Extensive gene gain associated with adaptive evolution of poxviruses

Aoife McLysaght, Pierre Baldi, Brandon S. GautProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

Poxviruses, including the one that causes smallpox, have evolved by extensively gaining new genes, particularly within the "orthopox" lineage. This gene gain, coupled with evidence of positive selection on many of these genes, suggests a dynamic process of adaptive evolution driven by host-parasite interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how genomes evolve is crucial for comprehending the diversity of life and the emergence of diseases. However, studying genome evolution has historically been hampered by the limited number of complete genomes available for comparison. This makes it difficult to infer the direction and rate of evolutionary changes, such as the gain or loss of genes, and to distinguish ancestral states from derived ones. Specifically, the authors aimed to investigate the patterns of genome content evolution across the Poxviridae family, a diverse group of double-stranded DNA viruses, and to explore whether these changes are linked to adaptive evolution.

Methods

The researchers employed a comparative genomics approach using complete genome sequences from 20 poxviruses.

  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They constructed a robust evolutionary tree (phylogeny) of the Poxviridae family using concatenated alignments of 34 highly conserved, single-copy genes found across all genomes. For the closely related orthopox viruses, they used a larger set of 92 orthologous genes to refine the tree. Both neighbor-joining (NJ) and maximum parsimony (MP) methods were used, with the NJ topology being favored due to higher bootstrap support.
  • Gene Family Definition: To analyze gene content, they defined gene families by clustering proteins with significant sequence similarity using an all-against-all BLASTP search. They developed a modified single-link clustering method to balance sensitivity and specificity in family identification.
  • Gene Gain and Loss Analysis: They inferred gene gain and loss events along each branch of the phylogenetic tree. The origin of a new family was assumed to be a single event, and gene loss was assigned parsimoniously. To assess the significance of these events, they used simulations where gene gain probabilities were proportional to branch lengths.
  • Selection Analysis: They calculated the ratio of nonsynonymous to synonymous substitution rates ($\omega$) for gene families with at least three members using the CODEML program. A $\omega > 1$ indicates positive selection, suggesting adaptive evolution.
  • Nonviral Homologue Identification: Poxvirus proteins were compared against the GenBank database to identify potential horizontally acquired genes from nonviral sources.

Datasets

The study utilized complete genome sequences from 20 poxviruses, obtained from GenBank. These included representatives from the entomopox, chordopox (further divided into orthopox, capripox, leporipox, molluscipox, avipox, and suipox genera), and yatapox groups. The protein sequences from these genomes were compiled into a dataset of 4,042 predicted proteins.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Genome Content is Dynamic, Structure is Stable: While the physical arrangement of genes (genome order) is remarkably conserved within the chordopox clade, the actual gene content varies significantly between poxvirus lineages.
  • Gene Gain is Not Uniform: The rate at which poxviruses acquire new genes is not constant over evolutionary time. Notably, the orthopox lineage (which includes the smallpox and vaccinia viruses) shows a significantly increased rate of gene acquisition.
  • Horizontal Gene Transfer is a Major Driver: A substantial portion of poxvirus genes show similarity to nonviral genes, strongly suggesting that horizontal gene transfer from other organisms has played a critical role in shaping poxvirus genomes.
  • Adaptive Evolution is Evident: A disproportionately high number of genes within the orthopox clade are under positive selection ($\omega > 1$). This indicates that these genes are evolving adaptively, likely in response to pressures from their hosts.
  • Host-Parasite Coevolution is Likely: The genes showing evidence of positive selection and the increased rate of gene gain in the orthopox lineage are often associated with virulence, host immune evasion, or other host-parasite interactions, pointing to coevolutionary arms races.

Key Results

  • The study identified 875 gene families across the 20 poxvirus genomes.
  • Gene order is highly conserved within chordopox genomes, with fowlpox being a notable exception.
  • Gene gain and loss events are common throughout poxvirus evolution.
  • The orthopox clade exhibits a statistically significant excess of gene gain events compared to other lineages.
  • Of the 204 gene families tested for selection, 26 showed evidence of positive selection ($\omega > 1$).
  • Significantly, 50% (13 out of 26) of the gene families under positive selection were found exclusively within the orthopox clade. This is a much higher proportion than in gene families not limited to the orthopox clade.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Bias: The authors acknowledge that the overrepresentation of orthopox genomes in their dataset could potentially influence the observed patterns of gene gain. They performed analyses to mitigate this, but it remains a consideration.
  • Inferring Gene Loss: While gene gain events could be simulated, inferring gene loss events is more complex as they depend on prior gain and loss events.
  • Horizontal Transfer Detection: The identification of nonviral homologues is limited by the completeness of the GenBank database. A lack of a hit does not definitively rule out horizontal transfer.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that the genes identified as being under positive selection and those acquired in the orthopox clade are prime candidates for further investigation into their roles in virulence, host adaptation, and potential targets for antiviral therapies. Understanding the specific environmental or host pressures driving these adaptive changes in the orthopox lineage is also a key area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies of genome evolution usually have involved one or two genomes and have thus been limited in their ability to detect the direction and rate of evolutionary change. Here, we use complete genome data from 20 poxvirus genomes to build a robust phylogeny of the Poxviridae and to study patterns of genome evolution. We show that, although there has been little gene order evolution, there are substantial differences between poxviruses in terms of genome content. Furthermore, we show that the rate of gene acquisition is not constant over time and that it has increased in the orthopox lineage (which includes smallpox and vaccinia). We also tested for positive selection on 204 groups of genes and show that a disproportionately high proportion of genes in the orthopox clade are under positive selection. The association of an increased rate of gene gain and positive selection is indicative of adaptive genome evolution. Many of the genes involved in these processes are likely to be associated with host-parasite coevolution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mclysaght2003extensive,
  author = {Aoife McLysaght and Pierre Baldi and Brandon S. Gaut},
  title = {{Extensive gene gain associated with adaptive evolution of poxviruses}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2136653100},
}
Figure