Extensive mitochondrial population structure and haplotype-specific phenotypic variation in the Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel

R. Bevers, Maria Litovchenko, Adamandia Kapopoulou, Virginie Braman, Matthew R. Robinson, Johan Auwerx, Brian Hollis, Bart DeplanckebioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals significant population structure within the mitochondrial genomes of the Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel (DGRP), identifying distinct mitochondrial haplotypes. These haplotypes are linked to specific metabolic and stress-related phenotypes, demonstrating the crucial, often overlooked, role of mitochondrial variation in genotype-phenotype relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) in Drosophila and humans have traditionally focused on nuclear genetic variants to understand phenotypic variation. However, the mitochondrial genome, with its unique inheritance and role in cellular metabolism, has been largely ignored. This oversight is problematic because mitochondrial function is critical for many cellular processes, and variations within it could significantly contribute to complex traits. Previous studies in Drosophila have hinted at the importance of mito-nuclear interactions, but a comprehensive characterization of mitochondrial variation within a well-established genetic reference panel like the DGRP, and its direct link to phenotypes, was missing. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a detailed catalog of mitochondrial variation in the DGRP and exploring its impact on phenotypes.

Methods

The researchers developed a robust mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) enrichment workflow to achieve high sequencing coverage. This involved differential centrifugation to isolate mitochondria, followed by phenol-chloroform extraction for mtDNA. They then used an in-house Tn5 transposase for tagmentation to create mtDNA-enriched sequencing libraries. For variant calling, they employed the GATK pipeline, first for nuclear variants and then specifically for mitochondrial variants, mapping reads to the Drosophila genome. To identify mitochondrial haplotypes, they used the TCS method, which considers variation across the entire mitochondrial genome. They also screened for genotype ratio distortions (GRDs) between mitochondrial and nuclear variants, indicating potential incompatibilities. Finally, they performed association analyses between mitochondrial haplotypes and a compendium of DGRP phenotypes, and experimentally validated findings related to food intake by swapping mitochondrial genomes.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study consists of mitochondrial genome sequences from over 170 Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel (DGRP) lines. Additionally, they generated sequencing data for three common reference lines (iso-1, Oregon-R, and w1118) and replicate samples for these lines. They also utilized a compendium of over 600 publicly accessible DGRP phenotypes, which was reduced to 259 uncorrelated phenotypes for analysis. For validation, they used specific DGRP lines selected for their extreme food intake phenotypes, as reported in previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mitochondrial Haplotypes Drive Phenotypic Variation: The most striking finding is that distinct mitochondrial haplotypes, not just individual variants, are significantly associated with specific phenotypes, particularly those related to metabolism and stress response. This suggests that the collective genetic background of the mitochondrial genome plays a crucial role.
  • Population Structure is Deeply Embedded: The identified mitochondrial population structure within the DGRP is not a recent artifact but likely reflects the structure present at the time the isofemale lines were established, indicating long-term evolutionary forces at play.
  • GRDs Don't Necessarily Mean Incompatibility: While a large number of genotype ratio distortions (GRDs) were found between mitochondrial and nuclear genomes, these did not consistently lead to major fitness defects. This suggests that many GRDs might be a consequence of existing population structure rather than direct genetic incompatibilities.
  • Mitochondrial Genome is Surprisingly Variable: Despite the common perception of low variation, the study identified a substantial number of mitochondrial variants (231 in coding regions) within the DGRP, with some lines showing unique variants.

Key Results

  • 231 Mitochondrial Variants Identified: The study identified 231 DGRP-specific mitochondrial variants, including 21 indels and 7 frameshifts, in the coding regions of the mitochondrial genome.
  • 12 Distinct Mitochondrial Haplotypes: Based on these variants, 12 genetically distinct mitochondrial haplotypes were resolved within the DGRP.
  • 1,845 Significant GRDs: A remarkable 1,845 significant genotype ratio distortions (GRDs) were detected between mitochondrial and nuclear variants, with a notable enrichment in the Sex-lethal (Sxl) gene region.
  • Phenotypic Associations: Mitochondrial haplotype association analysis revealed significant links with 12 phenotypes, including food intake in males, stress response, and metabolism.
  • Experimental Validation of Food Intake: Reciprocal swapping of mitochondrial genomes between high and low food intake lines confirmed that mitochondrial haplotypes significantly influence food intake, with an effect size comparable to or larger than some nuclear variants.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they identified a large number of GRDs, they did not uncover strong phenotypic associations for most of them. They speculate this could be due to the conservative nature of their analysis, the possibility of masked effects under laboratory conditions, or that many GRDs are indeed false positives or reflect existing population structure rather than direct incompatibilities. They also note that the experimental validation of food intake was performed in males, and the effect of X-linked variants cannot be entirely ruled out. Future work could involve exploring a wider range of phenotypes, investigating the functional impact of specific GRDs in more detail, and examining the role of mitochondrial variation in other model organisms and human populations. The study also highlights the need for further research into the mechanisms by which mitochondrial haplotypes influence complex traits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel (DGRP) serves as a valuable resource to better understand the genetic landscapes underlying quantitative traits. However, such DGRP studies have so far only focused on nuclear genetic variants. To address this, we sequenced the mitochondrial genomes of >170 DGRP lines, identifying 229 variants including 21 indels and 7 frameshifts. We used our mitochondrial variation data to identify 12 genetically distinct mitochondrial haplotypes, thus revealing important population structure at the mitochondrial level. We further examined whether this population structure was reflected on the nuclear genome by screening for the presence of potential mito-nuclear genetic incompatibilities in the form of significant genotype ratio distortions (GRDs) between mitochondrial and nuclear variants. In total, we detected a remarkable 1,845 mito-nuclear GRDs, with the highest enrichment observed in a 40 kb region around the gene Sex-lethal ( Sxl ). Intriguingly, downstream phenotypic analyses did not uncover major fitness effects associated with these GRDs, suggesting that a large number of mito-nuclear GRDs may reflect population structure at the mitochondrial level rather than actual genomic incompatibilities. This is further supported by the GRD landscape showing particular large genomic regions associated with a single mitochondrial haplotype. Next, we explored the functional relevance of the detected mitochondrial haplotypes through an association analysis on a set of 259 assembled, non-correlating DGRP phenotypes. We found multiple significant associations with stress- and metabolism-related phenotypes, including food intake in males. We validated the latter observation by reciprocal swapping of mitochondrial genomes from high food intake DGRP lines to low food intake ones. In conclusion, our study uncovered important mitochondrial population structure and haplotype-specific metabolic variation in the DGRP, thus demonstrating the significance of incorporating mitochondrial haplotypes in geno-phenotype relationship studies.
BibTeX
@misc{bevers2018extensive,
  author = {R. Bevers and Maria Litovchenko and Adamandia Kapopoulou and Virginie Braman and Matthew R. Robinson and Johan Auwerx and Brian Hollis and Bart Deplancke},
  title = {{Extensive mitochondrial population structure and haplotype-specific phenotypic variation in the <i>Drosophila</i> Genetic Reference Panel}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/466771},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure