Extracting short-ranged interactions from structure factors

Ard A. LouisMolecular 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Inverting scattering experiments to obtain effective interparticle interactions is generally a poorly conditioned problem. L. Reatto [Phil. Mag. A 58, 37 (1986)] showed that for atomic liquids close to the triple point, inversions are hard because the structure closely resembles that of an equivalent hard-sphere fluid. Here I demonstrate that at low concentrations and for particles with short-ranged attractive potentials, $S(k)$ also exhibits a very weak dependence on potential shape. Instead, different potentials all generate an $S(k)$ that closely resembles that of the Baxter model with a similar second-virial coefficient. By contrast, in this energetic fluid regime, the inversion of an attractive interaction from real-space correlations such as the radial distribution function $g(r)$ is well conditioned. Nevertheless, one may extract further information from $S(k)$ by measuring isosbestic points, values of $k$ where the scattering intensity $I(k)$ or the structure factor $S(k)$ is invariant to changes in interaction-potential well depth. These points suggest a new extended corresponding states principle for particles in solution based on the packing fraction, the second osmotic virial coefficient, and a new measure of effective potential range.

The Challenge of Scattering Inversion

In the study of soft matter and chemical physics, determining the effective interparticle potential $v^{eff}(r)$ is a primary goal for predicting system behavior. Traditionally, researchers attempt to infer this potential by inverting experimental scattering data, such as X-ray or neutron scattering, which yields the structure factor $S(k)$.

However, this inversion process is notoriously ill-conditioned, particularly for "energetic fluids"—systems at low concentrations with short-ranged attractive interactions. As shown in Figure 3, completely different potential shapes (such as Square Well, Lennard-Jones, or depletion potentials) can produce nearly indistinguishable $S(k)$ curves. These systems effectively mimic the Baxter "sticky hard sphere" model when matched to the same second virial coefficient. Consequently, a single $S(k)$ measurement at a fixed state point lacks the information necessary to uniquely identify the underlying potential. Interestingly, the real-space radial distribution function $g(r)$ remains sensitive to these differences, but $g(r)$ is not directly measured in scattering experiments.

Comparison of structure factors S(k), potentials βv(r), and radial distribution functions g(r) for different short-ranged models.

Methodology: Identifying Isosbestic Points

To overcome this ambiguity, the author proposes analyzing the evolution of $S(k)$ across different state points, such as varying temperatures that alter the potential well depth. Using the Percus-Yevick (PY) integral equation closure and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, the study identifies "isosbestic points"—specific wave-vectors ($k$) where $S(k)$ curves intersect and remain invariant despite changes in well depth.

By splitting the total correlation function into hard-core and attractive components, the author provides a mathematical basis for these points. The location of these intersections is not arbitrary; they are deeply connected to the spatial range of the attractive potential.

Results and the Extended Corresponding States Principle

The primary finding is that the first isosbestic point, $k_1\sigma$, serves as a direct proxy for the potential's range. As the potential becomes shorter-ranged (more "sticky"), $k_1\sigma$ shifts toward a value of $\pi$. Figure 6 illustrates this behavior across various Lennard-Jones potentials ($LJ-n$), where increasing the exponent $n$ (shortening the range) systematically moves the isosbestic point.

Isosbestic points in S(k) for various Lennard-Jones potentials and the relationship between the first isosbestic point k1σ and potential range.

This relationship allows for the derivation of a universal mapping formula that converts a measured $k_1\sigma$ into an equivalent square-well range, $\Delta_{eff}$. This leads to an extended corresponding states principle. While previous models relied on the packing fraction ($\eta$) and the second virial coefficient ($B_2^*$), this new framework incorporates $\Delta_{eff}$ as a third parameter.

Using this three-parameter approach, the author demonstrates that the critical range where the fluid-fluid transition becomes metastable (a key feature in protein crystallization and colloidal stability) occurs at a universal value of $\Delta_{eff} \approx 0.15$, corresponding to $k_1\sigma \approx 2.92$.

Conclusion

While $S(k)$ is insensitive to potential shape at a single state point, its variation with well depth reveals hidden structural information. Isosbestic points provide a robust, experimentally accessible method to characterize the range of interparticle attractions. This allows for the prediction of complex phase behavior in solutions using only three parameters, bypassing the need for a full, ill-conditioned potential inversion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Inverting scattering experiments to obtain effective interparticle interactions is generally a poorly conditioned problem. L. Reatto [Phil. Mag. A 58, 37 (1986)] showed that for atomic liquids close to the triple point, inversions are hard because the structure closely resembles that of an equivalent hard-sphere fluid. Here I demonstrate that at low concentrations and for particles with short-ranged attractive potentials, S(k) also exhibits a very weak dependence on potential shape. Instead, different potentials all generate an S(k) that closely resembles that of the Baxter model with a similar second-virial coefficient. By contrast, in this energetic fluid regime, the inversion of an attractive interaction from real-space correlations such as the radial distribution function g(r) is well conditioned. Nevertheless, one may extract further information from S(k) by measuring isosbestic points, values of k where the scattering intensity I(k) or the structure factor S(k) is invariant to changes in interaction-potential well depth. These points suggest a new extended corresponding states principle for particles in solution based on the packing fraction, the second osmotic virial coefficient, and a new measure of effective potential range.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{louis2011extracting,
  author = {Ard A. Louis},
  title = {{Extracting short-ranged interactions from structure factors}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1080/00268976.2011.611481},
}
Figure