Fabrication and characterization of combined metallic nanogratings and ITO electrodes for organic photovoltaic cells

Dominik A. Gollmer, Florian Walter, Christopher Lorch, Jiřı́ Novák, Rupak Banerjee, J. Dieterle, Gonzalo Santoro, Frank Schreiber, D. P. Kern, Monika FleischerMicroelectronic 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores integrating metallic nanogratings with indium tin oxide (ITO) electrodes to boost the efficiency of organic photovoltaic (OPV) cells. By fabricating these nanostructures within or below the ITO layer, the researchers overcome challenges related to surface roughness and organic film crystallinity, paving the way for more robust and efficient OPV devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic photovoltaic (OPV) cells offer a promising, cost-effective alternative to traditional silicon solar cells. However, their energy conversion efficiency still lags behind. A key limitation is the short exciton diffusion length in organic materials, meaning thicker active layers, which would normally increase light absorption, don't necessarily improve efficiency. One proposed solution is to incorporate metallic nanostructures to enhance light absorption. The challenge lies in integrating these nanostructures without negatively impacting the delicate organic thin films required for OPV operation. Specifically, surface roughness introduced by nanostructures can lead to short circuits, and changes in crystallinity can hinder exciton diffusion and charge collection. This paper addresses how to fabricate and characterize these nanogratings in a way that minimizes these detrimental effects.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary nanofabrication techniques:

  • Electron Beam Lithography (EBL): A serial process used for high-resolution patterning. This method was used to create gratings on top of, within, and below the ITO electrode.
  • UV Nanoimprint Lithography (UV-NIL): A parallel process offering higher throughput, making it more suitable for large-scale manufacturing. This technique was also used to fabricate gratings on top of ITO.

To characterize the nanostructures, they utilized:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): For visualizing the gratings and their dimensions.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): To measure surface roughness and structure height.
  • Grazing-Incidence Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (GISAXS): To assess the large-scale periodicity and homogeneity of the nanogratings.
  • White-light Extinction Spectroscopy: To investigate the optical properties, specifically the plasmonic resonances of the nanostructures.

A key innovation presented is the fabrication of nanogratings within or below the ITO electrode. This involves intricate multi-step processes including resist patterning, etching, and subsequent ITO deposition, aiming to create a more planar surface for the organic active layer.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the fabrication and characterization of nanostructures on substrates, rather than training or evaluating machine learning models on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Embedding nanostructures is crucial: Fabricating nanogratings within or below the ITO electrode significantly reduces surface topography compared to placing them on top. This is vital for preventing short circuits and maintaining the integrity of the organic thin film.
  • UV-NIL shows promise for scalability: While EBL provides precise control, UV-NIL offers a parallel fabrication route that is essential for cost-effective, high-throughput manufacturing of OPV devices.
  • Plasmonic resonance is tunable: The optical properties (specifically the plasmon resonance wavelength) of the nanogratings can be effectively tuned by altering their geometry (wire width and period) and the surrounding dielectric environment.
  • Grating-induced modes are observable: Beyond the primary plasmon resonance, a secondary "grating-induced mode" was observed, which can be influenced by the grating period and the refractive index of the surrounding materials.
  • Material choice matters for optical properties: The redshift observed when sputtering ITO onto gratings embedded in glass highlights the impact of the dielectric environment on plasmonic resonances.

Key Results

  • Reduced surface roughness: Gratings embedded within ITO exhibited a peak-to-peak roughness of approximately 3 nm, a significant improvement over gratings on top of ITO (~20 nm height). Gratings embedded in glass before ITO sputtering showed ~9 nm roughness.
  • Successful fabrication via EBL and UV-NIL: Both methods yielded regular gratings with comparable periods (~500-700 nm) and controlled wire widths (ranging from ~34 nm to ~150 nm).
  • Tunable extinction spectra: Extinction spectra showed plasmon resonances that redshifted with increasing wire widths. The position of these resonances was found to be only slightly influenced by the grating period but significantly affected by the fabrication method (EBL vs. UV-NIL) and the nanostructure's integration within the ITO layer.
  • GISAXS confirmed periodicity: GISAXS measurements validated the periodicity of the nanogratings, showing good agreement with SEM measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • UV-NIL geometry control: While UV-NIL offers scalability, the exact geometry (especially height) of the resulting structures can differ from the nominal gold layer thickness due to overetching or mask removal processes. This can lead to a reduced aspect ratio and a redshift in plasmon resonance compared to EBL-fabricated structures.
  • Further optimization of UV-NIL: Continued optimization of the UV-NIL process is needed to achieve better control over structure geometry and aspect ratio.
  • Integration with OPV devices: The study focuses on the fabrication and characterization of the nanogratings and electrodes. Future work will involve integrating these structures with small-molecule organic photovoltaic cells (specifically DIP and C60) to evaluate their impact on actual device performance.
  • Extending parallel fabrication: The authors suggest extending the parallel fabrication method (UV-NIL) to create gratings below and within ITO electrodes, which would be a significant step towards scalable, high-performance OPV devices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gollmer2014fabrication,
  author = {Dominik A. Gollmer and Florian Walter and Christopher Lorch and Jiřı́ Novák and Rupak Banerjee and J. Dieterle and Gonzalo Santoro and Frank Schreiber and D. P. Kern and Monika Fleischer},
  title = {{Fabrication and characterization of combined metallic nanogratings and ITO electrodes for organic photovoltaic cells}},
  booktitle = {Microelectronic},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1016/j.mee.2014.03.042},
}
Figure