External fixation versus elastic stable intramedullary nailing in the treatment of open tibial shaft fractures in children

Hong Pan, Saroj Rai, Xin Tang, Ruikang Liu, Jin LiJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nailing (ESIN) is a viable option in selected patients with Gustilo-Anderson (GA) grade II and IIIA open tibial fractures, offering comparable clinical outcomes to the traditional external fixator (EF). While pin tract infection remains the most significant complication in the EF group, implant prominence is a common issue in the ESIN group.

Introduction

Open tibial shaft fractures in children are serious injuries requiring both wound management and stable bone fixation to prevent infection and ensure proper healing. Historically, the External Fixator (EF) has been the preferred treatment for open fractures due to its ability to stabilize the bone without placing hardware directly into the potentially contaminated wound site. However, EF is associated with complications such as pin tract infections and refractures following hardware removal.

Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nailing (ESIN), while standard for closed fractures, has been controversial for open fractures due to the theoretical risk of spreading infection within the medullary canal. This study evaluates whether ESIN can serve as a safe and effective alternative to EF for specific grades of open pediatric tibial fractures.

Methods

This retrospective study analyzed 92 children (ages 5–11) treated for Gustilo-Anderson grade II or IIIA open tibial fractures between 2008 and 2018 at Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College in Wuhan, China. The cohort was divided into two groups:

  1. EF Group (n=55): Treated with external frames.
  2. ESIN Group (n=37): Treated with internal flexible nails.

Researchers monitored time to radiological union, limb length discrepancy (LLD), angular deformity, and various complications.

Figure 1: Radiographic progression of a six-year-old boy with a GA grade II tibial fracture treated with an external fixator (EF). (A-B) Pre-surgery; (C-D) Post-surgery; (E-F) 8-week follow-up; (G-H) After hardware removal at 11 weeks; (I-L) Long-term follow-up at 5 and 12 months.

Results

The study revealed several significant differences between the two surgical approaches:

Healing and Alignment

Patients in the ESIN group achieved radiological union significantly faster than those in the EF group (7.0 ± 0.9 weeks vs. 9.0 ± 2.2 weeks, $P < 0.01$). This accelerated healing is likely due to the "micro-motion" permitted by flexible nails, which promotes callus formation. Furthermore, ESIN resulted in better limb alignment, with lower rates of minor angulation and smaller limb length discrepancies (7.3 mm vs. 12.1 mm in the EF group).

Complications

The complication profiles differed notably between groups:

  • Infection: Pin tract infections occurred in 36% of the EF group. Deep wound infection rates at the fracture site were low (~5%) and similar in both groups, suggesting that internal nailing did not significantly increase the risk of spreading infection.
  • Refracture: Three refractures occurred in the EF group after frame removal, while none occurred in the ESIN group.
  • Hardware Issues: 16% of the ESIN group experienced implant prominence, where the nail ends caused skin irritation, necessitating a second surgery for removal.

Discussion

The findings suggest that ESIN is not only safe for GA grade II and IIIA open fractures but may offer biological advantages in terms of healing speed and alignment. The primary drawback of EF is the high maintenance required for pin sites and the risk of refracture. Conversely, ESIN requires a planned second operation for hardware removal and can cause localized irritation, but it avoids the external hardware burden.

Conclusion

ESIN is a viable and potentially superior alternative to EF for treating selected pediatric open tibial fractures. While surgeons must weigh the risk of pin tract infections against the need for a second surgery to remove internal nails, the faster union times and better alignment favor ESIN in appropriate cases. Future research should focus on long-term functional outcomes and formalizing criteria for which open wounds are most suitable for internal nailing.

Summary updated

Abstract

ESIN is a viable option in selected patients of GA grade II and IIIA open tibial fractures with comparable clinical outcomes as external fixator. Pin tract infection is the most troublesome complication in the EF group while implant prominence is a nuisance in the ESIN group.
BibTeX
@article{pan2021external,
  author = {Hong Pan and Saroj Rai and Xin Tang and Ruikang Liu and Jin Li},
  title = {{External fixation versus elastic stable intramedullary nailing in the treatment of open tibial shaft fractures in children}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-021-02679-w},
}
Figure