Factors Associated With Transmission Across Three Waves of SARS‐CoV‐2 in a Prospective Community‐Based Study of Households With School‐Aged Children—Dane County, Wisconsin, 2020–2022

Ajay K. Sethi, Cristalyne Bell, Derek Norton, Maureen Goss, Shari Barlow, Guanhua Chen, Amra Uzicanin, Jonathan L. TemteInfluenza 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tracked SARS-CoV-2 transmission within households with school-aged children across three major waves of the pandemic (pre-Delta, Delta, Omicron). They found that while overall household transmission risk decreased over time, higher household density remained a significant risk factor, particularly during the Omicron wave. This highlights the importance of considering both viral evolution and household-level factors in mitigating transmission.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic has been driven by the continuous emergence of new SARS-CoV-2 variants, each with potentially different transmission characteristics. Understanding how household transmission dynamics change across these waves is crucial for informing public health strategies. While previous research has identified factors associated with transmission, there's a need for longitudinal studies that track these changes within the same population over extended periods, especially considering the impact of vaccination and evolving variants. This paper addresses this gap by examining household transmission across three distinct periods defined by dominant SARS-CoV-2 variants in a community-based study in Wisconsin.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the ORegon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS), a prospective, community-based study in southcentral Wisconsin. Households with school-aged children experiencing respiratory symptoms were enrolled. Over an 18-month period (October 2020 to May 2022), household members provided self-collected nasal specimens for SARS-CoV-2 detection via RT-PCR.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Prospective Cohort Design: Following households over time to capture transmission events.
  • Variant-Defined Periods: Analyzing data in three distinct periods corresponding to the pre-Delta, Delta, and Omicron waves.
  • Logistic Regression: Used to investigate individual- and household-level characteristics associated with SARS-CoV-2 transmission.
  • Secondary Infection Risk (SIR) Calculation: Defined as the proportion of non-index household members who tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 within a 14-day assessment period.
  • Whole-Genome Sequencing (WGS): Used to identify concordant or discordant SARS-CoV-2 lineages within households, allowing for a post-hoc sensitivity analysis to exclude households with multiple introductions.
  • Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE): Employed as a supplementary analysis to account for within-household dependency.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the ORegon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS). This dataset includes:

  • Demographic information for household members.
  • Symptom data for index cases.
  • SARS-CoV-2 detection results from self-collected nasal swabs.
  • Vaccination status of participants.
  • Household characteristics such as density (members per bedroom).
  • Whole-genome sequencing data for SARS-CoV-2 positive samples.

This is a pre-existing, longitudinal dataset that was adapted for the specific research questions of this paper. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Declining Transmission Over Time: The study provides strong evidence that the risk of SARS-CoV-2 household transmission significantly decreased across the three variant periods, from pre-Delta to Omicron. This suggests that factors beyond just the virus itself are at play.
  • Household Density as a Persistent Risk Factor: Despite the overall decline in transmission, increased household density (more people per bedroom) consistently emerged as a significant predictor of transmission, particularly during the Omicron wave. This highlights the enduring importance of physical space and proximity in facilitating viral spread.
  • Impact of Vaccination and Prior Infection: While not directly included in primary analyses due to collinearity with variant periods, the study notes that rising vaccination rates and prior infections likely contributed to the observed decline in transmission. This underscores the complex interplay of host immunity and viral evolution.
  • Importance of WGS for Accurate SIR: The use of WGS to identify and exclude households with discordant SARS-CoV-2 lineages (suggesting multiple introductions rather than within-household spread) was crucial. Failing to do so could have inflated SIR estimates.

Key Results

  • The overall SIR across all households and periods was 47%.
  • SIR decreased significantly across variant periods: 72% (pre-Delta), 51% (Delta), and 41% (Omicron).
  • Odds of household transmission were 63% lower during the Omicron period compared to the pre-Delta period (OR=0.36, p=0.037).
  • Greater household density was significantly associated with increased transmission overall (OR=5.13 per person/bedroom, p=0.0008).
  • During the Omicron period, household density was a significant factor, with an odds ratio of 6.84 (p=0.0009) for each additional person per bedroom.
  • Index case age, illness severity, and individual symptoms were not significantly associated with the odds of household transmission.
  • The proportion of vaccinated household members rose from 7% in the pre-Delta period to 78% in the Omicron period.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size in Early Periods: The smaller sample sizes for the pre-Delta and Delta periods limited the power to detect significant associations for some factors.
  • Assumption of Index Case as Sole Source: The logistic regression and GEE models assumed that secondary infections originated solely from the index case, which may not always be true. More complex transmission models could offer more precise estimates.
  • Potential for Under-Accrual of Adult Index Cases: The study's focus on school-aged children with ARI symptoms might lead to under-representation of adult index cases, potentially biasing findings related to age.
  • Behavioral Data Limitations: The study could not quantify changes in participant behavior (e.g., masking, isolation) that might have influenced transmission, despite anecdotal evidence of "infection control" activities.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in a specific rural/suburban community in Wisconsin with a relatively high vaccination rate, which may limit generalizability to other populations.

Future research should continue to explore the interplay between viral variants, host immunity (from vaccination and prior infection), and individual/household behavioral factors to identify modifiable strategies for reducing future transmission risk. Further investigation into more complex transmission models is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Greater household density was associated with a higher risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission, but the risk declined over time with subsequent variants. Interplay between variants, prior infection, and individual/household factors may identify modifiable factors (e.g., behavior and vaccination) to reduce future transmission risk.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sethi2024factors,
  author = {Ajay K. Sethi and Cristalyne Bell and Derek Norton and Maureen Goss and Shari Barlow and Guanhua Chen and Amra Uzicanin and Jonathan L. Temte},
  title = {{Factors Associated With Transmission Across Three Waves of SARS‐CoV‐2 in a Prospective Community‐Based Study of Households With School‐Aged Children—Dane County, Wisconsin, 2020–2022}},
  booktitle = {Influenza},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1111/irv.70031},
}
Figure