Factors Influencing Public Participation in Community Disaster Mitigation Activities: A Comparison of Model and Nonmodel Disaster Mitigation Communities

Ting Que, Yuxin Wu, Shiyu Hu, Jianmin Cai, Nan Jiang, Huige XingInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates what drives public participation in disaster mitigation activities in China, comparing "model" communities with established programs to "nonmodel" ones. It reveals that while positive attitudes are universally important, model communities benefit from stronger social norms and cognitive engagement, whereas nonmodel communities are more influenced by direct disaster experience and perceived control, suggesting tailored strategies are needed for effective community-wide disaster preparedness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In regions prone to geological disasters, like Southwest China, effective disaster mitigation relies heavily on community involvement. However, simply organizing activities isn't enough; understanding why people participate is crucial for designing successful programs. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the nuanced factors influencing public participation in different types of disaster mitigation activities, specifically comparing communities with advanced, government-recognized disaster mitigation programs ("model communities") against those without such formal designation ("nonmodel communities"). The goal is to identify how these differences in community development and resource allocation impact resident engagement and to provide evidence-based recommendations for strengthening disaster resilience.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach. A quantitative survey was conducted with 260 residents from both model and nonmodel communities in Jinchuan County, a geohazard-prone area. The survey collected data on demographic characteristics and key independent variables: attitude, subjective norms, perceived behavioral control, risk perception, disaster experience, and participatory cognition. These variables were measured using a five-point Likert scale. To analyze the data, binary logistic regression was used to determine the factors influencing participation in three specific activities: "evacuation drills," "self-help skills training," and "opinion expression." The study also utilized factor analysis for dimensionality reduction and calculated odds ratios (OR) and marginal effects to quantify the influence of each factor. Additionally, 25 semi-structured interviews were conducted with community residents and leaders to gather qualitative insights.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 260 questionnaires administered to residents in Jinchuan County, Sichuan Province, China. The sample was divided into two groups:

  • Model Communities: Data was collected from the Mulin community, designated as a "National Comprehensive Disaster Reduction Model Community." (n=112)
  • Nonmodel Communities: Data was collected from villages that have experienced flash floods and mudslides and are vulnerable to secondary hazards, including Desheng Village, Sha'er Township, Shangengzi Village, and Danzhamu Village. (n=148)

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing community structures and resident participation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Model" vs. "Nonmodel" Differences: Model communities, with their established resources and programs, show higher participation in structured activities like evacuation drills and skills training. However, nonmodel communities exhibit a greater willingness to participate in "opinion expression" activities, suggesting a stronger desire for agency and a need to voice concerns.
  • Universal Importance of Attitude: Across both community types, a positive attitude towards disaster mitigation activities is a consistent and significant driver of participation. This highlights the foundational role of public perception and belief in the value of these efforts.
  • Divergent Influences: While attitudes are common, other factors diverge significantly. Model communities are more influenced by subjective norms (social pressure) and participatory cognition (understanding and belief in the process), indicating the effectiveness of community cohesion and established communication channels. In contrast, nonmodel communities are more swayed by direct disaster experience and perceived behavioral control (belief in one's ability to act), suggesting that personal history and a sense of agency are key motivators where formal structures are less developed.
  • The "Overconfidence" Paradox: Interestingly, in model communities, higher perceived behavioral control and risk perception were associated with lower participation in self-help skills training. This suggests a potential for overconfidence or a false sense of security, which policymakers need to address.

Key Results

  • Evacuation Drills: Model communities had significantly higher participation (82.1%) compared to nonmodel communities (60.8%). Positive attitudes and perceived behavioral control were key drivers in model communities, while risk perception, disaster experience, and participatory cognition were more influential in nonmodel communities.
  • Self-Help Skills Training: Model communities also showed higher participation (63.4%) than nonmodel communities (43.9%). Positive attitudes were a universal driver. However, in model communities, higher perceived control and risk perception paradoxically decreased participation, while in nonmodel communities, perceived control and participatory cognition positively influenced engagement.
  • Opinion Expression: Participation was generally low in both types of communities, but slightly higher in nonmodel communities (23.6%) than model communities (8.9%). Attitude was a significant positive factor for both. Model communities were positively influenced by subjective norms and participatory cognition, while nonmodel communities were negatively influenced by subjective norms and disaster experience but positively by perceived behavioral control.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's sample is limited to Jinchuan County, a specific geohazard-prone area. This means the findings might not be directly generalizable to communities with different risk profiles or levels of development. Furthermore, the study explored individual factors but did not delve deeply into the complex interactions and path relationships between these variables.

Future work could expand the sample to diverse regions, investigate the interplay between influencing factors more thoroughly, and explore how to effectively channel the higher demand for participation and feedback observed in nonmodel communities. The authors also suggest that model communities should focus on observing and guiding public attitudes and abilities, particularly in self-rescue training, to avoid issues like overconfidence.

Summary updated

Abstract

Public participation in community-organized disaster mitigation activities is important for improving disaster mitigation capacity. With data from 260 questionnaires, this study compared the current status of public participation in model disaster mitigation communities and nonmodel communities in a geological-disaster-prone area. Three community-organized disaster mitigation education activities were compared cross-sectionally. A binary logistic regression was used to analyze the effects of attitude, perceived behavioral control, disaster experience, and other key factors on the public's choice to participate in community disaster mitigation activities. The analysis results indicated that model communities had higher public participation in two efforts, evacuation drills and self-help skills training, and lower participation in activities that invited them to express their feedback than nonmodel communities. The influence of attitudinal factors on the decision to participate in disaster mitigation activities had a high similarity across community types. The public participation in model disaster mitigation communities is influenced by factors such as subjective norms and participation cognition; the behavior of people in nonmodel communities is influenced by factors such as previous experience with disasters, perceived behavioral control, risk perception, and participation cognition and has a greater potential for disaster mitigation community construction. This study provides practical evidence and theoretical support for strengthening the sustainable development of disaster mitigation community building.
BibTeX
@article{que2022factors,
  author = {Ting Que and Yuxin Wu and Shiyu Hu and Jianmin Cai and Nan Jiang and Huige Xing},
  title = {{Factors Influencing Public Participation in Community Disaster Mitigation Activities: A Comparison of Model and Nonmodel Disaster Mitigation Communities}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191912278},
}
Figure