Factors Influencing International Infrastructure Investment: An Empirical Study from Chinese Investors

Senchang Hu, Yunhong Wang, Wenzhe TangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study empirically investigates the key factors influencing China's international infrastructure investment (CIIE) location choices across 134 countries from 2009-2017. It reveals that while good highway infrastructure is attractive, investors also target regions with underdeveloped port and power infrastructure, suggesting a focus on market potential. Bilateral diplomatic visits and resource endowments also significantly drive these investment decisions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sustainable global development hinges on robust infrastructure. Developing nations often face a significant infrastructure financing gap, making international investment crucial. While China has become a major player in global infrastructure development, particularly through initiatives like the Belt and Road, understanding the specific factors that guide its investment decisions in different countries remains critical for optimizing these investments and for developing nations seeking to attract them. This paper addresses this by empirically identifying and analyzing the key determinants of China's international infrastructure investment location choices.

Methods

The study employs a panel data regression analysis using a fixed-effects model. This approach is suitable for analyzing data that has both cross-sectional (countries) and time-series (years) dimensions, allowing for the control of unobserved country-specific and time-specific effects. The authors construct several models, progressively adding variables to test the robustness of their findings. They use the number of newly signed contracts (VNC) as the primary explained variable and the completed contract amount (VTF) for a robustness check. Unit root tests were conducted to ensure data stationarity, a prerequisite for reliable regression analysis.

Datasets

The study utilizes panel data from 134 countries and regions spanning from 2009 to 2017. The data is sourced from various reputable databases, including:

  • China Statistical Yearbooks (CSY): For data on China's foreign contracted projects.
  • World Bank's World Development Indicators (WDI): For economic indicators like GDP growth, labor supply, and resource-related data (fuel and ores in merchandise exports).
  • World Economic Forum's Global Competitiveness Index (GCI): For measures of business trade, infrastructure quality, and financial market environment.
  • Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI): For assessing the institutional environment (political stability, government effectiveness, regulatory quality, rule of law, and corruption control).
  • China Diplomatic Yearbook (CDY): For data on bilateral diplomatic visits and treaties.
  • Centre d'études prospectives et d'informations internationals (CEPII): For geographical distance data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Highway Infrastructure as a Foundation, but Not the Only Factor: While good highway infrastructure is a strong attractor, the study highlights that investors are also drawn to regions with underdeveloped port and power infrastructure. This suggests a strategic focus on identifying markets with significant potential for future growth and development, rather than solely seeking established infrastructure.
  • Diplomacy as a Catalyst: Bilateral diplomatic visits are found to be a significant driver of infrastructure investment. This underscores the importance of high-level political engagement in fostering opportunities and facilitating project delivery, acting as a crucial enabler for Chinese enterprises.
  • Resource Exchange as a Motivator: The strong correlation between resource endowment and investment points to resource exchange as a key motivation for CIIE. This implies a symbiotic relationship where China gains access to resources, and host countries benefit from infrastructure development.
  • Institutional Environment Nuances: Interestingly, the study found that China's investment is inclined towards countries with poorer quality of government supervision. This might be interpreted as a preference for environments with fewer regulatory hurdles and less stringent environmental or legal constraints, potentially streamlining project implementation.

Key Results

The regression analysis revealed several significant findings:

  • Infrastructure Conditions:
    • Highway Infrastructure (QoRoad): A significant positive correlation, indicating a preference for countries with good highway infrastructure.
  • Port Infrastructure (QoPort): A significant negative correlation, suggesting a tendency to invest in regions with lower port infrastructure quality, implying market opportunity.
  • Power Infrastructure (QoElec): A significant negative correlation, similar to port infrastructure, indicating a focus on areas with potential for power infrastructure development.
  • Air Transport Infrastructure (QoAir): Not found to be a significant factor in location choice.
  • Diplomatic Activities (Visit): A significant positive coefficient, confirming that more active bilateral diplomatic visits promote international infrastructure investment.
  • Resource Endowment (Fuel, Ores): Significant positive coefficients, confirming that resource-rich countries are preferred investment destinations.
  • Commercial Trade (Manuf): No significant relationship found with manufactured goods imports.
  • Business Costs of Crime and Violence (CoCV): A significant negative coefficient, indicating a preference for countries with lower costs related to public security and commerce.
  • Institutional Environment: While some indicators like Government Effectiveness showed positive influence, others like Regulatory Quality and Political Stability were not consistently significant or showed negative correlations, suggesting a complex interplay.
  • Financial Market Environment: Easier equity financing (Equity) was found to be a significant positive factor, while foreign ownership (Owner) also showed a positive trend. Access to loans (Loan) was not significant.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Informal Institutional Factors: The study did not account for informal institutional factors such as cultural, language, and religious differences, which can significantly influence international projects.
  • Project and Firm-Level Heterogeneity: The analysis focused on country-level factors and did not consider the heterogeneity of different projects or firms, which could offer deeper insights.
  • Broader Country Coverage: While the study included 134 countries, expanding the dataset to include more nations could further validate the findings.
  • Complex Interactions: International infrastructure projects are characterized by long durations, large scales, and complex technologies, necessitating further study into the intricate interactions between various influencing factors.
  • Broader Scope of Investment: The study focused on China's infrastructure investment. Future research could explore the factors influencing infrastructure investment from other major investing countries.

Summary updated

Abstract

International economic cooperation accelerates the flow of capital, technology, labor, and other factors between different countries, which promotes global sustainable development. Building infrastructure construction is an important way to strengthen social development, and absorbing foreign capital is an effective way for developing countries to improve their infrastructure and to promote economic development. This study puts forward the factors that have influenced China’s investment in international engineering projects, and it constructs a panel data regression model for empirical testing. The study shows that, first, international infrastructure investment tends to select countries or regions with good condition of highway infrastructure. Second, international infrastructure investment tends to choose countries or regions with low development level of port and power infrastructure. Third, bilateral diplomatic visits play a significant role in promoting international infrastructure investment. Fourth, international infrastructure investment tends to choose countries or regions with good resource endowment. This study reveals the influencing factors and the mechanisms for the choices of location for China’s investment in international engineering projects, providing a theoretical framework for investors to optimize international infrastructure investment and management, as well as providing the policy references for developing countries to attract international infrastructure investment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2023factors,
  author = {Senchang Hu and Yunhong Wang and Wenzhe Tang},
  title = {{Factors Influencing International Infrastructure Investment: An Empirical Study from Chinese Investors}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151411072},
}
Figure