: An advanced variant using a "Tabu list" (short-term memory of recent moves) to avoid local optima, allowing the algorithm to explore the solution space more effectively.
Datasets
The framework was evaluated using two types of data:
- Synthetic Datasets: Six families of synthetic data (Uni, Gauss) were created with varying "difficulty" levels. "Course buckets" were introduced to simulate scenarios where certain courses naturally have higher scores for specific groups, testing the algorithms' ability to break these biases.
- Real-World "ComptSci" Dataset: Ten years of anonymized student data from the University of Minnesota. Socioeconomic status was simulated using entry registration and transfer credits, categorizing students into HS, HSAP, and NAS groups.
Results and Key Insights
- Significant Bias Reduction: In synthetic datasets with high initial unfairness (up to 45%), FaiREO algorithms eliminated bias while incurring only a ~10% quality loss.
- Real-World Success: On the University of Minnesota dataset, the algorithms reduced unfairness from 16.5% to less than 2%, with less than 10% degradation in recommendation quality.
- Algorithm Performance: GHC-Tabu and GHC-Inc emerged as the most effective. GHC-Tabu's ability to escape local optima made it the most robust choice across different data distributions.
- Fairness Trade-offs: The study confirms that fairness isn't "free"; achieving equity requires swapping some high-scoring recommendations for those that better balance group distribution.
Conclusion
FaiREO demonstrates that significant improvements in user-group fairness are achievable in course recommendation systems with manageable trade-offs in quality. By treating recommendations as opportunities, the framework provides a path toward more equitable educational outcomes. Future work will explore the long-term impact of these constraints on student feedback loops and investigate more complex definitions of opportunity.
Summary updated