Factors influencing Stress, Anxiety, and Depression in Students regarding The Thesis Process

Hoang An Nguyen, Bao Chau Duong, Thuc Duy Le, Cat Anh Le, Thuc Quyen Huynh, Van Nhi Tran, Nguyễn Phương Thảo, Thi Thu Hoai NguyenJOURNAL 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps the psychological landscape of Vietnamese students navigating the high-stakes thesis process, identifying key triggers for stress, anxiety, and depression. By utilizing path analysis, the researchers demonstrate that while "pre-thesis" students are primarily rattled by perceived discrimination and advisor pedagogical skills, "peri-thesis" students (those currently writing) find their greatest mental health buffer in robust institutional administrative support.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Completing a thesis is a universal academic rite of passage, but it is often a "black box" of psychological strain. While extensive research exists on doctoral burnout in Western contexts, there is a significant gap regarding undergraduate and graduate students in Asian academic settings—specifically Vietnam.

Vietnamese students face unique cultural pressures, including high family expectations and specific institutional hurdles. The authors sought to move beyond simple correlations to understand the directional relationships between demographic factors, academic environment, and mental health outcomes (Stress, Anxiety, and Depression) across different stages of the thesis journey.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional online survey design, collecting data from 475 Vietnamese participants. The study utilized three primary components:

  1. Demographics & Thesis Status: Categorizing students into pre-thesis, peri-thesis (active), and post-thesis (completed) groups.
  2. DASS-21: The "Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale," a validated 21-item instrument used to quantify psychological distress.
  3. Path Analysis: This is the core technical approach. Unlike simple regression, path analysis allows researchers to model complex, multi-step relationships (e.g., how "Advisor Attitude" influences "Administrative Support," which in turn reduces "Stress").

Statistical significance was determined using Mann-Whitney U and Fisher’s Exact tests, with models adjusted using Satorra-Bentler scaling to account for non-normal data distributions.

Datasets

The study relied on a primary dataset of 475 Vietnamese nationals (over 18 years old) with at least an undergraduate education level.

  • Pre-thesis: 180 students.
  • Peri-thesis: 83 students.
  • Post-thesis: 212 students (used as a control group to infer unidirectional relationships).

The sample was notably 71% female and 91% undergraduate, reflecting the specific demographic most impacted by these academic milestones in the region.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Discrimination as a Direct Stressor: For pre-thesis students, "Pressure from discrimination" (based on gender or ethnicity) was a primary direct driver of stress. Interestingly, this pressure was exacerbated by poor advisor pedagogical skills and the stress of "stopping grade-improvement courses."
  • The "Administrative Support" Buffer: In the peri-thesis group, the most powerful mitigator of mental health issues wasn't just the advisor's knowledge, but the administrative support provided by the institute.
  • The Advisor’s Dual Role: An advisor’s "good attitude" and "pedagogical skills" don't just help with the research; they act as catalysts that help students navigate institutional bureaucracy, which indirectly lowers psychological distress.
  • Expectation vs. Reality: For students yet to start, their expectations of the thesis (e.g., wanting an "easy" thesis vs. one "within ability") were significant predictors of depression scores, suggesting that mental preparation is as vital as academic preparation.

Key Results

  • Pre-thesis Path Model: Perceived discrimination directly increased stress scores (β=0.16, p<0.001). Anxiety in this group was specifically tied to "Current illnesses" (β=0.13) and the pressure of "Stopping grade-improvement courses" (β=0.15).
  • Peri-thesis Path Model: Administrative support was the "hero" variable, directly decreasing scores across the board:
  • Stress: β=-0.31, p=0.008
    • Anxiety: β=-0.39, p<0.001
    • Depression: β=-0.42, p=0.008
  • Internal Consistency: The DASS-21 scale showed excellent reliability in this context, with Cronbach’s alpha ranging from 0.82 to 0.95.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Sampling Bias: The use of an online Google Form may exclude those with limited digital literacy or internet access.
  • Gender Imbalance: With 71% female participants, the results might not fully capture the male experience of thesis-related stress.
  • Cross-sectional Nature: The study provides a "snapshot" in time. The authors suggest that future longitudinal studies are needed to track how a single student's mental health evolves from the proposal stage to the final defense.
  • Self-Reporting: The data relies on subjective DASS-21 scores rather than clinical interviews, which could introduce reporting bias.

The paper concludes by calling for policy interventions, such as mandatory bias awareness training for faculty and dedicated mental health support services specifically tailored to the thesis lifecycle.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose: To investigate the factors contributing to stress, anxiety, and depression among Vietnamese students before and during their thesis process. Methodology: A Cross-sectional online survey was conducted with questionnaire comprised three parts: (1) demographics, (2) thesis status, expectation, and potential factors influencing stress, anxiety, and depression, and (3) The Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale (DASS-21) assessment. The collected data was analyzed using Mann-Whitney U test, Fisher’s Exact test, and Path analysis to explore relationships among the surveyed variables to stress/anxiety/depression condition. Results: Among participants, 180 were pre-thesis students, 83 were peri-thesis students, and 212 had completed the thesis. Six factors were identified as significantly influencing stress, anxiety, and depression among pre-thesis students. They included “Pressure from discrimination”, “Pressure from unexpected incidents”, “Good pedagogical skills of thesis advisor”, “Stopping grade-improvement courses when doing thesis”, “Dealing with illnesses that are being treated”, and “Student’s expectations for their future thesis”. Perceived discrimination would directly increase stress score (β=0.16, p-value&lt;0.001), and was directly influenced by factors such as (1) “Pressure from unexpected incidents”, (2) “Good pedagogical skills of thesis advisor”, and (3) “Stopping grade-improvement courses when doing thesis”. Anxiety scores were increased by “Current illnesses” and “Stopping grade-improvement courses when doing thesis” (β= 0.13, p-value=0.002 and β=0.15, p-value&lt;0.001, respectively). Only “Student’s expectations for their future thesis” increased the severity of depression. For the peri-thesis group, strong “Academic supports from thesis-conducting institute” and a “Good attitude of thesis advisor” enhanced the likelihood of receiving administrative supports, thereby decreasing stress, anxiety, and depression scores (β=-0.31, p-value=0.008; β=-0.39, p-value&lt;0.001; and β=-0.42, p-value=0.008, respectively). Conclusions: Thesis-conducting environment, students’ expectations of future advisors and schedules might directly and indirectly impact stress, anxiety, and depression levels among students in pre-thesis and peri-thesis stages.
BibTeX
@article{nguyen2025factors,
  author = {Hoang An Nguyen and Bao Chau Duong and Thuc Duy Le and Cat Anh Le and Thuc Quyen Huynh and Van Nhi Tran and Nguyễn Phương Thảo and Thi Thu Hoai Nguyen},
  title = {{Factors influencing Stress, Anxiety, and Depression in Students regarding The Thesis Process}},
  journal = {JOURNAL},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.29245/2578-2959/2025/1.1339},
}
Figure