TL;DR
This paper introduces fairMARS, a novel approach to building fair and interpretable regression models by integrating fairness constraints directly into the Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines (MARS) algorithm. By modifying knot selection and coefficient estimation, fairMARS aims to reduce prediction disparities across sensitive subgroups without sacrificing accuracy, addressing a critical need for ethical AI in high-stakes domains like education.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Predictive analytics are increasingly used to inform crucial decisions in fields like education, healthcare, and finance. However, many of these models are proprietary and opaque ("black boxes"), making it difficult to assess their fairness, identify biases, and ensure ethical deployment. This lack of transparency and interpretability hinders accountability and can lead to models that exacerbate existing societal inequities. While significant progress has been made in ensuring fairness in classification tasks, fair regression models, which predict continuous outcomes (e.g., student grades, income), remain a less explored but equally important area. Existing fair regression methods often rely on parametric assumptions or lack interpretability, leaving a gap for robust, transparent, and fair models that can handle complex, non-linear relationships.
Methods
The core innovation is the development of fairMARS, which extends the existing MARS algorithm. MARS is a powerful non-parametric regression technique known for its ability to handle non-linear relationships, perform feature selection, and generate interpretable decision rules. fairMARS enhances MARS in two key ways:
- Fairness-Aware Knot Selection (
fairknot): The algorithm modifies the knot optimization process (both forward selection and backward elimination) by incorporating fairness constraints into the objective function. Instead of solely minimizing the residual sum of squares (RSS), it now balances RSS with a measure of subgroup disparity (absolute error difference). This encourages the selection of knots that not only improve model fit but also reduce prediction differences between sensitive groups. - Fairness-Aware Coefficient Estimation (
faircoef): The loss function used for estimating model coefficients is modified to incorporate weights. These weights reflect the proportional distribution of observations within each sensitive subgroup, effectively transforming the standard least-squares regression into a weighted least-squares approach. This aims to ensure that the model's coefficients are estimated in a way that accounts for subgroup representation.
The paper also proposes a theoretical justification for fairknot using a lemma and proposition that demonstrate how specific knot placements can influence basis functions to differentially affect subgroups.
Datasets
The paper evaluates fairMARS on three diverse real-world datasets:
- ELS Dataset (Education Longitudinal Study of 2002): Uses "race" as a sensitive attribute and "GPA" as the response variable.
- Crime Dataset: Uses "race" as a sensitive attribute and "crimes per capita" as the response variable.
- Student Performance Dataset: Uses "gender" as a sensitive attribute and "final grade" as the response variable.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Direct Integration of Fairness: The paper argues for and demonstrates the effectiveness of integrating fairness directly into the model's learning process (in-processing) rather than relying solely on pre- or post-processing. This allows for a more holistic approach to balancing accuracy and fairness.
- MARS as a Fair Model Foundation: MARS's inherent interpretability, ability to handle non-linearities, and feature selection capabilities make it a strong candidate for building fair models.
fairMARSleverages these strengths to create models that are both accurate and understandable. - Trade-off Management: The introduction of a regularization parameter ($\lambda$) allows users to explicitly control the trade-off between accuracy (RSS) and fairness (subgroup disparity), providing flexibility for different application contexts.
- Efficiency:
fairMARSdemonstrates remarkable efficiency, with significantly faster fold times compared to other fair regression methods likefairDT, making it more practical for real-world deployment.
Key Results
- Accuracy Maintained: In experiments,
fairMARSgenerally maintained comparable or even improved accuracy (measured by MSE and R²) compared to the original MARS model across various datasets and fairness configurations. - Reduced Disparity: The proposed
fairMARSapproach, particularly when usingfairknot, effectively reduced subgroup absolute error differences, indicating improved fairness. - Efficiency Gains:
fairMARSachieved significantly faster computation times (minutes per fold) compared tofairDT(hours per fold) on the evaluated datasets. - Interpretable Rules: The
fairMARSmodel, like standard MARS, generates interpretable decision rules, aiding in understanding how predictions are made and why certain outcomes occur for different subgroups.
Limitations and Future Work
- Choice of Fairness Metric: The paper primarily focuses on "absolute error difference" as the fairness metric. While justified for regression, the authors acknowledge that other fairness definitions exist and might be relevant depending on the specific application.
- Trade-off Tuning: The optimal value of the regularization parameter ($\lambda$) needs to be carefully chosen to balance fairness and accuracy. While the paper explores a range of $\lambda$ values, finding the "best" balance can be context-dependent.
- Generalization to Complex Fairness Notions: While effective for reducing disparities based on single sensitive attributes, future work could explore extending
fairMARSto handle intersectional fairness (bias across combinations of attributes). - Further Empirical Validation: While the paper presents results on three datasets, broader empirical validation across a wider range of regression tasks and sensitive attributes would strengthen the findings.
Summary updated