Factors Influencing Loyalty to an Online Clothing Shop among College Students

Yajing Shi, Jiawei Xu, Taohai Yan, Dongdong LuFibres 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the drivers of brand loyalty in the massive Chinese online apparel market, focusing specifically on the "digital native" college student demographic. By analyzing survey data from 259 students, the researchers identified that while price remains the ultimate factor for everyone, significant gender differences exist: men prioritize style and "matchability," while women focus on comfort, quality, and the logistics of the shopping experience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As e-commerce in China matures, the "easy growth" phase of mild competition has ended. With the online clothing market projected to reach nearly $600 billion by 2025, merchant acquisition costs (traffic costs) are skyrocketing. For online shops to survive, they must move beyond one-off transactions and cultivate long-term customer loyalty.

The authors tackle the challenge of understanding the "loyalty path"—the transition from a habitual buyer to an emotional, loyal advocate. While previous research often focused broadly on e-commerce or specifically on female shoppers, this paper zeroes in on college students, a high-consumption group that views online shops not just as vendors, but as "friends and partners."

Methods

The researchers employed a standard social science framework but applied rigorous statistical validation to ensure the data's integrity:

  1. Factor Screening: Based on literature and preliminary surveys, 12 key influencing factors were identified (e.g., price, fashion popularity, logistics speed, clothing comfort).
  2. Survey Design: A 5-point Likert-scale questionnaire was distributed online.
  3. Statistical Analysis: The team used SPSS 20.0 to perform:
  4. Reliability Testing: Using Cronbach’s alpha to ensure internal consistency.
  5. Validity Testing: Using the Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin (KMO) measure and Bartlett’s test for sphericity to confirm that the survey effectively measured the intended concepts.
  6. Comparative Analysis: Breaking down results by gender and grade level to find nuanced differences.

Datasets

The "dataset" in this context consists of primary survey data collected from 259 valid respondents at a university level.

  • Gender Split: 134 males and 125 females.
  • Grade Distribution: Relatively uniform across Freshmen (65), Sophomores (56), Juniors (72), and Seniors (66).
  • Context: The sample was drawn from college students in China, specifically targeting those with the ability to purchase fast-moving consumer products.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Universal Driver: Regardless of gender, price is the primary factor influencing loyalty (average score of 4.03/5). In a competitive market, "reasonable prices and discounts" remain the baseline for keeping a student customer.
  • The Male "Stylist" vs. The Female "Pragmatist":
    • Males are significantly more influenced by the "matchability" (collocation) of clothes and the overall fashion trendiness of the store. They use the store's "fashion level" as a proxy for whether they should return.
  • Females place a higher premium on the physical experience (comfort and quality) and the service ecosystem (logistics speed and customer service attitude).
  • The "Size" Tolerance: Interestingly, the lowest-scoring factor was "size completeness" (3.85/5). This suggests that college students are more willing to forgive a limited size range if the price and style are right, compared to failings in quality or service.
  • The Loyalty Path: The paper reinforces the theory that loyalty is a multi-stage process: Non-brand loyalist → Habitual buyer → Satisfied buyer → Emotional buyer → Loyal buyer.

Key Results

  • Statistical Rigor: The survey achieved a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.960, indicating exceptionally high reliability. The KMO value of 0.965 confirmed that the factor analysis was highly valid.
  • Top 3 Factors (Overall):
    1. Item Price (4.03)
    2. Fashion Popularity (3.98)
    3. Clothing Comfort (3.95)
  • Gendered Scores:
    • Matching/Collocation: Males (4.00) vs. Females (3.90).
  • Clothing Comfort: Females (4.02) vs. Males (3.89).
  • Logistics Speed: Females (3.98) vs. Males (3.87).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the primary limitation is the specificity of the context. Because the study focuses strictly on online clothing shops and a specific age demographic (college students), the findings may not generalize to older consumers or other product categories (like electronics or groceries).

Future research could expand on these findings by:

  • Investigating how these loyalty factors change as students graduate and enter the workforce.
  • Exploring the impact of "social commerce" (shopping via apps like WeChat or Douyin) on these loyalty metrics.
  • Developing specific marketing strategies for merchants based on the gendered preferences identified here.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract This study evaluated the factors influencing loyalty to an online clothing shop among college students. A survey was first conducted, and responses were compared. The main factors were identified and screened, and a sample of college students was selected. Likert-scale questionnaires were distributed, and the scores were calculated. The total score associated with the attitude of each respondent was ultimately determined. The strength of the respondents' attitude towards each topic was extracted and calculated, and the results were measured to determine the factors affecting loyalty to online clothing shops among college students. The top three influencing factors identified were as follows: the prices of the items sold by clothing stores, the fashion popularity of clothing, and clothing comfort. Compared with the female respondents, the male ones paid more attention to the matchability of clothing in stores and the fashion popularity of the goods sold. Compared with the males, the females paid more attention to clothing comfort, quality, the merchant's logistics speed and customer service attitude.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2022factors,
  author = {Yajing Shi and Jiawei Xu and Taohai Yan and Dongdong Lu},
  title = {{Factors Influencing Loyalty to an Online Clothing Shop among College Students}},
  booktitle = {Fibres},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2478/ftee-2022-0045},
}
Figure