Factors Associated with Emergency Department Visits and Consequent Hospitalization and Death in Korea Using a Population-Based National Health Database

Junhee Park, Yohwan Yeo, Yonghoon Ji, Bongseong Kim, Kyungdo Han, Wonchul Cha, Meong Hi Son, Hong Jin Jeon, Jaehyun Park, Dong Wook ShinHealthcare 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a massive Korean national health database to identify key sociodemographic, medical, and behavioral factors associated with emergency department (ED) visits, subsequent hospitalizations, and even death. The findings highlight that while younger individuals are more prone to ED visits, older populations face a higher risk of adverse outcomes, and specific health behaviors and pre-existing conditions significantly elevate these risks across the board.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing burden on emergency departments (EDs) worldwide, including in Korea, presents a significant challenge to healthcare systems. Understanding the factors that drive ED visits and, more critically, predict adverse outcomes like hospitalization and death after an ED visit, is crucial for developing targeted public health policies and optimizing emergency care resource allocation. Previous studies often had limitations in terms of population size, generalizability, or the scope of data analyzed. This paper aims to address this by using a comprehensive, population-based national health database to provide a nuanced understanding of these associations in the Korean context.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional study design using data from the Korean National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) database, which covers nearly the entire Korean population. They analyzed data from 2014-2015, focusing on a 50% randomly sampled population.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Descriptive statistics: To characterize the study population and identify common diagnoses for ED visits.
  • Multiple logistic regression: This was the primary method used to determine the adjusted odds ratios (aORs) for ED visits, ED hospitalizations, and ED deaths, controlling for a wide range of sociodemographic, medical, and health behavior factors. This allows for the isolation of the independent effect of each factor.

The study meticulously defined its outcomes:

  • ED visit: Any attendance at an ED within the study period.
  • ED hospitalization: Hospitalization occurring immediately after an ED visit.
  • ED death: Death occurring within seven days after an ED visit.

Datasets

The study utilized the Korean National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) database. This database is a comprehensive resource that includes:

  • Demographic information: Age, sex, place of residence, and household income.
  • Medical information: Linked to a death registry, including primary diagnosis codes (ICD-10) for ED visits and data on current and past medical treatments derived from claims and prescription records.
  • Health examination data: Information from regular health screenings, including self-administered questionnaires on lifestyle factors (smoking, alcohol consumption, exercise habits), anthropometric measurements (height, weight, blood pressure), and laboratory test results.

The study population was derived from a 50% random sample of eligible adults who underwent health screening between January 1, 2014, and December 31, 2015.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age paradox: While younger individuals are more likely to visit the ED, the risk of hospitalization and death dramatically increases with age, particularly for those 65 and older. This suggests different underlying reasons for ED visits across age groups.
  • Gendered risks: Women are slightly more likely to visit the ED, but men face a significantly higher risk of ED-associated hospitalization and death. This points to potential differences in health-seeking behaviors or the nature of conditions presenting in men.
  • Socioeconomic gradient: While income didn't strongly predict ED visits, higher income was associated with a lower risk of ED death, suggesting that financial barriers might not be the primary driver of ED use but could influence outcomes.
  • The cumulative impact of health: Comorbidities, disabilities, and a history of previous ED visits or hospitalizations are strong predictors of all adverse ED outcomes. This underscores the importance of managing chronic conditions and preventing recurrent ED use.
  • Behavioral health as a critical determinant: Unhealthy behaviors like current smoking, heavy alcohol consumption, and lack of regular exercise are consistently linked to increased risks of ED visits, hospitalizations, and death. This highlights the potential for public health interventions targeting these behaviors.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: Out of over 10.7 million participants, 6.7% visited an ED, 1.9% were hospitalized post-ED, and 0.004% died within seven days of an ED visit.
  • Age and Outcomes: Individuals aged 65-74 had a lower risk of ED visit (aOR: 0.70) but a higher risk of ED hospitalization (aOR: 1.23) and death (aOR: 14.55) compared to the 19-39 age group. The ≥75 group showed an even higher risk for hospitalization (aOR: 1.65) and death (aOR: 34.54).
  • Gender and Outcomes: Females had a slightly higher risk of ED visit (aOR: 1.03), while males had a higher risk of ED hospitalization (aOR: 0.88) and death (aOR: 0.45) – Correction: The abstract states males have higher risk for hospitalization and death, while Table 4 shows females have lower risk for hospitalization and death. This discrepancy should be noted.
  • Medical Factors: Conditions like ischemic heart disease (aOR: 2.56 for ED visit), stroke (aOR: 2.09), and malignancy (aOR: 1.73) significantly increased the risk of ED visits. These conditions, along with CHF and CKD, also increased hospitalization and death risks.
  • Health Behaviors: Current smokers had a higher risk for ED visit (aOR: 1.14) and hospitalization (aOR: 1.18). Heavy alcohol consumers had a higher risk for ED visit (aOR: 1.11) and death (aOR: 1.41). Regular exercisers had a lower risk for all outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Selection Bias: Health screening participants are generally healthier, potentially leading to an underestimation of risks in the broader population.
  • Retrospective Design: Confounding factors like environmental or psychological influences that might affect ED decisions could have been missed.
  • Comorbidity Data: The severity of comorbidities was not available, potentially limiting the precision of their analysis.
  • Under-recording of Diagnoses: The study notes that primary diagnosis codes might be under-reported for certain conditions (e.g., "cerebral infarction") due to administrative reasons, potentially affecting the accuracy of diagnosis frequency.
  • Mental Health Stigma: The underestimation of mental health issues as primary ED diagnoses due to stigma in Korean culture is highlighted.

Future work could focus on:

  • Developing targeted interventions for high-risk groups identified (e.g., older adults, males, individuals with comorbidities, smokers, heavy drinkers).
  • Investigating the specific reasons behind the age and gender disparities in ED outcomes.
  • Exploring strategies to mitigate the impact of socioeconomic factors on ED outcomes, particularly for lower-income individuals.
  • Addressing the under-reporting of mental health conditions in ED data.
  • Further research into the role of primary care accessibility and continuity in preventing ED visits and improving outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

We aim to investigate common diagnoses and risk factors for emergency department (ED) visits as well as those for hospitalization and death after ED visits. This study describes the clinical course of ED visits by using the 2014-2015 population data retrieved from the National Health Insurance Service. Sociodemographic, medical, and behavioral factors were analyzed through multiple logistic regression. Older people were more likely to be hospitalized or to die after an ED visit, but younger people showed a higher risk for ED visits. Females were at a higher risk for ED visits, but males were at a higher risk for ED-associated hospitalization and death. Individuals in the highest quartile of income had a lower risk of ED death relative to lowest income level individuals. Disabilities, comorbidities, and medical issues, including previous ED visits or prior hospitalizations, were risk factors for all ED-related outcomes. Unhealthy behaviors, including current smoking, heavy alcohol consumption, and not engaging in regular exercise, were also significantly associated with ED visits, hospitalization, and death. Common diagnoses and risk factors for ED visits and post-visit hospitalization and death found in this study provide a perspective from which to establish health polices for the emergency medical care system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2022factors,
  author = {Junhee Park and Yohwan Yeo and Yonghoon Ji and Bongseong Kim and Kyungdo Han and Wonchul Cha and Meong Hi Son and Hong Jin Jeon and Jaehyun Park and Dong Wook Shin},
  title = {{Factors Associated with Emergency Department Visits and Consequent Hospitalization and Death in Korea Using a Population-Based National Health Database}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare10071324},
}
Figure