TL;DR
This paper introduces "compact bundles" as a new way to define "nicely structured" allocations in fair division problems involving graph-structured items. They prove that checking for fair and compact allocations is computationally hard in many cases, but develop efficient algorithms for graphs with bounded treewidth, offering a more flexible alternative to previous "connected bundle" requirements.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The field of fair division typically deals with allocating indivisible items (like goods or tasks) among agents, ensuring fairness according to various criteria (e.g., proportionality, envy-freeness). However, in many real-world scenarios, these items are not independent but are related to each other, often representable by a graph. For instance, items could be rooms in a building, and the graph shows adjacency. Previous work on "fair division of graphs" focused on ensuring each agent receives a connected subgraph. While useful, this can sometimes lead to awkward bundles. This paper addresses this limitation by proposing "compactness" as an alternative structural constraint, aiming to ensure agents receive bundles of "closely related" items, and then investigates the computational complexity of achieving fair allocations under this new constraint.
Methods
The core of the paper lies in defining and analyzing "compact graphs" and "compact allocations." A graph is (α, β)-compact if its vertices can be covered by α balls of radius β. This is a generalization of connectivity. The authors then study the computational complexity of finding fair allocations (proportional, envy-free, maximin share) where each agent's bundle induces an (α, β)-compact subgraph.
Key methodological contributions include:
- Formalizing Compactness: Introducing (α, β)-compact and strongly (α, β)-compact graph definitions.
- Complexity Analysis: Proving NP-hardness results for proportionality and envy-freeness under compact bundle constraints, especially for cases with α ≥ 3.
- Algorithmic Development: Designing efficient algorithms, particularly for graphs with bounded treewidth. This involves a sophisticated dynamic programming approach over tree decompositions, which is a standard technique for solving graph problems efficiently on restricted graph classes. They also provide XP algorithms parameterized by the number of agents and maximum degree.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical complexity and algorithmic design, not empirical evaluation on specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Compactness as a Flexible Alternative: Compactness offers a more nuanced way to ensure "relatedness" of items within an agent's bundle compared to strict connectivity, which can be too restrictive or lead to undesirable bundle shapes.
- Bridging Graph Theory and Fair Division: The paper effectively leverages concepts from graph theory (like distance, balls, treewidth, tree decompositions) to tackle problems in fair division, opening up new avenues for research.
- Treewidth as a Powerful Parameter: The development of dynamic programming algorithms parameterized by treewidth highlights its utility in solving complex combinatorial problems like fair division on structured inputs.
- Trade-offs Between Fairness and Structure: The NP-hardness results demonstrate that achieving both fairness and specific structural constraints (like compactness) simultaneously can be computationally challenging.
Key Results
- NP-Hardness: Checking for proportional and envy-free allocations with (α, β)-compact bundles is strongly NP-hard for α ≥ 3, even for edgeless graphs.
- Tractability for Bounded Treewidth: For any fixed α and β, algorithms with runtime (tw + n)^(O(tw+n)) * W^(O(n^2)) are provided for proportionality, envy-freeness, and maximin share guarantees, where 'tw' is the treewidth of the graph, 'n' is the number of agents, and 'W' is the maximum agent utility. This makes the problem tractable for graphs with small treewidth.
- Tractability for Planar Graphs: On planar graphs, the algorithms achieve pseudo-XP complexity parameterized by 'n', leveraging the fact that planar graphs have bounded treewidth related to their diameter.
- Special Case (α=1, β=0): When each agent can receive at most one item (α=1, β=0), the problems are polynomial-time solvable, reducible to matching problems.
Limitations and Future Work
- Strong NP-Hardness for α ≥ 3: The strong NP-hardness results hold for α ≥ 3. The complexity for α=2 remains open for envy-freeness.
- Strong Compactness: While hardness results extend to "strongly compact" variants, algorithmic results for these are not explicitly detailed.
- General Valuations: Some algorithmic results assume integer-valued valuations; extending them to arbitrary valuations is a potential future direction.
- Exploring Other Structures: The authors suggest investigating other "nice structures" for bundles beyond connectivity and compactness.
- Algorithmic Extensions: Investigating if the algorithmic techniques can be extended to the strongly compact setting is also proposed.
Summary updated