Factors Affecting the Income of Agritourism Operations: Evidence from an Eastern Chinese County

Xiaowen Jin, Liang Wang, Zhang Zhengzheng, Jingzhuang YanSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the factors influencing agritourism income in a specific county in Eastern China, a developing economy context. Using regression analysis on survey data, it identifies seven key variables that significantly impact net income, offering insights for local governments and operators to promote sustainable agritourism development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agritourism, the integration of agricultural activities with tourism, is recognized globally as a strategy for rural revitalization and economic development. However, its long-term sustainability hinges on the profitability of agritourism operations. While previous research has explored factors affecting agritourism income, much of it has focused on developed economies and broader regional or national trends. This paper addresses the gap by examining the specific micro-level factors influencing the net income of agritourism entrepreneurs in a developing country context, specifically a county in Eastern China. The authors highlight that a "one-size-fits-all" policy approach is often adopted by local governments, neglecting regional differences and leaving operators in a vulnerable position. Understanding these localized factors is crucial for effective policy-making and for helping operators improve their financial performance.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach using survey data. The core methodology involved:

  • Data Collection: A comprehensive survey was conducted in the Luhe District, targeting all 1050 potential agritourism operators. Through a two-step screening process, 97 operators were identified as agritourism operators, and data was collected from 72 of them.
  • Regression Analysis: A multivariate linear regression model was used to identify the factors significantly affecting agritourism income.
  • Variable Selection: Given the large number of potential predictors (20 variables grouped into four dimensions: individual characteristics, resources/scale, operation/management, and staff training/marketing) and a relatively small sample size, a best subset variable selection method was employed. This method, utilizing Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) and Akaike's Corrected Information Criterion (AICC), was used to identify the most parsimonious and predictive model by selecting the optimal subset of variables.
  • Data Transformation: The dependent variable, average annual income, was log-transformed to address normality assumptions. The average tourist numbers were standardized.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset collected through surveys administered to agritourism operators in the Luhe District, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, China. The initial survey targeted 1050 potential operators, with 97 identified as agritourism operators, and 72 providing valid data for the final analysis. This dataset is specific to the Luhe District and was collected between July and December 2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Context Matters: The study strongly suggests that factors influencing agritourism income can differ significantly between developed and developing economies, and even within different regions of the same country.
  • Beyond Individual Traits: Surprisingly, individual operator characteristics like age, education, and experience were not found to be significant predictors of income in this study. This is attributed to the early stage of agritourism development in the region, where operational resources and scale might be more dominant drivers.
  • Scale and Specialization Drive Income: Larger agricultural enterprises, despite being fewer in number, dominated agritourism development and generated income more efficiently than smaller family farms and cooperatives. This is likely due to greater investment capacity and professionalization.
  • Diversification is Key (with caveats): Offering a greater number of agritourism activities generally correlates with higher income. However, the sale of non-agricultural products and the sheer number of tourists did not positively impact income, suggesting potential inefficiencies or a need for better integration of these elements.
  • The Power of Visibility: Road signs were found to be a significant positive predictor of income, highlighting the importance of basic, accessible marketing and navigation tools, especially in areas where digital access or literacy might be lower.

Key Results

The multivariate linear regression analysis identified seven variables that significantly affected the average agritourism income (log-transformed) over three years (2017-2019):

  • Positive Impacts:
    • Large agricultural enterprises: Operations classified as large agricultural enterprises saw an increase of 1.33 units in log-transformed income compared to family-owned operations.
  • Road signs: Having road signs was associated with a 0.78 unit increase in log-transformed income.
  • Selling agricultural products: Operations selling agricultural products experienced a 0.61 unit increase in log-transformed income.
  • Number of agritourism activities: Each additional agritourism activity was linked to a 0.2 unit increase in log-transformed income.
  • Average productive land area: A small but positive association was found, with a 0.0006 unit increase in log-transformed income per unit of productive land area.
  • Negative Impacts:
    • Selling non-agricultural products: Operations selling non-agricultural products experienced a 0.89 unit decrease in log-transformed income.
  • Average tourist numbers (standardized): Counterintuitively, a higher number of tourists was associated with a 0.31 unit decrease in log-transformed income, suggesting potential issues with conversion or efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Specificity: The study is a case study of a single county (Luhe District) in Jiangsu Province, China. The findings may only be generalizable to areas with similar characteristics.
  • Developing Economy Context: The results are specific to a developing economy context, and the unbalanced regional development within China means that even within the same province, environments can differ.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Broader Sampling: Enhancing the robustness of conclusions by randomly selecting agritourism samples from different rural areas across various Chinese provinces to reduce selection bias.
  • Longitudinal and Comparative Studies: Systematically and periodically collecting, investigating, analyzing, and comparing data on agritourism operations across diverse conditions worldwide to gain a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Exploring Inefficiencies: Further investigating why non-agricultural product sales and tourist numbers negatively impact income, suggesting potential areas for operational improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, agritourism has developed rapidly, and contributed considerably to economic and cultural revitalization in rural regions across the world. However, it cannot achieve long-term sustainable development if the operators are unable to enjoy necessary economic benefits. Therefore, the primary objective of this study is to identify the factors that affect the net income of agritourism entrepreneurs. Most previous studies have focused on regional or national incomes flowing from agritourism. This study surveyed all (1050) potential agritourism operators in the Luhe District, an eastern Chinese county. Seventy-two of them were identified as agritourism operators. A regression analysis with a best subset variable selection method of the surveyed data shows that the average agritourism income of three years is significantly affected by seven variables of twenty investigated. Some of those factors were also reported on by previous studies while others were new indicators. The findings highlight the importance of locality for local tourism governments when making regulations to promote agritourism. Finally, we provide some policy implications to promote agritourism in small areas (e.g., counties) in an early stage of development, especially in emerging developing economies such as rural China and many other Asian countries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jin2022factors,
  author = {Xiaowen Jin and Liang Wang and Zhang Zhengzheng and Jingzhuang Yan},
  title = {{Factors Affecting the Income of Agritourism Operations: Evidence from an Eastern Chinese County}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14148918},
}
Figure