Introduction
In Topological Data Analysis (TDA), persistent homology is used to track the evolution of topological features—such as components, loops, and voids—as a filtration of a space changes. A common scenario involves analyzing the sub-level sets of a real-valued function $f$ defined on a manifold. A natural theoretical question is how the persistence diagram of $f$ relates to the diagram of its negation, $-f$. This relationship is governed by the Symmetry Theorem.
The Symmetry Problem
The original work on this topic aimed to use Poincaré and Lefschetz duality to show that the persistence diagrams of $f$ and $-f$ are essentially mirror images. However, the initial publication contained calculation errors in the proof of the Symmetry Theorem. This erratum provides the necessary corrections, establishing the precise formulas for how different types of persistence (Ordinary, Extended, and Relative) transform under function negation.
Mathematical Framework
The authors consider a real-valued function $f$ on a $d$-manifold, typically represented via a triangulation as a simplicial complex $K$. The core of the analysis involves:
- Function Negation: Comparing the persistence of sub-level sets of $f$ with those of $-f$ (which correspond to super-level sets of $f$).
- Duality: Applying Poincaré and Lefschetz duality to relate the homology of the manifold to its cohomology. This allows for a mapping between the "birth" and "death" of topological features across complementary dimensions.
- Geometric Reflections: Two specific transformations are defined for points $(x, y)$ in a persistence diagram:
- Reflection $R$: Across the minor diagonal, mapping $(x, y) \to (-y, -x)$.
- Reflection $0$: Through the origin, mapping $(x, y) \to (-x, -y)$.
The Corrected Symmetry Theorem
The key insight of the correction is that symmetry is dimension-dependent and varies by the "flavor" of persistence being measured. The relationship between $f$ and $-f$ is not a simple swap; the dimension $r$ of the features shifts based on the manifold's dimension $d$.
The corrected identities for a real-valued function $f$ on a $d$-manifold are:
- Ordinary Persistence: $\text{Ord}_r(f) = \text{Ord}^R_{d-r-1}(-f)$
- Extended Persistence: $\text{Ext}_r(f) = \text{Ext}^0_{d-r}(-f)$
- Relative Persistence: $\text{Rel}_r(f) = \text{Rel}^R_{d-r+1}(-f)$
While Ordinary and Relative persistence require a reflection across the minor diagonal ($R$), Extended persistence requires a reflection through the origin ($0$).
Conclusion
This erratum provides the exact "dictionary" needed to translate topological features between a function and its negative. By fixing these foundational formulas, the authors ensure that theoretical stability results and computational pipelines in TDA are mathematically sound. This distinction between reflections is particularly crucial for researchers implementing these algorithms in software, where precise indexing and dimensional shifts are paramount.
Summary updated