Factors that influence the preferences for telehealth among family caregivers of disabled elders: a qualitative study

Lina Guan, Guijuan Zhang, Yuyang Yi, Yaqin Liang, Xiaochun Zou, Bingsheng Guan, Yanya Chen, Wai‐Kit MingInternational Journal of Nursing Studies Advances 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This qualitative study explores the barriers and facilitators influencing family caregivers' preferences for telehealth services for disabled elders. It reveals that while convenience and professionalism are key drivers, challenges like learning capacity, cost, and habituation to traditional care significantly hinder adoption, highlighting the need for user-centered telehealth design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Family caregivers of disabled elders often face significant burdens, lacking adequate support. Telehealth offers a potential solution to alleviate this strain by providing remote healthcare services. However, the adoption of telehealth among this specific demographic remains limited, and the underlying reasons are not well understood. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by investigating the factors that influence family caregivers' preferences for using telehealth in their caregiving roles, particularly within a non-Western context.

Methods

The study employed a qualitative, interpretivist approach, utilizing semi-structured focus group interviews. Four focus groups were conducted with a total of 20 family caregivers of disabled older adults. The data was analyzed thematically using NVivo software, following Braun and Clarke's six-step analysis process. The researchers aimed for credibility, transferability, and conformity by using methods like member checking and iterative discussions among the research team.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Digital Divide" is Multifaceted: It's not just about access to technology, but also about the perceived ability to learn and use it, especially for older caregivers.
  • Habituation is a Powerful Force: Long-standing reliance on traditional, in-person medical care creates a significant inertia against adopting new telehealth methods, even if the latter offers benefits.
  • Trust is Paramount: Caregivers need to trust the telehealth platform and the professionals involved. Concerns about privacy, scams, and the authenticity of online interactions are major deterrents.
  • Telehealth is Not a Panacea: While it can offer convenience, it's not seen as a replacement for the comprehensive, hands-on care provided by professional settings like nursing homes, especially for complex conditions.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis is Crucial: Caregivers are highly sensitive to the financial implications of telehealth, especially when costs are perceived as high or unpredictable compared to traditional care.

Key Results

The study identified two overarching themes: barriers and facilitators to telehealth use among family caregivers.

Barriers (12 subthemes):

  • Learning Capacity: Difficulty in learning new digital skills.
  • Acceptance of Telemedicine: Lack of understanding of its purpose and benefits, privacy concerns, and intrusive advertisements.
  • Differences in Treatment Modalities: Preference for traditional treatment approaches.
  • Health Self-Management Capability: Reliance on personal experience and existing self-care practices.
  • Habituation to Medical Care: Strong preference for face-to-face interactions.
  • Job: For those working in healthcare settings, direct access to colleagues reduces the need for telehealth.
  • Cost: Perceived high costs and potential for double expenses (telehealth + in-person visit).
  • Limitations of Telehealth: Concerns about the comprehensiveness and individualization of telehealth evaluations.
  • Operation Experience: Desire for simpler interfaces, multi-language support, and dedicated operational teams.
  • Quality of Care in Nursing Homes: High-quality nursing homes reduce the perceived need for telehealth.
  • Convenience of Medical Treatment: Proximity of local health facilities and free services.
  • Popularisation: Lack of awareness and understanding of telehealth.

Facilitators (2 subthemes):

  • Convenience: Especially for caregivers who are geographically dispersed or have mobility issues.
  • Professionalism and Authority of Healthcare Professionals: Trust in reputable institutions and qualified providers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographical Restriction: The sample was drawn from a limited geographical area, potentially limiting the generalizability of findings to other regions with different healthcare systems and socio-cultural contexts.
  • Focus Group Dynamics: Potential for uneven contributions, bias, and groupthink overriding critical thinking.
  • Influence of Discussion: Participants unfamiliar with telehealth might have had their imaginations influenced by the group discussion.
  • Social Desirability Bias: Participants might have responded in socially acceptable ways.
  • Carer Type: The majority of participants were spouses, and findings might differ for other caregiver types (e.g., adult children).

Future work should involve larger-scale studies in diverse regions to enhance representativeness. The authors also suggest that telehealth solutions should prioritize addressing the identified barriers faced by family caregivers, emphasizing user-centered design and clear communication.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study identified a series of factors that appear to influence the preference of family caregivers of elderly individuals with disabilities for telehealth in the context of conducting home care. These factors should be considered when designing and developing telehealth for conducting home care.
BibTeX
@article{guan2025factors,
  author = {Lina Guan and Guijuan Zhang and Yuyang Yi and Yaqin Liang and Xiaochun Zou and Bingsheng Guan and Yanya Chen and Wai‐Kit Ming},
  title = {{Factors that influence the preferences for telehealth among family caregivers of disabled elders: a qualitative study}},
  journal = {International Journal of Nursing Studies Advances},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijnsa.2025.100351},
}
Figure