Eye-centered visual receptive fields in the ventral intraparietal area

Xiaohong Chen, Gregory C. DeAngelis, Dora E. AngelakiJournal of Neurophysiology 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how neurons in the ventral intraparietal area (VIP) represent visual information, specifically whether their receptive fields (RFs) are centered on the eye or the head. Using a novel large-field visual stimulus, the researchers found that the vast majority of VIP neurons have eye-centered RFs, challenging previous findings that suggested a significant proportion were head-centered. This suggests that the way visual stimuli are presented and how attention is directed can influence the reference frame used by these neurons.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain needs to create a stable representation of the world despite constant movement, especially head and eye movements. Different brain areas use various "reference frames" to encode spatial information, such as whether a stimulus is located relative to the eyes (eye-centered) or the head (head-centered). The ventral intraparietal area (VIP) is a crucial hub for integrating sensory information, including visual, vestibular, and somatosensory inputs, and it's known to process these signals in diverse reference frames.

Previous research on VIP neurons yielded conflicting results regarding visual receptive fields. Some studies, using simple moving bar stimuli, reported a substantial number of neurons with head-centered RFs. However, more recent work by the same research group, using complex optic flow stimuli to measure heading tuning, found that these signals were predominantly represented in an eye-centered frame. This discrepancy raised a key question: are these differences due to the specific visual property being measured (heading tuning vs. RF location) or the type of visual stimulus used (simple bar vs. complex optic flow)? This paper aims to resolve this by systematically mapping visual RFs in VIP using a large-field, multi-patch stimulus, similar to the optic flow used previously, while varying eye position.

Methods

The researchers employed extracellular recordings from two male rhesus monkeys. To map visual receptive fields (RFs), they used a sophisticated multipatch, random-dot motion stimulus. This stimulus covered a large visual area (80x80 degrees) and was divided into a grid of 64 smaller subfields. Within each subfield, random dots moved coherently in one of eight directions, with directions updated every 100 milliseconds.

A key aspect of their methodology was to vary the monkey's eye position relative to a fixed head. This was achieved by having the monkeys fixate on targets presented at three different horizontal positions (-20°, 0°, +20°). By analyzing the neuronal responses to the random-dot motion stimulus across these different eye positions, they could determine whether the RFs shifted with eye movements (indicating an eye-centered frame) or remained fixed relative to the head (indicating a head-centered frame).

To quantify RF shifts, they used two primary methods:

  1. Displacement Index (DI): This non-parametric method measures how much an RF shifts relative to changes in eye position. A DI of 1 indicates an eye-centered RF, while a DI of 0 indicates a head-centered RF.
  2. Model-based analysis: They fitted the RF data with both eye-centered and head-centered models to determine which model best described the neuronal responses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved recordings from two rhesus monkeys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stimulus Matters: The type of visual stimulus used to probe neuronal responses significantly impacts the inferred spatial reference frame. Large-field, complex stimuli like optic flow appear to elicit more eye-centered representations in VIP compared to simple, localized stimuli like moving bars.
  • Attention's Role: The authors hypothesize that attention plays a crucial role. When attention is broadly distributed across a complex visual scene (as with their stimulus), it might favor eye-centered representations. Conversely, focusing attention on a single stimulus might engage different neural mechanisms.
  • Flexibility in the Brain: This study adds to a growing body of evidence suggesting that neural representations are not fixed but are flexible and context-dependent, adapting to sensory input and cognitive demands.
  • Bridging the Gap: This work helps reconcile conflicting findings in the literature by demonstrating that both eye- and head-centered representations can exist in VIP, but their prevalence depends on experimental conditions.

Key Results

  • Majority Eye-Centered RFs: The vast majority of VIP neurons tested exhibited eye-centered visual receptive fields. The Displacement Index (DI) analysis showed a mean DI of 0.92, strongly indicating an eye-centered frame.
  • Few Head-Centered RFs: Only one neuron was classified as strictly head-centered.
  • Intermediate Representations: A small minority of neurons (19/139) showed intermediate reference frames, falling between purely eye- and head-centered.
  • Model Fit Confirmation: The model-based analysis further supported these findings, classifying 69.1% of neurons as eye-centered and only 2.4% as head-centered.
  • Correlation with Heading Tuning: For a subset of neurons where both RFs and heading tuning were measured, the DI values for both were significantly correlated, suggesting that the reference frame for visual RFs is related to the reference frame for visual heading signals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stimulus Dependency: The primary limitation acknowledged is the potential stimulus dependency of the observed reference frames. The study's findings are based on a specific type of large-field, random-dot motion stimulus. Future work could explore a wider range of visual stimuli and their impact on RF representation.
  • Attention Control: While attention is hypothesized to play a role, it was not explicitly controlled in this study. Future experiments could directly manipulate attention to test this hypothesis more rigorously.
  • Horizontal Meridian Focus: The study focused on horizontal eye movements. Investigating vertical eye movements would provide a more complete picture of the spatial reference frames in VIP.
  • Interactions with Other Sensory Modalities: VIP is a multisensory area. Future research could explore how visual RFs interact with vestibular and somatosensory inputs in different reference frames.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ventral intraparietal area (VIP) processes multisensory visual, vestibular, tactile, and auditory signals in diverse reference frames. We recently reported that visual heading signals in VIP are represented in an approximately eye-centered reference frame when measured using large-field optic flow stimuli. No VIP neuron was found to have head-centered visual heading tuning, and only a small proportion of cells had reference frames that were intermediate between eye- and head-centered. In contrast, previous studies using moving bar stimuli have reported that visual receptive fields (RFs) in VIP are head-centered for a substantial proportion of neurons. To examine whether these differences in previous findings might be due to the neuronal property examined (heading tuning vs. RF measurements) or the type of visual stimulus used (full-field optic flow vs. a single moving bar), we have quantitatively mapped visual RFs of VIP neurons using a large-field, multipatch, random-dot motion stimulus. By varying eye position relative to the head, we tested whether visual RFs in VIP are represented in head- or eye-centered reference frames. We found that the vast majority of VIP neurons have eye-centered RFs with only a single neuron classified as head-centered and a small minority classified as intermediate between eye- and head-centered. Our findings suggest that the spatial reference frames of visual responses in VIP may depend on the visual stimulation conditions used to measure RFs and might also be influenced by how attention is allocated during stimulus presentation.
BibTeX
@article{chen2014eye,
  author = {Xiaohong Chen and Gregory C. DeAngelis and Dora E. Angelaki},
  title = {{Eye-centered visual receptive fields in the ventral intraparietal area}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00057.2014},
}
Figure