Extravesical vs. intravesical ureteric reimplantation for primary vesicoureteral reflux: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Zhi Wei Law, Caroline Ong, Te‐Lu Yap, Amos Hong Pheng Loh, Udayan Joseph, Siam Wee Sim, Lin Yin Ong, Y.l. Low, Anette Jacobsen, Yong ChenFrontiers in Pediatrics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review and meta-analysis compares two primary surgical methods for treating vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) in children: extravesical (EVUR) and intravesical (IVUR) reimplantation. While both techniques are equally effective at correcting the condition, EVUR offers significantly shorter operative times and hospital stays, though it carries a higher risk of temporary urinary retention in bilateral cases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vesicoureteral reflux (VUR)—a condition where urine flows backward from the bladder into the ureters—affects roughly 1% of the pediatric population and can lead to recurrent infections and kidney scarring. When conservative management fails, surgical "reimplantation" of the ureter is the gold standard.

Surgeons typically choose between two approaches:

  1. Intravesical (IVUR): Working inside the bladder. This often requires a bladder incision (cystotomy), which can lead to postoperative pain and bloody urine (hematuria).
  2. Extravesical (EVUR): Working outside the bladder. This is less invasive but involves dissection near the nerves that control bladder emptying.

Despite decades of use, there has been no clear consensus on which approach yields better recovery outcomes. This paper synthesizes the available evidence to provide a data-driven comparison of efficacy and complications.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, searching Medline, Embase, and Cochrane databases through March 2022. They identified 12 eligible studies (1 randomized controlled trial and 11 observational cohort studies).

The researchers used meta-analysis techniques to pool data on:

  • Success rates (persistence of reflux).
  • Surgical efficiency (operative time).
  • Recovery metrics (length of hospital stay).
  • Complications (acute urinary retention and hydronephrosis).

Datasets

As a systematic review, the "dataset" consists of the 12 clinical studies included in the analysis. This encompassed a total of 972 patients and 1,413 ureters (577 patients in the EVUR group and 395 in the IVUR group). The studies included both traditional open surgeries and minimally invasive (robotic/laparoscopic) approaches.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Equivalence in Efficacy: The most important finding is that both techniques work. There was no statistically significant difference in the success rate of correcting VUR (~97% for both).
  • The "Outside" Advantage: EVUR is consistently faster and leads to quicker discharge. By avoiding a large incision in the bladder wall, patients experience less postoperative pain and hematuria, which translates to a hospital stay that is roughly two days shorter on average.
  • The Bilateral Trade-off: The "Achilles' heel" of the extravesical approach is Acute Urinary Retention (ARU). When surgeons perform EVUR on both sides (bilateral), the risk of the child being unable to void after surgery is 4.4 times higher than with the intravesical approach. This is likely due to "neuropraxia"—temporary nerve stunning—caused by dissection near the bladder base.
  • Unilateral Safety: Interestingly, the risk of urinary retention was virtually non-existent for patients undergoing surgery on only one side (unilateral), regardless of the technique used.

Key Results

  • Operative Time: EVUR was significantly faster, with a mean difference of -22.91 minutes (P = 0.04).
  • Length of Stay (LOS): EVUR patients left the hospital 2.09 days sooner than IVUR patients (P < 0.00001).
  • Urinary Retention (ARU): In bilateral cases, ARU occurred in 8.1% of EVUR patients compared to only 1.7% of IVUR patients (OR = 4.40, P = 0.02).
  • Success Rate: No significant difference was found in postoperative VUR persistence (OR 1.08, P = 0.81).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors highlight several limitations that suggest caution:

  • Study Quality: Only one of the twelve studies was a randomized controlled trial; the rest were retrospective, which introduces potential selection bias (e.g., surgeons might choose IVUR for more "difficult" cases).
  • Surgical Heterogeneity: The meta-analysis combined open, laparoscopic, and robotic surgeries. While subgroup analyses were performed, the small number of minimally invasive studies makes it hard to draw definitive conclusions about robotic-assisted EVUR vs. IVUR.
  • Missing Data: Information on the duration of urinary catheterization and the specific use of painkillers was not consistently reported across studies.

The authors conclude that while EVUR is a highly efficient "day-surgery" candidate for one-sided reflux, surgeons must weigh the benefits of faster recovery against the higher risk of temporary voiding issues when treating reflux on both sides. Future high-quality randomized trials are needed to specifically compare these techniques in the realm of robotic surgery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Both EVUR and IVUR are equally effective in correcting primary VUR. Operative time and hospital stay are shorter after EVUR compared to IVUR. However, bilateral EVUR is associated with higher risk of postoperative ARU.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{law2022extravesical,
  author = {Zhi Wei Law and Caroline Ong and Te‐Lu Yap and Amos Hong Pheng Loh and Udayan Joseph and Siam Wee Sim and Lin Yin Ong and Y.L. Low and Anette Jacobsen and Yong Chen},
  title = {{Extravesical vs. intravesical ureteric reimplantation for primary vesicoureteral reflux: A systematic review and meta-analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pediatrics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fped.2022.935082},
}
Figure