Factors Influencing Chinese University English Majors' Ability to Analyze 19th Century Romantic Poetry

Yali Li, Wong Siew PingInternational Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study utilizes Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to identify the cognitive and environmental drivers behind literary analysis proficiency among Chinese English majors. The researchers found that while motivation and cultural context are vital, innovative teaching methods and critical thinking skills are the primary catalysts for successfully deconstructing the complex symbolism of 19th-century Romantic poetry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Analyzing 19th-century Romantic poetry is a "high-order" cognitive task that presents a steep barrier for non-native English speakers. The genre is defined by dense metaphorical language, historical allusions, and philosophical concepts like "the sublime" that are often alien to modern students.

The authors identify a significant gap in Chinese higher education: traditional, lecture-based "rote learning" fails to equip students with the tools needed to move beyond surface-level translation. The paper seeks to quantify which factors—ranging from personal interest to pedagogical style—actually move the needle on a student's ability to perform nuanced literary analysis.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative research design grounded in Social Cognitive Theory (SCT). SCT posits that learning is a triadic interaction between personal factors, environmental influences, and behavioral outcomes.

  • Modeling: The researchers used Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to test the relationships between five independent variables (Motivation, Interest, Exposure, Cultural Knowledge, and Teaching Methods) and the dependent variable (Analytical Ability).
  • Moderation Analysis: A key technical feature of the study is the examination of Critical Thinking Skills (CTS) as a moderator. The goal was to see if high CTS "amplifies" the effectiveness of the other factors.
  • Sampling: They used a stratified purposive sampling technique to ensure a representative mix of gender and year of study among participants.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of survey responses from 400 Chinese university English majors who had completed coursework in Romantic poetry.

  • Instrument: A five-point Likert scale questionnaire.
  • Collection: Data was gathered online via university networks and social media platforms (WeChat and QQ).
  • Validation: The researchers confirmed the dataset's reliability using Cronbach’s alpha and conducted pilot testing to ensure internal consistency across all constructs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Teaching Method" Dominance: Of all the factors studied, Teaching Methods (TM) had the strongest direct effect on analytical ability. Interactive, student-centered approaches (like group discussions and multimedia) significantly outperformed traditional "static" lectures.
  • Critical Thinking as a Force Multiplier: The study’s "aha moment" is the role of Critical Thinking Skills (CTS) as a moderator. It doesn't just exist alongside other factors; it acts as a lens that allows students to better leverage their motivation and cultural knowledge. Without high CTS, even a motivated student may struggle to bridge the gap between "reading" and "interpreting."
  • The Contextual Schema: Cultural knowledge isn't just "trivia" about the 19th century; it functions as a cognitive framework. Students with a grasp of the era's philosophical currents were significantly more accurate in their decoding of poetic themes.
  • The Exposure Paradox: While the abstract notes that exposure increases familiarity, the literature review warns of a "paradox" where exposure to overly complex works without proper scaffolding can lead to mixed attitudes or "overwhelmed" students.

Key Results

  • Quantitative Impact: Teaching methods emerged as the most influential determinant of success.
  • Motivation & Interest: These factors were strongly correlated with improved skills, acting as the "fuel" for persistence in deep cognitive tasks.
  • Moderation Significance: SEM analysis confirmed that CTS significantly amplified the effects of all independent variables on the students' ability to analyze poetry.
  • Pedagogical Shift: The results provide empirical evidence that moving away from didactic instruction toward active learning is essential for mastering high-level literary analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genre Specificity: The study focuses exclusively on 19th-century Romantic poetry. The authors suggest that future research should explore whether these findings hold true for other demanding genres, such as Modernist poetry or Shakespearean drama.
  • Geographic Scope: While the findings have implications for international literary education, the data is limited to Chinese universities. Cross-cultural studies comparing these results with students in other non-native English contexts would be valuable.
  • Qualitative Depth: Although the abstract mentions a "mixed-methods" approach including interviews, the methodology section provided focuses almost entirely on the quantitative survey data. Future publications could benefit from integrating the "why" behind student attitudes through more robust qualitative analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

This thesis explores the factors influencing the ability of Chinese university English majors to analyze 19th-century Romantic poetry. As Romantic poetry is characterized by its complex language, rich symbolism, and deep emotional content, it presents unique challenges for students. This study aims to identify and understand the key factors—motivation, interest, exposure to Romantic poetry, cultural knowledge, and Teaching Methods—that impact students’ analytical abilities. The research adopts a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative surveys with qualitative interviews to gather comprehensive data from students and educators across several Chinese universities. The study also examines the moderating role of critical thinking skills in enhancing students’ ability to engage with and interpret Romantic poetry. Findings from this research reveal that motivation and interest are strongly impacted with improved analytical skills, with students who are more engaged showing a higher proficiency in literary analysis. Exposure to Romantic poetry, both in and out of the classroom, was found to significantly impact students’ familiarity with the genre, which in turn enhanced their analytical abilities. Cultural knowledge, particularly an understanding of the historical and philosophical context of the Romantic period, was also identified as a crucial factor in the depth and accuracy of students’ analyses. Moreover, the study highlights the importance of innovative Teaching Methods, such as interactive and multimedia approaches, in facilitating a deeper engagement with Romantic poetry. Traditional lecture-based methods, while useful, were found to be less effective in addressing the unique challenges posed by this literary genre. The research concludes with recommendations for educators, curriculum designers, and policymakers to develop strategies that can better support the development of analytical skills in students studying Romantic poetry. The study also suggests areas for future research, particularly in exploring the applicability of these findings across other literary genres and educational contexts.
BibTeX
@article{li2024factors,
  author = {Yali Li and Wong Siew Ping},
  title = {{Factors Influencing Chinese University English Majors' Ability to Analyze 19th Century Romantic Poetry}},
  journal = {International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.6007/ijarbss/v14-i11/23683},
}
Figure