Extending the Theory of Planned Behavior to Explain the Effects of Cognitive Factors across Different Kinds of Green Products

Leibao Zhang, Yanli Fan, Wenyu Zhang, Shuai ZhangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study extends the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) to understand consumer purchase intentions for different types of green products (utilitarian vs. hedonic). It finds that while attitude and perceived behavioral control are key drivers for both, subjective norms are more influential for utilitarian products. Notably, environmental concern positively impacts purchase intention for both, but more strongly for utilitarian green products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The growing urgency of sustainable development has led to increased academic interest in green consumption. While the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) is a common framework for studying purchase intentions, most research treats "green products" as a monolithic category. This overlooks potential differences in how consumers approach and decide to purchase different types of green products, such as those driven by practical needs (utilitarian) versus those driven by pleasure or aesthetics (hedonic). This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how TPB constructs, along with environmental concern, influence purchase intentions for these distinct categories of green products.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), specifically component-based SEM via SmartPLS 2.0. This method is suitable for predictive modeling and smaller sample sizes. They developed a questionnaire with 7-point Likert scales to measure latent variables, drawing items from established literature. The study tested an extended TPB model that included "environmental concern" as an additional cognitive factor. They then analyzed the direct and indirect effects of these constructs on purchase intentions for two specific types of green products: energy-efficient household appliances (utilitarian) and organic clothing (hedonic).

Datasets

The study collected data through an online survey conducted in the Southern region of China. A total of 223 valid samples were obtained after outlier removal. The sample was characterized by a high proportion of participants with bachelor's degrees or higher (96.14%), reflecting a demographic that is often more engaged with environmental issues.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Green Products Aren't Monolithic: Consumers don't approach all "green" products the same way. The distinction between utilitarian (practical) and hedonic (pleasure-seeking) green products is crucial for understanding purchase drivers.
  • Attitude is King (Mostly): A positive attitude towards green products is a strong predictor for both utilitarian and hedonic purchases, consistently showing a higher effect than other TPB constructs.
  • Subjective Norms Matter Differently: While subjective norms (social pressure) significantly influence the intention to buy organic clothing (hedonic), they have a negligible impact on purchasing energy-efficient appliances (utilitarian).
  • Environmental Concern is a Broad Driver: Environmental concern directly and positively influences attitude, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control, thereby indirectly boosting purchase intentions for both product types.
  • Cognitive Factors Lean Utilitarian: Environmental concern has a greater direct impact on the purchase intention for utilitarian green products compared to hedonic ones.

Key Results

  • TPB Constructs:
    • Attitude and Perceived Behavioral Control positively and significantly influenced purchase intention for both energy-efficient appliances and organic clothing.
  • Subjective Norms positively and significantly influenced purchase intention for organic clothing but had an insignificant effect on energy-efficient appliances.
  • Environmental Concern:
    • Positively and significantly affected attitude, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control.
  • Directly and positively influenced purchase intention for both energy-efficient appliances (coefficient 0.23) and organic clothing (coefficient 0.13).
  • The direct effect of environmental concern was higher for utilitarian green products (appliances) than hedonic green products (clothing).
  • Showed similar indirect effects on purchase intention for both product types.
  • Hypotheses: Most hypotheses were supported, with the exception of H3a (Subjective Norms → Purchase Intention for Energy Efficient Household Appliances).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Product Classification: The study used only two categories (utilitarian and hedonic) and specific examples (appliances, clothing). Future research could explore other classifications (e.g., nature-based, industrialized) and a wider range of products.
  • Cognitive Factors: "Environmental concern" was the sole cognitive factor examined. Future work could investigate other factors like "environmental knowledge" and their differential effects.
  • Sample Size and Scope: While the sample size met the requirements for PLS-SEM, a larger and more diverse sample across different regions, occupations, and age groups could enhance generalizability.
  • Cross-Cultural Comparisons: Future research could compare green consumption patterns between different countries (e.g., China and the USA).
  • Moderating Effects: The study focused on direct and indirect effects. Future research could explore moderating effects of environmental concern on purchase intention.
  • Additional Concepts: Other influential concepts like "belief" and "value" could be incorporated into future models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sustainable development is a powerful impetus to achieve the coordination between economic advancement and environmental protection. Therefore, the promotion and adoption of green consumption has attracted increasing attention from academics. As an important tool for multivariate data analyses, structural equation modelling has been extensively used in purchase intention for green products. However, most previous research has recognized green products as a general class when studying their purchase intention, which focused little attention on comparing purchase intention for different kinds of green products. This study extends and tests the theory of planned behavior (TPB) and includes another cognitive construct, that is, environmental concern, to explore purchase intention for different kinds of green products. First, the effect of TPB constructs was examined on purchase intention for utilitarian green products and hedonic green products. Second, a cognitive factor, that is, environmental concern, was used to test its different effects on these two kinds of green products. Third, the indirect effect of environmental concern on purchase intention was measured for these two kinds of green products. The study showed that extended TPB constructs, that is, attitude, perceived behavior control, and environmental concern positively and significantly affected purchase intention for both utilitarian green products and hedonic green products, while subjective norm only significantly and positively affected purchase intention for utilitarian green products. Moreover, the cognitive factor, that is, environmental concern, had a higher effect on purchase intention for utilitarian green products than purchase intention for hedonic green products, and it also had a similar indirect effect on both kinds of green products. This study provides an insight to policymakers, entrepreneurs, and marketers into how to increase purchase intention for different kinds of green products.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019extending,
  author = {Leibao Zhang and Yanli Fan and Wenyu Zhang and Shuai Zhang},
  title = {{Extending the Theory of Planned Behavior to Explain the Effects of Cognitive Factors across Different Kinds of Green Products}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11154222},
}
Figure