Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation as life-saving bridge for patients with airway obstruction caused by neck and chest tumors to salvage procedure: an in-depth review

Shitong Su, Lianjing Liang, Zijian Liu, Ling Wang, Tong Zhang, Nianyong ChenInternational Journal of Surgery 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review highlights Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO) as a critical life-saving bridge for patients with severe airway obstruction caused by neck and chest tumors. By providing essential respiratory support, ECMO enables complex surgical interventions that would otherwise be too risky, demonstrating a high survival rate in analyzed cases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Airway obstruction due to neck and chest tumors presents a life-threatening emergency. Traditional ventilation methods like intubation or tracheostomy can be insufficient or even dangerous in these complex cases, especially when tumors cause severe narrowing or extrinsic compression. This leaves patients at high risk of suffocation and cardiopulmonary collapse, often precluding timely surgical intervention. The paper addresses the limited understanding and established protocols for using ECMO as a bridge to surgery in these specific, high-stakes scenarios.

Methods

This paper is an in-depth literature review and case series analysis. The authors systematically searched PubMed, Web of Science, and other medical databases to identify studies on ECMO for tumor-induced airway obstruction. They analyzed data from 27 studies involving 54 patients who received ECMO as ventilatory support for surgical relief of airway obstruction. Additionally, they present a case series of 5 patients to illustrate real-world outcomes. The review also includes anatomical illustrations to clarify the mechanisms of obstruction and ECMO's role.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" for this review consists of data aggregated from 27 published studies, encompassing a total of 54 patients. These studies are primarily case series and reports. The authors also present their own case series of 5 patients. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ECMO as a Viable Bridge: The most significant insight is the demonstrated efficacy of ECMO in stabilizing patients with critical airway obstruction, allowing for necessary surgical interventions that would otherwise be impossible.
  • VV ECMO Dominance: Venovenous (VV) ECMO is the preferred mode for airway obstruction management, as it focuses solely on respiratory support without the added complexity of circulatory support, which is often not required in these cases.
  • Limitations of Conventional Methods: The review clearly illustrates why traditional methods fail in severe cases, highlighting the risks of intubation (complete obstruction) and tracheostomy (bleeding, limited reach).
  • High Survival Rate: The aggregated data shows a remarkably high survival rate (87%) for patients managed with ECMO, underscoring its life-saving potential.
  • Prognosis Tied to Underlying Disease: Deaths observed were primarily due to disease progression, not ECMO complications, emphasizing that ECMO is a bridge, not a cure.

Key Results

  • Overall Survival: Out of 54 patients analyzed, 87% (47/54) survived postoperatively.
  • Mortality: 7.4% (4/54) of patients died due to postoperative disease progression, unrelated to ECMO complications.
  • Unknown Prognosis: The prognosis for 5.6% (3/54) of patients could not be determined.
  • Case Series Comparison: In the authors' case series of 5 patients, 4 who received ECMO support were successfully discharged, while 1 patient managed with conventional ventilation died before surgery.
  • VV ECMO Prevalence: 43 out of 54 patients received VV ECMO, with only 2 receiving VA ECMO.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Literature: The authors acknowledge that published articles on this specific topic are limited, primarily consisting of case series and reports, which inherently have biases and lack robust statistical power.
  • Need for Standardization: Further studies are needed to validate standardized methods and establish clear indications for ECMO use in these patients.
  • ECMO Complications: While ECMO offers significant benefits, the authors note the potential for complications (24-55% reported rates) such as air leakage, thrombosis, hemolysis, and bleeding, which require careful management by experienced teams.
  • Cost and Resource Intensity: The emergent use of ECMO is indicated but carries higher procedural costs and requires specialized centers.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their findings provide a basis for further research and can be used to improve management strategies for patients with tumor-induced airway obstruction. They emphasize the need for consensus among surgeons and ECMO teams regarding patient condition, surgical indications, and perioperative management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Narrowed or stenotic airways are frequently encountered in emergency practice. Neck and chest tumors-caused airway obstruction usually follow a severe clinical course, necessitating urgent ventilation as a bridge to perform emergency operations. In certain cases, traditional ventilation methods may not safely address complicated airway conditions. In such instances, special cardiopulmonary support becomes necessary to manage both hemodynamics and ventilation for patients. Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is considered a last resort treatment for respiratory failure. When dealing with emergency difficult airway situations, ECMO offers certain advantages over conventional ventilation. However, its effectiveness in managing airway obstruction due to solid tumors located in the neck or chest is not well-established due to limited clinical practice. Published articles about this topic are still limited and primarily rely on case series and reports. As a result, they offer insufficient data and illustrations to fully elucidate emergency issues. In the present article, the authors summarize the existing literature concerning ECMO utility in managing patients with airway obstruction due to solid tumor located in the neck or chest based on PubMed, Web of Science, and other medical databases, to conduct an in-depth review. The authors conducted an analysis of 27 studies, including a total of 54 patients with airway obstruction caused by tumors. All patients underwent surgical relief of airway obstruction with ECMO as ventilatory support. Postoperatively, 87% of the patients (47/54) survived. 7.4% of the patients (4/54) died due to postoperative disease progression, unrelated to ECMO complications. The prognosis of 5.6% of the patients (3/54) could not be obtained. Additionally, the authors present an interesting case series (n=5) based on a real-world research to demonstrate the different outcomes among airway-obstructed patients due to neck and chest masses. In this series, four patients supported by ECMO were successfully discharged postoperatively, while one patient on conventional ventilation died due to respiratory collapse before surgery. Meanwhile, the authors share novel illustrations and clinical figures to supplement the understanding of this condition. The findings presented in this article provide a basis for further studies and can be used to improve management of the patients.
BibTeX
@article{su2024extracorporeal,
  author = {Shitong Su and Lianjing Liang and Zijian Liu and Ling Wang and Tong Zhang and Nianyong Chen},
  title = {{Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation as life-saving bridge for patients with airway obstruction caused by neck and chest tumors to salvage procedure: an in-depth review}},
  journal = {International Journal of Surgery},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1097/js9.0000000000002008},
}
Figure