Extracting Salient Keywords from Instructional Videos Using Joint Text, Audio and Visual Cues

Youngja Park, Ying LiNAACL 2006

TL;DR

This paper introduces a multi-modal system, GlossEx, that extracts domain-specific keywords from instructional videos by combining text transcripts with audio and visual cues. This approach significantly improves keyword salience and facilitates better video indexing and search compared to text-only methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The explosion of online video content, particularly instructional videos, has created a pressing need for effective video search and categorization. While text-based search is dominant, its effectiveness is hampered by the difficulty of accurately tagging domain-specific keywords. Existing methods often treat video transcripts as generic text, failing to leverage the rich audiovisual information inherent in videos, leading to unsatisfactory search results. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a system that intelligently integrates text, audio, and visual cues to identify truly salient keywords.

Methods

The proposed system builds upon an existing text-based keyword extraction system called GlossEx. The core innovation lies in enhancing GlossEx's output by incorporating audiovisual information. The process involves:

  1. Text-based Keyword Extraction (GlossEx): This initial step uses a hybrid approach that combines linguistic and statistical knowledge to identify candidate keywords from video transcripts. It considers term domain-specificity (how unique a term is to a specific domain) and term cohesion (how well the words within a multi-word term fit together).
  2. Audiovisual Content Analysis: The system analyzes both audio and visual streams to understand the video's structure and content types.
  3. Audio Segmentation: The audio track is partitioned into segments and tagged with labels like "speech," "silence," "music," etc., using a Support Vector Machine.
  4. Video Segmentation and Feature Extraction: The video is segmented based on physical setting. Visual features are extracted to identify segments containing a "narrator" (human faces) or "informative text" (text overlays). Segments lacking these are classified as "linkage scenes."
    • Semantic Audiovisual Labeling: Audio and visual labels are integrated to assign a semantic label to each video segment (e.g., "narrator with speech," "informative text with music").
  5. Cue Context Identification: The system identifies specific "cue contexts" within the video where salient keywords are more likely to appear. These include:
  6. The beginning of narrator presentations or voice-overs on informative text.
  7. The beginning of a new speaker's segment.
  8. Question sentences and their immediate answers.
  9. Segments following silence or informative text with music (transitional periods).
  10. Keyword Salience Adjustment: The salience of keywords identified by GlossEx is recalculated by considering:
  11. The original confidence score from GlossEx.
  12. The frequency of the keyword appearing in the identified cue contexts.
  13. The number of words in the keyword (favoring multi-word keywords). An "incentive value" is calculated based on these factors, and the original salience is boosted accordingly.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on four government instructional videos from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). These videos covered diverse topics such as bio-terrorism history, weapons of mass destruction, and school preparation for terrorism, with lengths ranging from 30 minutes to 2 hours. Video transcripts were acquired using closed captions. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but uses existing DHS videos for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Audiovisual Cues is Crucial: The core insight is that simply analyzing text transcripts is insufficient for effective keyword extraction in videos. The temporal and contextual information provided by audio and visual elements significantly enhances the identification of domain-specific keywords.
  • "Cue Contexts" as Salience Indicators: Identifying specific moments in a video (like the start of a new topic, questions, or transitional periods) where important information is likely to be presented is a powerful heuristic for boosting keyword relevance.
  • Multi-word Keywords Benefit: The system's salience adjustment mechanism favors multi-word keywords, which are often more descriptive and domain-specific than single words.
  • Instructional Videos Have Structure: The paper notes that professionally produced instructional videos often exhibit predictable structures (introductions, topic segments, transitions), which can be exploited for content analysis.

Key Results

Experiments on four DHS instructional videos showed that:

  • An average of 82% of manually identified salient keywords were found within the top 50% of keywords re-ranked by the proposed system.
  • The integration of audiovisual cues improved precision by 1.1% and recall by 1.5% compared to the text-only GlossEx system.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the identification of speaker changes and question sentences currently relies on signature characters in the transcript. They suggest that more advanced techniques for speaker change detection and prosody analysis could be employed if this information is unavailable. Future work includes performing more sophisticated experiments with additional audiovisual cues and improving the calculation of keyword incentive values. A direct comparison between the proposed scheme and the original GlossEx system is also planned.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2006extracting,
  author = {Youngja Park and Ying Li},
  title = {{Extracting Salient Keywords from Instructional Videos Using Joint Text, Audio and Visual Cues}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2006},
}
Figure