Abstract
Nonoperative management (NOM) is the standard of care for hemodynamically stable patients with blunt splenic injuries. However, the presence of a "contrast blush" (CB) on CT—indicating active extravasation—complicates this approach in low-grade (Grade I–II) injuries. This multicenter retrospective study by the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma (EAST) quantifies the failure rate of NOM in this specific population, finding a 20% failure rate that suggests these injuries behave more like Grade III injuries than the Grade IV classification currently proposed by some guidelines.
Introduction
Splenic injuries are a hallmark of blunt abdominal trauma. While splenectomy was once the default, modern trauma care emphasizes organ preservation through NOM to maintain immune function. A significant clinical challenge arises when CT imaging reveals a contrast blush (CB), signifying active arterial bleeding or pseudoaneurysm. The 2018 American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) guidelines suggested upgrading any injury with a CB to Grade IV. However, the actual risk profile of a Grade I or II injury with a small blush remained poorly defined. This study aims to determine if these low-grade injuries with CB truly warrant a high-grade classification or if they behave more moderately.
Methods and Patient Cohort
Researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study across 21 trauma centers using the REDCap tool. The study included adult patients (≥18 years) with AAST Grade I or II splenic injuries and documented CB on initial CT. Patients with hemodynamic instability (SBP < 90 mmHg), known coagulopathies, or those requiring immediate surgery for other injuries were excluded.
The primary endpoint was "failure of NOM," defined as the requirement for an unplanned surgical intervention (splenectomy) or angioembolization.
Key Results
Out of the 145 patients analyzed, 29 (20%) failed NOM. There was no statistically significant difference in failure rates between Grade I (18.2%) and Grade II (21.1%) injuries, suggesting that the presence of the blush is a more critical prognostic factor than the laceration grade itself.
Most failures (69%) occurred within the first 12 hours of admission. Patients who failed NOM experienced significantly longer hospital stays (median 8 vs. 5 days) and required more blood transfusions (55.2% vs. 25.9%) compared to those successfully managed without intervention.
Discussion and Clinical Implications
The 20% failure rate observed in this study is substantial. While AAST 2018 guidelines suggest these injuries should be classified as Grade IV (which typically sees failure rates around 33%), the data here suggests they behave more like Grade III injuries. The authors propose that "downgrading" the classification of low-grade injuries with CB to Grade III might prevent over-treatment while still signaling the need for close monitoring or early intervention.
The study also highlights that the risk of failure diminishes significantly after the first 48 hours. Clinicians should maintain a high index of suspicion and consider early angioembolization for these patients, especially within the first 12 hours of arrival.
Limitations
The retrospective nature of the study introduces potential inconsistencies in radiologic interpretation and documentation. Furthermore, the exclusion of patients on major anticoagulants limits the generalizability of these findings to the geriatric trauma population. Prospective studies with centralized CT review are recommended to further refine splenic injury grading systems.
Summary updated