Failure modes and mechanisms of layered h-BN under local energy injection

Ping Liu, Qing‐Xiang Pei, Yong‐Wei ZhangScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers used molecular dynamics simulations to resolve conflicting experimental reports on how hexagonal Boron Nitride (h-BN) fails under local energy injection (like electron beams). They discovered that thinner h-BN films are actually more resilient to heat than thicker ones, and that failure follows a specific progression from internal swelling to surface "hillocks" and finally to the formation of pits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hexagonal Boron Nitride (h-BN) is the "wonder insulator" of the 2D materials world. It is chemically inert, thermally stable, and mechanically robust, making it an ideal dielectric for next-generation nanoelectronics. However, these devices are often processed or characterized using high-energy electron beams or lasers.

Previous experimental studies on how h-BN breaks down under these beams produced confusing, contradictory results. Some researchers observed layer-by-layer peeling, others saw the formation of deep pits, and some reported "hillocks" (surface protrusions). This paper aims to provide a unified physical mechanism that explains these different failure modes by simulating the atomic-level response to local heat injection.

Methods

The authors employed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations using the LAMMPS package.

  • The Model: They built a heterostructure consisting of 1–10 layers of h-BN sitting on a five-layer graphene substrate.
  • Energy Injection: To simulate an electron beam, they "injected" kinetic energy into a cylindrical zone (1 nm radius) through the h-BN layers.
  • Potentials: They used the Tersoff potential to model the strong covalent bonds within the layers and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential for the weaker van der Waals forces between layers.
  • Variables: The study systematically varied the number of h-BN layers, the heat injection rate, the presence/location of atomic vacancies (defects), and the thermal boundary conditions.

Datasets

As a computational physics study, this paper does not use external training datasets. Instead, it generates primary data through MD simulations. The "benchmarks" here are the physical properties (like thermal conductivity) of h-BN and graphene, which were validated against existing literature to ensure the simulation's accuracy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Thickness Paradox: Counter-intuitively, thinner h-BN films take longer to fail than thicker ones. This is because the underlying graphene substrate acts as a highly efficient heat sink. In a monolayer, heat escapes into the graphene immediately. In a 10-layer film, the middle layers are "insulated" from both the substrate and the surface, causing heat to accumulate rapidly.
  • Defects as Heat Traps: Failure almost always starts at a defect site (boron or nitrogen vacancies). These defects cause "phonon localization," meaning heat vibrations get trapped around the vacancy rather than dissipating, leading to a localized "meltdown" much sooner than in a pristine crystal.
  • The "Hillock-to-Pit" Evolution: The paper reconciles conflicting experimental observations by showing they are often stages of the same process.
  • In monolayers, atoms simply vaporize, leaving a hole.
  • In multilayers, internal layers melt and vaporize first. The resulting gas pressure pushes the top layers upward, creating a hillock (swelling). If heating continues, the pressure causes the top layers to burst, forming a pit.
  • Defect Interaction: When multiple defects are present in different layers, they "talk" to each other. Their localized heat zones overlap, accelerating the failure process beyond what a single defect would cause.

Key Results

  • Failure Timing: For a pristine sample, the failure start time ($t_F$) dropped from 246.25 ps for a monolayer to 135.75 ps for a 10-layer film under the same energy flux.
  • Defect Impact: Introducing a single Boron vacancy in a 10-layer film reduced the failure time from ~136 ps to 99.3 ps.
  • Location Matters: Defects near the top surface are more dangerous than those near the graphene substrate. A vacancy in the top layer caused failure at 87.5 ps, while one in the 9th layer (near the substrate) lasted until 115.25 ps.
  • Boundary Effects: The researchers found that if the lateral edges of the h-BN are kept cool (efficient heat draining), the material can reach a steady state where it never fails, highlighting the importance of thermal management in device design.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few areas for further exploration:

  • Beam Geometry: The simulation assumes a vertical, cylindrical energy injection. Real-world electron beams might have different profiles or incident angles.
  • Defect Variety: The study focused primarily on point vacancies. Future work could look at more complex structural flaws like grain boundaries or dislocations, which are common in large-scale CVD-grown h-BN.
  • Chemical Environment: The simulations were conducted in a vacuum-like environment. In reality, ambient gases or specific substrates might interact chemically with the h-BN during the heating process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Layered h-BN may serve as an important dielectric and thermal management material in the next-generation nanoelectronics, in which its interactions with electron beam play an important role in device performance and reliability. Previous studies report variations in the failure strength and mode. In this study, using molecular dynamics simulations, we study the effect of local heat injection due to the electron beam and h-BN interaction on the failure start time and failure mode. It is found that at the same heat injection rate, the failure start time decreases with the increase in the layer number. With the introduction of point defects in the heating zone, the failure always starts from the defect site, and the start time can be significantly shortened. For monolayer h-BN, failure always starts within the layer, and once failure starts, its propagation is through melting or vaporization of the h-BN atoms, and no swelling occurs. For multiple layers, once failure starts within the h-BN film, swelling occurs first. With continued heating, the large pressure induced by melting and vaporization can cause the burst of the layers above, leading to the formation of a pit. In the presence of multiple defects within the heating zone, these defects can interact, causing a further reduction in the failure start time. We also reveal the relation of beam power with layer-by-layer failure mode and swelling/pit formation mode. The present work not only reproduces many interesting experimental observations, but also reveal several interesting mechanisms responsible for the failure processes and modes. It is expected that the findings revealed here may provide useful references for the design and engineering of h-BN for device applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022failure,
  author = {Ping Liu and Qing‐Xiang Pei and Yong‐Wei Zhang},
  title = {{Failure modes and mechanisms of layered h-BN under local energy injection}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-16199-y},
}
Figure