Factors Influencing the Willingness to Pay for Wetland Bird Protection: A Value Assessment Based on a Questionnaire Survey of Residents in Gahai Wetland, Gansu, China

Xiushan Li, Xiaoliang Shi, Tiantian Yu, Jin‐Hong Du, Tom D. BreezeAnimals 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the economic value of wetland bird protection in China's Gahai Wetland by surveying local residents. It reveals a significant willingness to pay (WTP) for conservation, influenced more by factors like gender, age, and perceived necessity than by income or education, offering crucial insights for conservation policy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wetlands are vital ecosystems providing numerous services, from water purification to supporting immense biodiversity. Wetland birds, in particular, are sensitive indicators of wetland health and hold cultural significance. However, the economic value of these non-market services, especially cultural and biodiversity values, is often overlooked in development and conservation planning. This leads to unsustainable practices that threaten these critical habitats. Quantifying the public's willingness to pay (WTP) for wetland bird protection can provide a monetary basis for conservation efforts, bridging the gap between ecological importance and economic valuation. This paper addresses the challenge of valuing these intangible benefits by assessing the WTP of residents in the Gahai Wetland, a crucial habitat for threatened bird species in China.

Methods

The study employed a contingent valuation questionnaire to assess residents' willingness to pay (WTP) for wetland bird protection. This involved a face-to-face survey to ensure clarity and high response rates, with questions translated into both Chinese and Tibetan. The questionnaire was structured in three parts:

  1. General descriptive statistics: Collecting demographic information (gender, ethnicity, religion, age, occupation, education, income).
  2. Knowledge and evaluation: Assessing respondents' understanding of wetland pressures and their belief in the necessity of protection.
  3. WTP estimation: Directly asking respondents if they were willing to pay, the amount they would pay, their reasons, and preferred payment methods.

To analyze the data, two primary analytical approaches were used:

  1. Binary Logistic Regression: To identify the statistically significant factors influencing the propensity to pay for bird protection. This model helps understand who is willing to pay.
  2. WTP Models: To estimate the economic value of the WTP. This involved calculating both a lower limit (median payment multiplied by the proportion willing to pay) and an upper limit (cumulative frequency distribution of WTP values).

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a questionnaire survey conducted in and around the Gahai Nature Reserve in Luqu County, Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, Gansu Province, China. A total of 332 questionnaires were administered, with 325 valid replies, representing a recovery rate of 97.89%. The survey targeted residents of the six "regions" surrounding the reserve, with 90% of respondents being nature reserve residents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cultural and religious factors are influential but indirectly: While descriptive data showed strong WTP among Tibetan Buddhists, the regression analysis revealed that these factors were not statistically significant when controlling for other variables. This suggests that cultural and religious beliefs might create a favorable environment for conservation but don't directly dictate WTP as much as other attitudinal factors.
  • Perceived necessity is a powerful motivator: The strongest predictor of WTP was the belief that protection is "essential." This highlights the importance of framing conservation messages around the fundamental need for protection rather than solely on ecological benefits.
  • Socioeconomic factors play a less direct role than expected: Contrary to conventional economic theory, income and education levels did not show statistically significant effects on WTP. This suggests that in this specific cultural and economic context, other factors might be more dominant.
  • Livelihood dependence drives conservation investment: Even without high absolute income, individuals whose livelihoods directly depend on natural resources (like farmers and herdsmen) showed particularly strong support for conservation. This underscores the importance of integrating conservation efforts with local livelihoods.

Key Results

  • Significant Willingness to Pay: 78.77% of respondents (256 out of 325) expressed a willingness to pay for wetland bird protection.
  • Estimated WTP Range: Local residents were willing to pay an average of 208 to 230 CNY (approximately $29–$32 USD) annually per person for bird protection.
  • County-Level Valuation: Extrapolated to the entire county population, this translates to an estimated annual value of 7.9 to 8.8 million CNY ($1.1–$1.3 million USD) for wetland bird protection.
  • Gender and Age Matter:
    • Men showed a statistically significant higher WTP than women (p = 0.002).
  • Older respondents (age) demonstrated a greater willingness to contribute (p = 0.001).
  • Protection Necessity is Key: The perception that protection is "essential" was a significant positive predictor of WTP (p = 0.033).
  • Limited impact of Income/Education: Neither education level (p = 0.487) nor average annual income (p = 0.220) were statistically significant predictors of WTP in the regression model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Social Desirability Bias: The face-to-face survey methodology, while ensuring high response rates, may have introduced social desirability bias, potentially leading respondents to overstate their WTP.
  • Hypothetical Nature of WTP: Stated WTP values may not perfectly predict actual behavior.
  • Limited Generalizability: The sample size (N=325) and specific geographic focus limit the generalizability of findings to urban populations or other ethnic groups.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Employ mixed-method approaches, combining stated preference surveys with revealed preference data (e.g., experimental auctions, recording real donations).
  • Conduct longitudinal designs to validate findings over time.
  • Utilize larger sample sizes and broader geographic coverage to better examine potential cultural influences.
  • Further investigate the mediation hypothesis for cultural and religious influences through hierarchical modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Gahai wetland in Gansu, China, is a key wetland for nationally and globally threatened bird species. This research aims to quantify the economic value of wetland birds by the method of contingent valuation questionnaire, thereby providing a foundation for conservation of avian species. The result indicated that residents were willing to pay between 208 and 230 CNY (29-32 USD $) annually for bird protection, a total annual value of wetland birds in Luqu County ranging from 7.9 M to 8.8 M CNY (1.1-1.3 M USD $). Men, locals, and older individuals were more inclined to contribute and offered higher payments, albeit non-significant correlation between education level and annual income with the willingness to pay. While the depth of understanding of wetland pressures did not significantly influence the willingness to pay, it did show a positive correlation; those with more profound understanding tended to be more generous in their payments. Tibetan male residents were more likely to prioritize ecological and environmental protection due to their religious beliefs and cultural customs, which emphasize the reverence for and compassion towards birds. This research not only complemented and validated the applicability of the contingent valuation method in China but also underscores the considerations that should be taken into account when employing this method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025factors,
  author = {Xiushan Li and Xiaoliang Shi and Tiantian Yu and Jin‐Hong Du and Tom D. Breeze},
  title = {{Factors Influencing the Willingness to Pay for Wetland Bird Protection: A Value Assessment Based on a Questionnaire Survey of Residents in Gahai Wetland, Gansu, China}},
  booktitle = {Animals},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/ani15152183},
}

Loading related content...

Figure